>I just read an article about Neil Scobie and his sounding bowls. In the article he mentions that he has studied bowl gouge grinds extensively and that he grinds his 50 degrees by simply rotating the gouge on the stone. The grind looks very much like a factory grind on a rough out gouge with now sweep on the wings whatsoever. He says this works because of the absolutely straight edge.
Now I know Neil turns more than I but I'm confused. Stewart Batty thinks 40 degrees is the best angle and I've played with that and it definitely cuts better than the same gouge with a 55 degree grind that I used to have on it. The stewart Batty grind has the wings ground back very slightly (nothing like an Ellsworth grind)
Right now I don't have a spare gouge that I can grind this way to see if I can tell any difference. So many different grinds and so little time. I know I'll probably stick with what I have but I sure do love to play.
>I didn't reread the issue (Woodwork Magazine, August 2007) so I don't recall where the grinds were discussed, but Neil Scobie's article is on page 19 and the Sounding Bowl article (part 1) is on page 65. I'll try to reread it this weekend to catch the part you mentioned.
>I recently picked up a copy of "Woodturning Masterclass" from Lightning Publications. It's a great book featuring several wonderful turners, their work and showing how they create one of their pieces. Tobias Kaye is one of the turners. The Woodwork article has more info relative to the sounding bowls, but they are shown in the book.
Really great book and on sale for 50% off ($8.95). The collection seems to be thinning since I bought my copy, but there are a number of other good titles available in this sale as well. (Warehouse clearance sale.)
>There are so many opinions on this subject, and I have ground away so much metal trying many different grinds. Many of these opinions I think are based upon the type forms being turned, as well as, other factors usually not mentioned such as flute shape and bevel length. And some have other gouges ground differently to be able to complete their turnings Stuart being one of them. Unless someone has many gouges with different grinds depending on the project, I find the Ellsworth grind with the oval flute to be the most versatile for bowl turning in that it can do rough turning, finish cuts, and sheer cuts.
>John, do you mark your rest at 40 degrees left and right and then rotate from center to the tip of the wing ending up on the mark? This is the method I have been trying but at 45 degrees. I did not know that Stewart recommended 40 degrees. Knowing how busy you are, if you ever get the time could you take a photo of your grind?
>George I initially ground mine to 45 using the left and right marks just like Stewart. Then I checked my notes from his demo and he said 40 so I changed it. It does cut better at 40.
It proves nothing, but I prefer a 45-degree straight grind for hollowing out bowls with one sweeping cut from the rim to the bottom. It is also a lot easier to teach someone new to woodturning how to grind and use a bowl gouge that way than requiring them to invest in a special jig before then can learn how to turn a piece of wood with a tool profile that they have little chance of duplication at home in their opwn shop.
I also use a similar straight grind with an 85-degree and a 30-dergee grind because they allow a better position of the handle for some things. The 85 is a good too for turning across the bottom because of the handle position, and the 25 or 30 is good for running down the sides of a deep vase. The handle on the 45 gets in the way for both of these.
The 45-degree straight bevel is the best tool for turning bowls on smaller lathes with a bed, because when the tool is rolled over and pointed into the wood, the tool and handle is held level and parallel to the lathe bed for the best cutting.
I like a gouge with a blunt nose angle and a long side grind because I can use it as a scraper for cleaning up the outside of a bowl. It also has the advantage that it can cut equally as well in both directions on the inside of a bowl. This configuration also allows what we call a "pull cut" where the cutting edge is not supported by the bevel. The "pull cut" can be done with the conventional straight grind, but not as well nor as easilly with a conventional grind.
A bowl gouge is no different from a skew or a spindle gouge in that, the sharper tha angle between the flute and the bevel, the better and smoother will be the cut, but the more difficult it is to control. The opposite is also true. The 65 or 70 degree at the tip of many bowl gouges is not the ideal for making a smooth cut, but the large angle keeps the bevel short and that is good. We can make a smoother cut by compounding the angles and giving the cutting edge a shallower presentation into the wood. This compounding and resulting reduction in the approach angle is why most people using the Irish Grind are advocates of using the tool with a very low handle location, or use a bowl lathe without a lathe bed to get in the way.
I use the description "Irish Grind" for the bowl gouge with the blunt nose angle and long side grind, because the "Ellsworth Grind" is an Irish Grind with a specific nose angle (65 degrees), and a specific angle (also 65 degrees) between the walls of the flute and the bevel.
And that is probably a lot more than anyone wants to hear about bowl gouges. They are a complex tool, but when used correctly they can be a very versatile turning tool. A lot of people will say that this or that works best for them, but if they were to really look closely at what they are doing, they will be somewhere within the parameters I have described.
>Excellent response, Russ. This really gets to the heart of a lot of the problems people may be having and explains what works and why. Maybe you should add it to "Russ's Corner".
>How are the 'degrees of grind bevel measured? Where do you begin to measure the angle? If the angle's base is the shaft, it seems to me that 85 degrees is almost a square end on the gouge. Is that right, or am I still just too dense to understand it?
The complimentary angle to 85� is 5�. If you measure the other way around, no turning tool can be that sharp. The hand carvers' tools are merely 20~25�.