Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

FIRE!!

Posts

FIRE!!

#1

FIRE!!

Dave Winters

>Had a fire in the workshop last night!

I was sawing up some bowl blanks, and my dust collector caught afire.

I'm suspecting it was from the ceramic guides on my Laguna LT-18 bandsaw sparking. I do see sparks, very infrequently from them which I've been told is normal with ceramic guides. But upon thinking about it, I can't see the bottom guides, and they could be sparking like crazy if they got out of alignment and you wouldn't see it.

So I'm sawing away and my eyes started burning, and I'm thinking I got too much sun. It gets worse and then I realise I'm smelling smoke.

I look at the dust collector and the bottom bag has a hole in it and it's spewing smoke and flame. Run and get the extigusher and empty it on it. Then realise, "You idiot, turn off the collector!!" Now the smoke is so bad I can't breathe. Call 911. Run upstairs screaming bloody murder to get the wife, kids and dog out. Run back into the basement with the garden hose. Smoke is way too bad.

F.D. comes pronto, puts it out right away, damage is limited to the dust collector and an air hose reel. Very very lucky.

Dumb questions:

-Ever hear of this type of issue with ceramic bandsaw guides?

-I think I'll take the ceramic guides off this saw if for nothing else than peace of mind. What other guides can I get for this saw??

-I'm scared to report it to my ins. co. for fear of them wanting me to carry a lot more coverage, or that they will cancel me outright and close me down. I do sell my wares, have a city and state tax i.d., website, etc. Maybe I should carry more coverage..

All in all I feel very fortunate. One can always say,"It could have been a lot worse", but still...

I'll post some pics in a few days.

-Dave Winters

Re: FIRE!!

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: FIRE!!

Steve Kubien

>Glad to hear you are alright and no one was hurt. Can't help you with the ceramic guide but I've heard of many people who make their own guides out of small pieces of oily, waxy wood like lignum vitae.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: FIRE!!

#3

Re: FIRE!!

Wilford Bickel

>When I put my shop in at the farm the agent told me as long as it was hobby and used to repair things on the farm it would be covered but if I started selling goods then I would have to get commercial insurance to cover the shop. Realize that had your house burned down the insurance company could legally refuse to pay for the house if they find out you are in business and have not declared it to them. With a website, etc. they would find out. AAW has a professional insurance available - don't know all the details on it but you may want to check into it. I would be making sure I was covered on the house with the business you are running out of the shop. I have seen many dust collector fires in the textile mills over the years - all it takes is one spark to get the dust set off so you may be right about your saw sparking. You can cut guides out of Lignum Vitae to replace the ceramic. My small 9 Inch Delta bench top band saw came with a graphite impregnated plastic type of guide and I have never seen a spark off of them. You are very lucky!!!

Re: FIRE!!

#4

don't connect a vac hose to a

TDaniel

>grinder either. Same thing can happen. I had a shop vac catch on fire once. The tiniest spark can be fanned into a fire in seconds. Usually the dust will just smolder for a while but if you have any shavings in the can it is another matter. All I lost was a paper filter.

Re: FIRE!!

#5

Re: FIRE!!

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>Dave,

Glad you and your family are ok!

I have a basement shop and had been thinking about installing some kind of fire suppressant system, maybe I'll just have it put in now!

Take care,

Rick

Re: FIRE!!

#6

Re: FIRE!!

John Leonard

>I have State Farm and I contacted my agent about getting coverage changed since I sell a few things. He contacted State farm and they won't cover any wood working operation. I went with the AAW insurance which is expensive but cheap if I have a fire compared to no coverage. My shop is separate from the house so I have no idea how you would cover a shop in the house. John L.

Re: FIRE!!

#7

Re: FIRE!!

Carole Valentine

>John,

I heard somewhere along the line that AAW won't cover your shop if you have certain equipment in there, like a table saw. Is this true? Not to be nosey, but when you say "expensive" - how expensive? More expensive than commercial insurance through other companies?

Re: FIRE!!

#8

Re: FIRE!!

robo hippy

>I have the Laguna 16 HD with the ceramic guides, and the sparking makes me nervous. After watching the sparks go into shavings that build up on the guides when I don't clean out the saw often enough, I noticed that they don't even scorch, and I have 2 years and 100 plus hours of sawing time. Most of the time the wood is wet. I would call Laguna and ask them. I have never heard of this happening before. The sparks from the ceramic guides are supposed to be cool. I don't know if someething else in the dust collector could have caused it or not.

robo hippy

Re: FIRE!!

#9

Re: FIRE!!

Dave Winters

>Thanks all for the responses.

Robo - Yeah, I emailed Laguna, haven�t heard back yet. Do you use dust collection on your 16? I�m wondering if the added draft of the suction could fan the flames. I don�t know much about metallurgy and sparks, but isn�t a spark something red hot?

The wood I was sawing was totally wet, so I can�t imagine it was that. Could have been a rock or barbed wire, both of which I hit with my chainsaw when I was roughing.

I have called my insurance co. and I'm scared to death what will happen because of it all, but I generally do what the little guy on my shoulder says, so...

Keep you posted.

Re: FIRE!!

#10

Re: FIRE!!

George Van

>Hey Dave, glad to hear the fire was not worse. We had a large fire once and it was a mess after the fire and a mess and a lot of work to get things replaced and back to normal. I will be cautious now with the vacuum on the bandsaw!

Re: FIRE!!

#11

Re: FIRE!!

Allen Neighbors

>Robo, I've been a firefighter for over 18 years, and I don't know that I've ever seen a cool spark. If they told you that, they're wrong.

Sparks plus dust equals danger. I would think that if ceramic guides make sparks, they would be pulled off the market by some 'ralphnadertype'. I'd opt for the Lignum Vitae.

Re: FIRE!!

#12

Re: FIRE!!

Bob Fawcett

>Glad everyone is alright.

I don't know about wood dust, but many types of dust and a spark can be explosive. I've read news stories about explosions in grain elevators becasue of the dust. I also know that sugar dust can be explosive. I would think that wood dust as fine as we can make with sanding could also be explosive. I would rather replace guides often than recreate your fire, or worse with something that makes sparks.

Re: FIRE!!

#13

Re: FIRE!!

john lucas

>Dave-glad your OK. I almost had a fire yesterday. I had weak hot water and went down to check on it. I turned off the power and took my meter down. I was getting funny readings on the thermostat and smelled burnt electrical wires. I turned on the power and went back down stairs to take some more meter readings and there was fire coming out of the thermostat. I rushed up to turn off the power and grab the fire extinguisher. I was able to just blow it out after the power was removed. It turned out there as a water leak at the top and it was running down on the thermostat shorting it out.

Re: FIRE!!

#14

Re: FIRE!!

eliot d

>I also use a Laguna HD 16 with ceramic guides. I am very interested in what Laguna has to say about all this. They should be worried about law suits.

Re: FIRE!!

#15

Re: FIRE!!

John Kyler

>Is it possible that your chips are decaying like compost and it caused spontaneous combustion from Pyrolysis?

John

Re: FIRE!!

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: FIRE!!

keith tompkins

>Dave, I'm surprised that an expensive saw such as your laguna has ceramic guides...I'd swith over to a roller setup.

Re: FIRE!!

#17

Re: FIRE!!

robo hippy

>Dave,

I do have an Oneida 3hp dust collector, so lost of air going by. As an after thought, I wonder if it would have been better to send the fire extinguisher down the dust collector hose, rather than hit your bag with it. I would like to hear what Laguna has to say also. My other saw (PM 14 inch industrial) has roller bearings, and I like the ceramic guides a lot better, unless they do start fires.

robo hippy

Re: FIRE!!

#18

Re: FIRE!!

Gary Ratajczak

>I have a Jet 14" with a riser block. I purchased ceramic guides when I got the saw. On tight radius turns, they spark also. What i believe happens is that the ceramic guide actually starts cutting (albeit minimal) into the side of the blade when you stress it on a sharp curve.

Were you cutting round bowl blanks? The guides are made for smooth contact on the sides of the blade.

I too was nervous about aparks in the colelctor, and always take out the bag if I have been cutting anything that has caused sparks.

Have not yet installed yet, but I have a new set of Carter guides. They should take care of all the spark issues.

Also, be sure that the guides are not set ahead of the blade gullets. Again, if you are cutting straight it's usually not a problem. On a tight curve, the gullet can actually hit the ceramic guide if it is flexed to the side.

As already mentioned, glad you caught it in time!!! I am going to start replacing my smoke detectors with the integrated units. i believe Lowes offers them. If one goes off, they all go off. Starting with the shop and the bedroom.

Re: FIRE!!

#19

Re:There is no such thing as ....

Jamie Donaldson

>.... a cool spark! I have roller bearings on my new (2 yr old) MiniMax and I don't like them as well as the cool blocks I had on my old Delta saw. They pack with wood junk and bind against the blade, and they are noisy! I haven't been able to find any suitable guide replacements, but I'm still looking!

Re: FIRE!!

#20

Re: FIRE!!

Bill Hale

>Hey all

Consider the system I use. I know this will not work in the winter for many of you but the summer is ok.

By pass the collection bags, when you can, and vent directly outside. I blow mine out on to the ground away from the shop.

You can also keep the pile wet and make good compost

As always good turning and be safe.

Bill in Show Low, AZ.

Re: FIRE!!

#21

Really scary stuff

mike foster

>Speaking from experience, this really scares me. It is good to hear that the fire was limited to just the collector, you were really lucky. I had a fire 5 years ago in which we lost about 1/3 of our house. This was not a shop related fire, but no fire is a fun experience. We were fortunate that our damage was confined to a part of the house that was to be renovated anyway, and none of our family hierloom antics were in that part of the house.

I also have a Laguna bandsaw with the ceramic guides that is hooked up to an Oneida dust collection system. My shop is in an old barn with the dust collector in a room in the basement under the shop. It has an open grill into the shop, so smoke would be apparent in the shop should a fire happen, but this scenario scares the crap out of me. I am going to buy the AAW insurance and am waiting with baited breath regarding the answer from Laguna.

Dave, please post a follow-up if you do receive any feedback from Laguna. I hate to say it, but my experience with the support from Laguna has been less than satisfactory, and I'll be really surprised if you get any feedback at all.

Re: FIRE!!

#22

Re: FIRE!! *LINK*

E.T.

>If these ceramic blocks are sparking I would change them to cool blocks LDQ. Here is a link to the cool block upgradee on the laguna site. ET

http://www.lagunatools.com/ProductImageGallery.asp?ProductID=190&GalleryItem=1


http://www.lagunatools.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=190

Re: FIRE!!

#23

Re: FIRE!!

tm

>Like everyone else I'm glad youre okay Dave.

I'm shopping for a bandsaw now.

Thanks to all for the info.

tm

Re: FIRE!!

#24

Re: FIRE!!

don lewonczyk

>Dave,im no expert but when you pile up wet wood shavings and somewhere I read that it could cause a fire.It goes through a heat just like hay thats baled a little wet. I might expect a spark to start a fire on dry wood shavings but not wet wood. Even a compost pile goes through a heat cycle and it could catch fire. Mine use to smolder all the time. You suppied the air to fuel the heated wet wood with the dust collecter just like a blacksmith uses his forge with his bellows to super heat the coals. I don't know about anyone else but I get wet wood shavings that pile up around the lathe out of the shop and spread it out so it can't heat up. Same thing with oily rags from finishing turnings,I either put them in an air tight container are spread them out to dry and then dispose of them. Try a pieace of flint to a pile of wet wood and try to start a fire, it might happen but only if you got alot of lung behind the spark. Call me crazy but thats my take on it and I doubt your guides had anything to do with the cause of your fire. Good Luck DonL

Re: FIRE!!

#25

Re: FIRE!!

Dave Winters

>Had a few people saying it could have been from the wet wood shavings and spontaneous compustion. May be possible but I don't think so in my case. When I post the pics you'll see a place inside the bottom door of the bandsaw where the fire started. It's all charred there.

No word back from Laguna yet.

Thanks so much for all the kind words..

-Dave