Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

Posts

ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#1

ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

Ed Moore

>Last year at Louisville I saw the ROBUST lathe that Brent English had on display at the AAW Symposium. I checked out the Tilt-Away tailstock feature thoroughly and was really impressed with the quality of the construction and the thought that went into the design. As many of you know, I purchased a ROBUST 25 x 18 with 3 HP that arrived in late September of 2006.

I wrote an extremely favorable report on the lathe after I had had it a little while, promising to write a follow-up after I had a chance for some heavier work. This is that follow-up. And I am still as positive about the lathe now as I was earlier. I have used the McNaughton coring system and the lathe did fine. Any problem was related to the operator, not the lathe. [grin] I have put some heavy pieces of red oak on the lathe and it handled them as well as could be expected. If I continue to make large red oak bowls than it would be prudent to add some weight - which would also be the case if I had a Oneway 2436 or Stubby 750.

I still think the Tilt-Away feature for the tailstock is a brilliant solution to the heavy tailstock problem. After 9 months of use the Tilt-Away ways are still aligned perfectly. This is a great feature.

The lathe cannot be started when the spindle lock is engaged. And this feature has prevented many errors on my part.

Brent has designed a new tool-rest with the small round bar glued on the upper edge. This bar is harder than the usual soft steel and does not mar easily. He was also extremely clever and changed the shape of the rest so that you can get a steeper angle with a tool. I recommend this rest to anyone whose lathe has a 1" post.

My conclusion after 9 months is that I absolutely made the best choice of a lathe for me when I selected the ROBUST 25 x 18. I feel that overall it is as good as any other lathe and it has a few features that give it a definite edge. Did I mention the stainless steel ways - they come standard on the ROBUST? Wet red oak can do a number on the ways of a lathe - but not mine. I endorse this lathe enthusiastically.

Earlier, I issued an invitation to come to my shop near Roanoke, Virginia, and test-drive the ROBUST if you are considering one. (John Lucas, when will you be here?)

If you are in Portland, PLEASE stop by the ROBUST booth and tell Brent that Ed Moore sent you. [grin]

Ed

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#2

Sigh......

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>After using a lathe at ACC with a sliding headstock, it makes my love affair with the General seem sort of pale :( I do love my lathe, but yearn for a more comfortable way to hollow out bowls and hollow forms.

If I had a million dollars.........

:)

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#3

Dick Hines

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

Dick Hines

>The ROBUST was not on the market when I get by PM 3520 but I think I would have still done with the PM. I will say I have never seen a ROBUST lathe. I some times turn from the back side and wonder if the tail stock gets in the way.

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#4

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

john lucas

>Ed I'm still drooling over the Robust but I've bought several cars and motorcylces that were less expensive. Of course that goes for the Stubby and Oneway as well. When I bought the Powermatic it was all I could afford (and difficult at that) Worth every penny as I'm sure the Robust is also. I'm still saving my pennies. One never knows.

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#5

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

Ed Moore

>Dick,

Bob Rosand is left-handed and often works on the back side of the lathe. I showed him how the tail-stock can rotate forward or backwards, depending on your druthers. The Tilt-Away is a great feature.

Ed

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#6

PM3520 comment

Ed Moore

>Dick, I think that the PM3520 gives a lot of bang for the buck. I recently assisted Bob Rosand at the John C Campbell Folk School where they have a lot of Powermatics. I did a sea urchin ornament demo and turned on a PM3520 for the first time. At some point I immediately discovered a real difference between the PM and the ROBUST. The PM headstock is large and makes access from the headstock side more difficult. I applaud the ROBUST, Oneway, Stubby, and Vicmarc because they have each designed a headstock that gives easier access on the headstock side than does the PM3520. I'm not knocking the PM, just noting that there is a noticeable difference in this one area.

Ed

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#7

Dick Hines

Re: PM3520 comment

Dick Hines

>You are right Ed the head stock is large. I don't turn small things on my PM so it has not been to much trouble. I have a Jet mini I use for small trunings.

I would like to try a Robust but no one in our club has one and there are no dealers around Richmond that sell them.

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#8

large headstock

john lucas

>That's both a pro and con. When I first got the lathe it bugged me that the headstock was so large. Now I find that I use that feature. I have a magnetic light that sits there. I use the magnet to hold things and of course the light to help illuminate. When doing small production work I often have my bottle of lacquer up there along with application rags. I noticed on the 3520B they have made this a storage area by adding rubber. I guess it's one of those things that you either love or hate.

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#9

Re: large headstock

Russ Fairfield

>You can easilly solve the access problem from the latge headstock for about $60. That is the price of a same size adapter that will move the chuck or faceplate 3" away from the headstock.

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#10

ROBUST in Virginia

Ed Moore

>Dick, I am in Burnt Chimney, which is between Rocky Mount and Bedford, and my offer to test drive the ROBUST is still open. I am about two hours west of Richmond and am easy to find - Tom Crabb had no difficulty finding our home.

C'mon over,

Ed

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

#11

Re: ROBUST lathe impressions - Part II (long)

georgetroy

>Ed is right. Turning on the Robust is great. I'm also using the new tool rest with the round top of harden steel. I just turned on a friends PM this morning and his rest was all beat up with nicks and dents. However I'm lucky, I have the Robust, PM 3520, 2 Vicmarcs, DVR, Avon and a Shopsmith. Lathe Junkie here. GT