Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

Posts

Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#1

Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Here is an interesting exercise. Go to the refrigerator or grocery store and get a carton or two of eggs. Lay them all out and look at them carefully.

Are any two eggs the same shape?

Do any of them have that "perfect" egg shape?

None of mine were the same and none of them had that "perfect" egg shape.

So where did the idealized "perfect" shape come from?

And why do we worry about the idealized shape when chickens obviously don�t.

This lesson has been presented to me in several different ways over the last couple of years.

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#2

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

Curt Fuller

>A while back I turned a batch of eggs for a display for the Ogden Nature Center. My daughter was building the display and gave me the dimensions and shapes for the various eggs. She also did the painting. But you're absolutely right, there is no real defined shape for an egg.


img

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#3

"Perfect" Egg diagram *LINK*

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I ran across this a while ago. The Woodturners Guild of North Carolina has some handouts from a Darren Grozy demo on turning an egg-shaped box. One of them is "The Perfect Egg". It's the second item down on the page in the link below.


Woodturners Guild of NC handout page

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: "Perfect" Egg diagram

keith tompkins

>Brian, the "perfect egg", if nothing else, is a good goal to shoot for when turning and studying shapes. Eggs have an attractive shape, and are worth emulating. Notice the organic curves...they apply to all types of turning, not just turning eggs. The egg shape can also be divided into two separate bowl forms, both successful on their own. Like fingerprints or snowflakes, no two eggs are exactly alike, but they aren't exactly created as art either. I think if you asked 100 turners to each turn a perfect egg not one would be the same.

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#5

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

Troy German

>I don't have anything to add. I just wanted to let you know that I found this little thread interesting. Thanks for starting it.

Troy

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#6

There is an error in the diagram

Ed Moore

>The diagram, as drawn works and it produces a good egg. The error is in the statement that the Golden Ratio is involved. For the small circle the radius used is "cx" or 2-sqrt(2) which is approximately .585. That would make the ratio of the radii of the circles 1 : 1.707108 which is NOT 1 : 1.618034 as claimed. Plain and simple, the Golden Ratio is not involved in this computation anywhere.

Close, but no cigar.

Ed

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#7

Re: "Perfect" Egg diagram

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#8

Re: "Perfect" Egg diagram

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Keith,

That approach is popular and certainly has merit. I once heard an actor and blues guitarist pass along this concept: In music, master a piece and then no matter how you improvise, it will be true to the piece. Similarly in acting, once you drop into character, what ever you do will be true to that character. I think the same is true for turning an egg. Master the "ideal" egg shape and then you can improvise and it still will be a good egg.

The other point of view says that if you want to make an egg, make a real egg and not a theoretical egg. Don't get hung up on the "ideal" shape because that isn't the way real eggs look.

Some people learn better by one path, others by the other path. However, I suspect that both paths converge after several hundred eggs.

I chose the egg example because I went through exactly that exercise when I made my first eggs. However, the principle or dichotomy applies to anything that has an organic reality as well as a theoretical ideal.

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#9

Re: There is an error in the diagram

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Fortunately that's not my diagram, so at least I don't have egg on my face! ;=))

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#10

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Thanks Troy.

I hope others found it interesting as well.

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#11

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

eaglesc

>The perfectegg(s)

go into an omlete with everyting but Jalapenos.

Everything else is just a copy of what cannot be be duplicated.

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

#12

Re: Real Eggs vs. the "Perfect" Egg

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>The ideal egg in my mind has a continuous curve from one end to the other, one end being a smaller radius than the other with the broadest part being a little off center. Proportions of width to length may vary, but it'e the continuous, "fair" curve that I find to be most appealing. The chicken seems to come closer than other birds, as seen in Curt's picture showing some really pointy eggs with fat bottoms.

Here's a pic I posted on WoW a couple years ago, of an egg from my fridge:


img