Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

Posts

Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#1

Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

dwr

>I have two HD's, one with the OS and Program files and a larger one for data storage and backups. I am concerned that the HD with the OS and program files might be trying to tell me it wants to die.

So, I am looking for any "software" solution that will allow me to "accurately" move the current OS and Program Files (entire HD if need be) to the larger HD.

I have Win2000 Pro. I would prefer not to have to create a boot CD and reboot the system as that is where things seem to get dicy... but am open to any recommendations.

Thanks and holding my breath...!

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#2

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

Curly Smith

>It would be much easier (and safer) to copy to a new hard drive but if you really want all of your stuff on one drive then this is what I'd do:

NOTE: your data drive must be the same size or larger than the OS/program drive for the free mirror software to work.

Backup your data drive to CD, DVD or an external hard drive (my preference is both DVD and external HD). Your data drive will be overwritten by the mirror software, any existing data will be destroyed.

If you're using a Seagate or Western Digital drive you can visit their website and download drive tools that will allow you to mirror your existing program drive to the data drive. Otherwise, you can download this program:

HDClone Free Edition 3.2.8

Once you've mirrored the drive, disconnect the data cable from the old OS/program drive and connect it to the new OS/program drive. You should not connect the data cable to the old OS/program drive if your OS allows booting from the secondary hard drive. If in doubt, don't connect it.

Turn the PC on and verify that it will boot from the new OS/program drive. If the mirror software worked, it will. Test your programs to be sure they work. The vast majority will but you might have to reinstall a few.

If everything is OK you can reload your data from the backup.

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#3

Curly... I think I will...

dwr

>... get another HD and connect it to the ribbon cable with the Old OS drive. I will make the new drive a slave initially. I have Western Digitals Data Lifeguard program and will see if it allows me to copy over the old HD, otherwise, use the free-sharewares.

After doing the transfer, however I end up doing it, I will change the old HD to a non-bootable slave and set the new one to be the Master. If it boots well and the OS works, then I can check the programs and reinstall the 160Gig data drive as the slave and remove the old OS drive... hopefully.... Sound about right?

Thanks!

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#4

That's the easiest solution

Curly Smith

>The only programs I've seen that don't like being transferred with the WD program are from Symantec and a repair installation took care of the problem (it has to do with their copy protection scheme). The Windows OS ran perfectly (or at least as well as it did before) so hopefully you won't have any problems.

If you haven't run the WD drive diagnostics you might consider running them on the old drive AFTER you've transferred the data. You might just have a bad spot on the disk and an otherwise perfectly fine HD. The possible downside with running the test now, if you haven't already, is that you can kill a bad disk during a repair attempt. Once you've transferred the OS/programs, and the new HD works, you've got nothing to lose by attempting a repair. And it's nice to have a bootable standby HD on hand in case of a failure. The website for the freeware (majorgeeks.com) also has drive diagnostics that you can download.

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#5

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

Juergen

>What is telling you the drive wants to die? Kinda remind me of Johnny Carson when He put the envelope up to the Great Carsoni's forehead. If your drive is " Smart Drive" capable goto the manufacturers website or download.com and download and install a program that will read and interpret the smart drive diagnostic data. In fact all that you may need is to defragment the boot drive. Another point is that since you're running win 2K your system is at least 5 years old. Most likely a reinstall will solve 99% of any real or perceived problem. Because your data is on a separate drive the solution is pretty straight forward. Personally, I would reinstall the OS and programs and clean up the machine in the process. If you have the original restore disk it's eve simpler. A lot of my customers usually had bootleg software on their PCs which complicated the fix considerably.

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#6

ebd

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

ebd

>You would be far better served if you install the new drive in place of the old one and do a clean install of the OS and programs. Over time the registry becomes full of entries that are no longer valid. This not only slows the machine down but can contribute to instability. Getting an exact copy of the current version of the OS & programs carries this accumulated mess with it.

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#7

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

dwr

>Juergen,

The drive develops an intermittent high pitched whine with a bit of a "gravely" sound, like the bearing(s) might be getting ready to go. It only happens when the HD has to do any seeking or data transmission... When I reboot the system, Windows stops half way through and says that "one of the drives needs to be checked for consistency." I have been fortunate to get it back up but it took three attempts. So, I feel it is "hanging by a thread" so to speak.

I am open to your thoughts.

I am comfortable with the Win2000 Pro for a number of reasons and will not upgrade unless I am forced to for some reason beyond my control...

Thanks!

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#8

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

dwr

>Good points...

I keep it optimized and defragmented. Before the nasty noises started, it ran nice and speed was never an issue.

Guess my big issues are doing all the downloading of updates, patches, security fixes and rebooting associated with a complete reinstall of the OS onto a new drive (took me two days last time...), not to mention setting my Outlook e-mail account back up with my ISP, archiving all me e-mail messages, etc, etc...

Guess having a backup HD with the OS and Programs installed and updated, then stored away, would make this a lot more painless...

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#9

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>You have a lot of good options here. For myself I use Ghost 2003 for a mirror backup and restore if needed.

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#10

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

Fog Tanner

>Sounds like a bearing. If it is it could die in five minutes, days, months, or longer. I always assume worst case and do it now before it totally sizes up. My background is working with large IBM mainframe systems where backup and recovery are near and dear to the heart. Some of the same methodology I apply to my PCs (have a several).

The best backup we(several mainframe friends of mine) have found are docking bays for the tower or desk tops. These fit in the same size bay that the CD/DVD reside. They come with a caddy for mouting a normal size disk drive. These may be cabled on the secondary controller, depending on the brand you would have to adjust the jumper settings. Maxtor is the easiest and Western Digital is a little fussier. I don't use other brand as they have less than steller records, best results with them is to drill a hole through the case and platters then run a drywall screw through it to make sure you don't accidentally use it. I have a "other" brand that was given to me - it will never turn again -totally froze up without warning.

I have used a number of different pieces of software to copy the partitions over the years. For the majority of that time I have used Partition Magic and Drive Image. But their usablity and support has gone down over the years. I am still using V6 for my Windowz 98 systems and have a copy of Win2000 version for use on my Win2k system. I have had some issues with both and had to use one of my Linux systems to correct soem of the problems they created. If you don't run a multiboot manager, you probably would not have the same issues. I have used Ghost and it appears to work OK, but also has problems at times.

I continue to look for another piece of software for copying partitions. You really need to copy the partition asis, if you are running the NTFS or later file system. NT (win2k, xp) maintains its own directory and doesn't really care to have the partiton "shrunk" outsize of itself. Trust me on that :-) You can find a starting place for software on www.tucows.com. They have both windowz and Linux groups.

If you are a software jock, there are a number of opensource pieces of code for partition manipulation. But most are Linux based and require a little more knowledge than the basic windowz environment. But, they are real handy for fixing the logic failures of the various windowz utilities. The last thing I every use is the utilities that come with the harddrive. I have had to fix the problmes they create more than I have been able to find them usefull.

Since you already have a good plan of keeping data on a seperate drive. I would suggest that you have a partition on that drive for your apps and leave the OS(s) to your priamry drive. Most of the viruii that you get will hit the C drive. If you set the bootsector as protetcted on the secondary drive, it is pretty hard for them to trash the partition table on that volume. Then when you buy a drive, buy two one as a replacement for the failing drive and a second for backing up your two drives. I currently have fourteen drives for backing up five systems, plus a couple of spare for installing some new version of Linux or a test Wyndowz.

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#11

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

dwr

>Fog,

Thanks a bunch. That is quite a bite to chew but most of it makes good sense.

I think I will get a new drive and install it as the bootable master and load my Win2K Pro... get all the updates and patches, reload my apps and their updates, then dismount it and hook the old drive back up as the master... and run it 'till it drops. When it does, I can drop the new drive in and be back in business, and then get another drive and recreate my future replacement again.

I need to check into making the boot sector protected. I have a router as part of my hardware firewall but it isn't fool-proof.

Thanks for the data dump, it was a good read!

Dave

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#12

Her's the Solution

Juergen

>As mentioned by another poster if the bearings are getting noisy and it takes multiple attempts to make a successful boot, then replace the drive.

Here's my recommendation. Buy a drive that'd supported by your controller and operating system. Win 2K uses NTFS and should therefore support larger drives. Also purchase Symantec Ghost (you may be able to download it as trail ware from their website). The current version works with NTFS. Ghost is probably the most widely used imaging program around I've been using it since the DOS days. Do a drive to drive copy (this way both partitions are imaged to the new drive simultaneously).

You can also resize the partitions during the copy if necessary. Once the copy is completed remove the original drive and the systme should boot to the new drive automatically.

CAUTION!! As with woodturning, powerful tools can do A LOT of damage if not used properly. I HIGHLY recommend you buy a new HD that is larger than the old one. That way you will not confuse the destination and source drive. I you confuse the the destination and source you will have 2 blank drives, Don't ask how I know.

As far as connecting the drives it doesn't matter Which drive is set as Master or Slave. I personally prefer this be done with the jumpers and not the Cable Select method. Also, be advised some manufacturers (Western Digital) require you to set the jumper to Slave with Master if both drives are attached on the same cable. Good Luck.

By the way the PC in my service department checkin desk lasted almost 6 years after the bearings started making noise. But then the data was on a server that got backed up daily with a tape drive. I left the drive in the PC to show customers when they complained about their noisy PC. ;-)

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

#13

ebd

Re: Urgent Harddrive question the "Pro's"

ebd

>Defragmenting the drive only makes the files on the drive contiguous. It does nothing to remove faulty registry entries. There are programs that can find and remove some of the problem registry entries but only a clean install will remove them all.