Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

first two new finials

Posts

first two new finials

#1

first two new finials

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>A few days ago I posted some questions about adding a finial to a short lidded box I had turned from catalpa.

Well, I took the suggestions I got and turned these two finials from blackwood. My new question is, which looks best and why?

I am mainly interested in knowing if I am headed in the right direction with my thought process.

Thanks in advance.

keithz


img

Re: first two new finials

#2

Re: first two new finials

ryker acuna

>I think the finial on the right has a better match to the box its sitting on. Because the box has rounded sloped lines it goes better with the lines of the right side finial. The other finial has sharper crisp lines to it which I feel contrasts with the flow of the box. To be more exact the smoother finial has the draw to me in the upper half, being the two bumps near the middle and top. This really tapers off the form and finishs the line. Just my thoughts really does'nt mean much but hope it helps. Ps Both finials are well done.

Re: first two new finials

#3

Re: first two new finials

GaryG in MD

>I agree with Ryker for the same reason.

My further reaction to the one on the right, that he and I prefer to the other, is that I think I would like to see it not quite so "fat". I think it would be more attractive if it were slimmed down a bit. Just my two cents. ...Gary

Re: first two new finials

#4

Bill Blasic

Re: first two new finials

Bill Blasic

>Keith,

I think they both are a little tall for the box they are on, for my eye they look better with the top third of the finial gone. The finials are well done but may be better suited to a taller piece.

Re: first two new finials

#5

Re: first two new finials

Gordon Seto

>I agree. The right is more pleasing.

I also agree that if the portion connecting the two onions is a tad slimmer, it would make the features stand out better.

Gordon

Re: first two new finials

#6

both.......

Ruth Niles

>Keith,

This is a perfect example of how the finial can alter the size of the vessel, in the mind's eye. The one on the left makes the vessel appear shorter and wider, the one on the right makes it appear more rounded and higher. NOT by much, almost "is it or isn't it more rounded/shorter/taller?"

Personally, I think they both work. I think we all decide if something is "pleasing" in 2 seconds, then we analyze or listen to others and see where the design needs tweeking.

Re: first two new finials

#7

Re: first two new finials

Ed Moore

>Keith,

You seem to be genuinely asking for help, so I feel an obligation to be honest in my response.

Neither.

I think that both are too tall for the shape of the lidded box. The rounded feature of the lid makes the crisp finial on the left seem out of place. The upper two-thirds of the finial on the right is chunky and the top is ill-defined. I wouldn't put a Drozda-like finial on either.

I think that a finial shapped like the Greek letter Pi (actually with a single curve, not a slight ogee) would look better. The lid sort of "hangs over", no problem, and a pull that reflects that may be better. A piece that has an oriental flavor is more appealing to me here.

Bob Rosand puts a "T" shaped finial on his small lidded box. The top is actually a twig. I think a "T" where the ends droop a little would look nice on your lidded bowls. The top piece should reflect the curve of the lid. I would not make the vertical component too long, maybe one-third the height of the current finials.

This is obviously a different approach and opinion than has been expressed above. And it is just that, an opinion.

Ed

Re: first two new finials

#8

"shaped", and lidded "boxes"

Ed Moore

>

Re: first two new finials

#9

ebd

Re: first two new finials

ebd

>Like them both very much. On the right, I'd like it better if the bottom of the top "onion" were more sharply defined.

Re: first two new finials

#10

Re: first two new finials

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>First I would like to say that I am not a big fan of finials on simple forms as they tend to draw the eye away from the turning. Most finials (to my eye) tend to be the center of attention with the vessel being the adornment.

The left finial reminds me of a chess piece, then the more I look at it I see the Eiffel tower, then I see a pagoda shape. I think that it has become the center of attention because my mind is trying to equate the shape as it appears familiar.

The right finial while still drawing the eye away from the vessel, mimmicks the shape of the vessel on the bottom enough that the shape should be refined to match that of the vessel and then thinner above(my opinion).

I don't ever comment on design elements as I see things in a less artistic and more utilitarian eye than others do but the first impulse of chess piece was strong enough that I thought I would comment.

Re: first two new finials

#11

Re: first two new finials

Arch

>Hi Keith,

I think you've turned an attractive and useful box with a properly robust and secure lid. To me it seems just right for holding wallets, wrist watches and bracelets, not ear rings, cuff links and studs. IMHO, it needs a proper "top" to grab onto and lift the lid. This should complement both box & lid, but know its place and not upstage the leading characters. :)

I think this nice looking functional box wants a complementary no nonsense part for lifting the lid. It can take many shapes, but not an fragile or fussy finial. I vote for the 'third" finial, the one that's between the right and left.

Please understand that this is not an indictment of your finials. They are lovely, but I think they are keeping the wrong company. OTOH, if I misunderstood and this is an artistic hollow form with a miniscule opening and gossamer walls, please forgive. :)

Arch

Re: first two new finials

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: first two new finials

keith tompkins

>Keith, definitely the right finial. The left one has every feature I mentioned in my previous post that should be avoided....straight sections and v-shaped sections. Neither has anything to do with the smooth curves of the form it sits upon. If you study lots of finials, you'll notice many, many, finials just like the piece on the left. The right finial is a bit heavy , but a huge improvement over the left.

Re: first two new finials

#13

Thanks everyone

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>This is exactly what I was looking for. I appreciate everyone's comments and suggestions. I now have a lot of R & D and practicing to do.

This is what makes Wood Central what it is, an incredible source of information and knowledge.

keith

Re: first two new finials

#14

What? No argument? I expected ...

Ed Moore

>someone to tell me how stupid and wrong I was. C'mon! I am married - I can take abuse. Take your best shots. [grin]

Ed

Re: first two new finials

#15

Re: What? No argument? I expected ...

John Lucas

>Well I don't disagree, but don't totally agree either. I think sometimes the finial is the mainstay of the piece so it can be larger. I do think most finials are too thick. They need contrast between the large and small elements so a large bead should usually be followed by a fairly narrow cove. Think narrow waist and skinny neck on a woman vs hips and chest. OK I know that's getting sexist but we tend to think of things as masculine and feminine when it comes to form.

I think you are absolutely correct in your "T" assesment. A horizontal piece sitting on top of the box would accent the horizontal movement of the box. This box screams, I'm short and wide, and if you put a finial on it your trying to make it veritcal. Keep it horizontal looking by putting a "beam" or handle of sorts across the top possibly with a Japanese flair.

OK, Ed, that's about as mean as I can get. Don't hit me :)

Re: first two new finials

#16

Why argue?

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I asked for comments and reasons; I got comments and reasons. Exactly what I asked for. It's time for me to absorb and rethink.

Actually, Ed, your suggestion of a japanese styled handle is intreguing.

Again, I say thanks to everyone.

keith