Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Small problem..

Posts

Small problem..

#1

Small problem..

Mike Nelson

>I turned this small Cedar-Elm box, completed the finish and the lid fit with a satisfying soft snap. Well, today I picked it up and tried to take the lid off...it is now a solid piece of wood! Wont budge any suggestions, the insert is walnut.


img

Re: Small problem..

#2

Re: Small problem.. 

Mike Nelson

>


img

Re: Small problem..

#3

Re: Small problem..

Allen Neighbors

>I did the same with a small ginger jar. Left it alone for a few days, and then, very gently, forced a thin pocket knife blade into the joint, and it moved. Turned it to another spot and did the same. About 3 or for times and it then came off.

It's because before fitting the lid, it should sit for a day or two to equalize the pressures on the wood. I think. :)

Re: Small problem..

#4

Re: Small problem..

Sean Troy

>Try putting it in the freezer for a few hours. The difference in the wood density may be just enough to contract the walnut a little more.

Re: Small problem..

#5

Re: Small problem..

john lucas

>Either microwave or Freezer might work. When I turn boxes if I'm going to make a really snug fitting lid I either leave the box in the house for a week,or rough turn the box and then bring it in the house, or microwave the blank before turning.

When you turn a box you relieve stress in the wood and it can often move. The wood also moves with the change of seasons. The lid will fit perfectly one season and sometimes will lock up when rotated 1/4 turn during other seasons, or might lock up completely. The one problem with microwaving is you risk checking unless you rough turn the pieces. The other problem is if you get them too dry they will actually pick up moisture when you bring them in the house and you'll have the same lid lock up problem but I've had a lot of success microwaving blanks. I do it slowly to avoid checking.

Side grain wood is the worse for this. End grain is better and sometimes burls, but I find burls kind of unpredictable.

If you choose woods that have a small difference between tangential and radial shrinkage you will have even more success. mahagony is one of these. I'd have to find my chart to tell you what other woods will work.

I've watched people pick up my boxes. Small boxes they pick up the whole box and then remove the lid,often by the lid or finial. Medium boxes they sometimes pick up the box by the lid but usually not the finial, it depends on the shape of the lid. Large boxes they almost grab for the finial or knob. For this reason here are my recommendations.

Small boxes can have a press fit or snap fit lid. Medium and large boxes should have a lid that comes off easily so if they pick it up by the lid the box won't fall off before they get thier hand under it. I like the lids that come off with a pop just like all woodturners but I find customers don't understand, especially if the lid locks up after a few months in thier house. Don't make the lid sloppy but just loose enough to not wiggle.

others may feel differently.

Re: Small problem..

#6

Re: Small problem..

Robert D. Macgregor

>Good luck getting the lid loose...maybe when it is a drier day?

If you can't get it off, you can always make a salt-shaker out of it by putting a plugged fill hole in the bottom and shaker holes in the top!

Re: Small problem..

#7

Re: Small problem..

David Breth

>Similar to John's note, I guess, but I pretty much never make a really snug-fitting box. It is handy to have it fit tightly on the lathe, but my last step is to sand that fitting a little bit. The trick, as John states, is to avoid having a sloppy fit - which I have been guilty of more than once...

If left snug, you end up with a lid that is hard to remove, or a lid that gets pushed off by the air being compressed and therefore never seats properly. Plus, if I buy a box from somebody, and put something in it, I don't want to have to struggle the lid off because I'll end up flinging whatever is in the box across the room. "Oh no! Grandma's ear rings!!" The popping noise is kind of cool to hear from the turner's perspective, and you certainly don't want a lid that falls off whenver you pick up the box, but for practical application I think you want a little slack for ease of opening.

My 2cents but you've got change coming.

Re: Small problem..

#8

Mixed woods

Ron McKinley

>I think the problem is you mixed a hardwood (walnut) with the soft cedar and the two move at different rates. An old carver told me never to mix the two.......Ron

Re: Small problem..

#9

poping lids

John Lucas

>It's actually fairly easy to get a popping lid and not have it fit too tight. Simply make the lip a lot larger with perfectly straight sides. Then each time the lid comes off you get that sort of popping sound. I used to do this on my needle boxes. The whole box would be maybe 2 1/2" long and the inside tenon lip would be about 5/8 to 3/4" long. Then the lid would be tall enough to accept a tenon this deep. They would fit just snug enough so that the air pressure would have to escape to get the lid on and off. This not only make the lid fit well but it won't fall off very easily either.

Of course on something as small as a needle box you don't have as much wood movement either so it's easier to fit the lid snug.

Re: Small problem..

#10

Re: poping lids

Mike Nelson

>Maybe I could sell it and say their is something really special inside....ask 25 and say there is a 50 dollar bill inside but I didn't have the heart to break it open? OK, I'll try the freezer first then jamb chuck and spin some heat on the top. If I snapped the lid on before the lacquer was totally dry it may well become a salt shaker! Thanks All

Re: Small problem..

#11

Re: Small problem..

FRANK joseph

>drill a small hole in the end it can be air presser or put a brass rod in and nock it off jently.