Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

Posts

A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

#1

A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

Gordon Seto

>I bought this A-11 steel 1�� wide, 5/16� thick negative rake scraper (NRS) blank from Doug Thompson. It was fresh back from the heat and cryogenic treatment before cleaning up, polishing and grinding. I need to lay my hand on this batch; there may be nothing left when Doug takes them to the Portland Symposium.

I saw Stuart Batty used the NRS to get a silky finish cut on the inside of tall and narrow bowl demo. Any idea on what the top and bottom grinding angles are?

I also got the skew. It took a lot of effort to clean up and grind. If I knew what I know now. I would have Doug ship me the completed skew.

Gordon


img

Re: A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

#2

Re: A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

DickAnderson

>Gordon:

I have a skew chisel that I use as a negative rake scraper and the cutting edge is ground to 40-degrees. Therefore, I can use it with the blade in either position on the rest. For that 40-degree cutting edge each face is ground at 20-degrees off horizontal. The skew I use as a negative rake is an oval skew, which I didn't like, but works fine as a negative rake. The blade is down to less than 3-inch length now.

For the negative rake scrapers I have made (several), that I don't want it to be used with only one side of the blade up then I grind the top side at about 20-degrees off horizontal (angle not too critical) and the bottom face at about the same as a regular scraper, that is about 70-degrees (again the degree is not too critical.

Hope this is somewhat clear and helpful.

Dick

Re: A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

#3

Re: A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

Wilford Bickel

>The Spring 2006 issue of American Woodturner has an article by Stuart that gives details and the various angles that work with the negative rake scraper. Measured from the top cut to the bottom (like this - >)angles will work from 45 degrees to 75 degrees. I have been using about 70 degrees with great success - I grind the bottom angle at 45 degrees and the top is ground off to make the 70. The really important part of NRS is to make sure you have a good burr.

Re: A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

#4

Re: A-11 steel Negative Rake Scraper Grinding

Gordon Seto

>Thanks, I am going to look the article up. It just didn't register when the A-11 wasn't available to me then.

I know this group is resourceful.

Gordon