Re: first two new finials
Ed Moore
>Keith,
You seem to be genuinely asking for help, so I feel an obligation to be honest in my response.
Neither.
I think that both are too tall for the shape of the lidded box. The rounded feature of the lid makes the crisp finial on the left seem out of place. The upper two-thirds of the finial on the right is chunky and the top is ill-defined. I wouldn't put a Drozda-like finial on either.
I think that a finial shapped like the Greek letter Pi (actually with a single curve, not a slight ogee) would look better. The lid sort of "hangs over", no problem, and a pull that reflects that may be better. A piece that has an oriental flavor is more appealing to me here.
Bob Rosand puts a "T" shaped finial on his small lidded box. The top is actually a twig. I think a "T" where the ends droop a little would look nice on your lidded bowls. The top piece should reflect the curve of the lid. I would not make the vertical component too long, maybe one-third the height of the current finials.
This is obviously a different approach and opinion than has been expressed above. And it is just that, an opinion.
Ed