Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Failing Finish

Posts

Failing Finish

#1

Failing Finish

HarryB in Kukpsville

>I need some help from all the expertise around here. I sold four bottle stoppers to a neighbor around Christmas. She gave three of them back to me last evening because the finish was pealing off. I don't remember what finish I used but it was either CA or lacquer. I know she didn't put them in the dishwasher and she claims they weren't soaked but she did use dish detergent and water. I suspect they were soaked a bit longer than she admits.

I really like the CA finish and can't think why it would do something like this. But of course I feel the same way about the lacquer.

Can anyone shed some light on what may have happened and perhaps give me some suggestions for a better finsh?

Thanks, Harry

Re: Failing Finish

#2

Re: Failing Finish

john lucas

>Can't speak for CA because I don't use it as a finish. I do use a lot of lacquer and have never had any problems. I'm guessing she either used really hot water or let them soak.

Re: Failing Finish

#3

Re: Failing Finish

HarryB in Kukpsville

>Thanks John, I suspect it is some of each. Half joking I told her not to put them in the dishwasher. Thought maybe she would get the idea of taking care of them like they were furniture. This woman is completely deaf and while she signs really well and reads lips almost perfectly, it is sometimes difficult to get things across to her.

Thanks again!

Re: Failing Finish

#4

water based poly

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I have recently started using General's HP polyurethane based on a FWW review of waterbased finishes whare it was a top pick. I brush it on my furnitue and it sands exactly like the lacquer I used to use. It rases the grain lika you would expect from a water based finish. It usually takes treee coats to build a glossy surface but on some dense woods I have gotten a good finish with only two coats. I have not tried it as a wipe on finish on lathe work. after a few days the finish is very tough and durable and on the plus side it has a UV blocker.

I seem to remember a caveat in the FWW article about some woods having a color reaction but so far I have not had any bad results with the stuff other than it costs $60/gal.

Robin Corell

Re: Failing Finish

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Failing Finish

Richard Allen

>Finish coming off could be caused by several things.

It could be the wood is one of several that don't accept finish very well. Cocobolo comes to mind as a wood that repels a film finish.

Sanding a wood to a very high grit before putting on a film finish makes the finish a candidate for failure.

Perhaps you could put on an oil wax finish and then give her a small container (think lip balm size) of the finish so she can "renew" the finish.

Good luck with a happy customer.

Re: Failing Finish

#6

Re: water based poly

HarryB in Kukpsville

>Thanks Robin, I've been using General's Wipe-On Poly Gelcoat for larger items like bowls and have been happy with the results. For something like a bottle stopper, even one with a high-class Ruth Niles stopper, I want something a little faster. With the Wipe-On Poly I usually get no more than three coats in a day and that is when I get up early and go to bed late! This time around I will probaby use Deft lacquer from a spray can....Harry

Re: Failing Finish

#7

Re: Failing Finish

HarryB in Kukpsville

>The three woods with the failed finish were Purpleheart, Redheart and spalted Maple. The one where the finish worked well was Yellowheart. (I was trying to match the colors of wine.)

I usually don't sand past 320 or 400 if I'm going to use a lacquer finish. With CA I add coats and sand with 320 until I can see a faint scratch pattern on the whole piece with no shiny spots. If there are shiny (low) spots, it gets another coat of thin CA. Once sanded, I start through the Micromesh grits up to 12,000 and then use the Beal buffing system.

In this case, I've sanded the stoppers and gotten off most of the old finish. Now I think I'll spray them with Deft. Two or three coats of lacquer and Beal buffing. Probably the most important, I'll give this woman written instructions on caring for the stoppers.

Thanks for your interest...Harry

Re: Failing Finish

#8

Re: Failing Finish

Russ Fairfield

>CA and lacquer dry to a rather brittle film finish, and as such, they will not tolerate any wood movement.

NO finish is totally impermeable to moisture vapor, hot water, or alcohol. The only differences in the finishes are in how long it takes for the moisture ro pass through the film. Since moisture makes the wood expand, and the finish is brittle, cracking is guaranteed.

If the wood is soaked, there is always the possibility of the moisture being absorbed through the endd or anywhere there is a sharp corner where the finish is the thinnest.

Bottle stoppers are more likely to survive in all environments if they have a more flexible oil finish on them.

My preference is to use nothing on them because there will be no finish problems with bare wood. I sand to 600, wet the wood with a damp cloth to raise the grain, wait overnight or use a hair dryer, resand with the 600-grit, and polish it off with 0000-steel wool.

Re: Failing Finish

#9

Re: Failing Finish

john lucas

>Harry I switched to Lacquer because I was using some of the friction polishes and most a shellac based which doesn't do well in water or alcohol. I rub a coat of lacquer diluted 50% with lacquer thinner, on with the lathe off. Let it dry and then put another coat on. Then I spin the lathe up to speed and rub it in with a dry paper towel. If there are any streaks I add just one drop to the dry towel and run over it again with the lathe on. After I finish all the stoppers I put the Beal system on the lathe and buff them all.

I tried spraying them once which leaves a really nice touch finish but just takes too long. I only get $12 for stoppers around here so I've got to keep the time short.