Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Design questions

Posts

Design questions

#1

Design questions

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I have a coupld of design questions I would like to pose to anyone that feels like stating their opinion.

I turned a lidded box, approximately 1 1/2" tall, lid and all, by 5 1/4" in diameter. The box is catalpa. The walls are 1/8", but the lid is about 3/16" thick with decoration on the inside surface.

My first question is, what would be a decent height for a finial for something such as this? And my second question is, what would be a good wood to use with catalpa?

Suggestions are welcome. I am attaching a crude drawing of what I am talking about.

Thanks in advance.

keithz


img

Re: Design questions

#2

Re: Design questions

Allen Neighbors

>JL, 1/3 or 2/3 or 5/3 of the total height of the piece, for the finial, IMO.

I think any dark wood, such as ebony or black walnut would work for the contrasting finial with catalpa; as would holly... I think the finial needs to be truly contrasting with the catalpa.

I'm sure there are those on this forum who are more knowledgeable than me about such as this, though, and you might be better served to listen to them.

Re: Design questions

#3

Re: Design questions

Wally Dickerman

>I don't feel there is a formula that actually works for this. Most folks seem to start turning finials that are too large and heavy for the piece. A finial should be somewhat delicate in appearance. My suggestion is to turn several finials and try them to see what works. In fact, it would be interesting to post some pics and ask for opinions.

Cooling off in Portland.

Wally

Re: Design questions

#4

Re: Design questions

John Lucas

>I agree with Wally and also with Allen. I turn a lot of Catalpa and I think Dark Finials work the best. I like the reddish or black woods with catalpa like Padauk, mahagony, Blackwood,or ebony. I use a lot of dyed woods like Walnut dyed black if you want a porous look or maple dyed black if you want a smooth look.

Size wize it's difficult. I've done everything from a small round knob to way too tall. I agree with Wally in that most finials are too thick and clunky looking. Turn one and place it on there and look very critically at it and decide what else it needs. Then turn another. I'll bet by the time you get to 3 you'll have a pretty good design.

Another suggestion is to turn the finials out of scrap wood and dye them black. This lets you really look at the form. When you have a good one then go to the good wood and turn it.

Re: Design questions

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design questions

keith tompkins

>HI Keith, I think there are other factors that are just as important as the height of the finial. How the finial sits on the form is critical....I think the form should flow right through the finial, with no interruptions. Otherwise, it appears as an afterthought, just sitting there. The shape of the finial should have something in common with the form, giving the piece some sense of unity. A series of v-grooves won't look right on a piece as you describe. I would avoid any straight lines in the finial, look for smooth curves from one element to the other. Think thin.....down to 1/8" in the thinner sections would be a good start. Color is important...many pieces have colors that clash, used for no obvious reason. Darker woods usually work well.

Here's a poor photo of a piece Michael Housaluk critiqued at Yankee symposium...not my "signature" kind of work, but one of the few pieces I had available for the IG. He referred to this piece as a "composition", where the elements all work together.

This is a fairly tall finial, I'm happy with the height, but feel it may look better if it were slightly slimmer. Hope this helps.


img