Olive Oil?
Philip Duffy
>Anyone beside me think that olive oil, not the EVO expensive kind, but regular old cooking quality, is a great finish? Seems to last forever and does not get rancid. Philip
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Olive Oil?
Philip Duffy
>Anyone beside me think that olive oil, not the EVO expensive kind, but regular old cooking quality, is a great finish? Seems to last forever and does not get rancid. Philip
Re: Olive Oil?
Jeff Taylor - Bloomington, Indiana
>Wow! That would be great news, if it did not turn rancid ..
I have used all kinds of oils and lubes, on "test" pieces, from WD40, to light machine oil .. but "shyed" away from olive oil due to the fear that it "would" go rancid .. May I ask, what amount of time has passed since the application, and how did it finish nicely ?? thanks
Good Site To Learn A Bit About Oils *LINK*
Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA
>
http://www.navaching.com/shaku/oil.html
Thanks Gil
Thad Parker
>Very interesting reading. I'm curious about the "french fry" method though. Any thoughts as to why the oil have to be non-catalyzed?
All You Ever Want To Know About Vegatable Oil..
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>as a finish. It's interesting to note That Tung oil is the best vapor barrier. However, we seldom use straight tung oil. It's usually mixed with a varnish which makes it an even better vapor barrier.
Also note..Olive oil is listed as one that never dries.
Wally
Re: All You Ever Want To Know About Vegatable Oil.
Jim in Nebraska
>You said something about tung oil and varnish. How do you mix it?
Re: All You Ever Want To Know About Vegatable Oil.
Gary in Zirconia, NC
>Jim,
Look in the column at the left and under Other Articals click on Russ's Corner.
Gary
Buy It *LINK*
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Waterlox High Gloss
available at link (no connection) and other quality woodworking vendors
Jeff Jewitt
Re: All You Ever Want To Know About Vegatable Oil.
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>Most of the oil finishes that we use are already a mixture which includes varnish. Only 2 of the oil finishes that I'm familiar with actually contain tung oil. Waterlox and Daly's Ben Matte (which is what I usually use)
Wally
Re: Olive Oil?
John Pickett
>I was wondering about olive oil. Raffan suggests peanut oil on one of his videos ... I used it to good effect.
Re: Olive Oil?
robo hippy
>I ran into a bowl turner from nothrern California, and all he used was olive oil. He didn't have any problems with things going rancid. I think the biggest thing is to make sure the bowls can breathe (they need to be out in the open, not away in the bottom of some cupboard), and remove any surface build up. What does soak into the wood doesn't seem to be a problem, but if you let food and other stuff sit on the surface for a long enough time, it can go sour. I use walnut oil as it does dry. I have heard that it can go sour also.
robo hippy
Maybe
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I've had a partially used bottle of olive oil go rancid after a year or so. Peanut oil lasted a little better, maybe 2 years before the remainder of the bottle turned rancid.
Mineral oil is the only non-curing oil that I know of that won't go rancid.
"Oil" Finish and "American" Fries
Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA
>Thad, I do not know the answer to your question about non-catalyzed oils, but it may have something to do with heating the oils up to around 360�F. All the Burger joints here seem to have a contract for new oil IN, and used oil OUT. They will not even part with a quart of the old oil that I could test as a finish. I suppose I could determine the type oil that they use, get some, and heat it myself. Maybe even cook or fry food in it to nibble on, and make Swamp gravy from all of the stuff that sinks to the bottom of the fryer.
Gil
Re: Olive Oil?
Philip Duffy
>Well, despite the disclaimers and shots at the drying and rancidness, all I can say is that it looks dry, feels dry and smells great after an application on the lathe and a good run-in with a paper towel at good speed. In a couple hours it seems totally dry and hard. Go figure. Sometimes science gets duped by practicality! Phil
Re: Olive Oil? Rancid?
Russ Fairfield
>I have never found Olive Oil to be any different from any other nut, seed, or vegetable oil when it comes to turning rancid. It all depends on the process by which the oil was removed. It has nothing to do with whether it comes from a fruit, nut, seed, or plant.
There are two (2) processes for extracting the oils. It can be squeezed out in a high pressure press, or it can be distilled (cooked) out. The proteins come out with the oil that is squeezed, and they are left behind in that oil that has been cooked.
These proteins are the culprit. The proteins are what makes the oil turn rancid, and it is the proteins that people are allergic to. Since distilled oil has no proteins, there is nothing to rot, and there is nothing to be allergic to.
There can be exceptions to the rule because there are differences in the extraction processes that are used, and there are sometimes additives in the oil to prevent it from becoming rancid or hardening with age. These hybrid oils don't make a very good finish either dry or wet, so they are best left on the shelf.
However, for the most part, we can buy the oil by reading the label, and noting whether it is pressed or distilled. Leave it on the shelf if it doesn't say which process was used, or whether preservatives or colorants have been added.
I have always preferred Sunflower Oil. Note that I wrote Sunflower, and NOT Safflower Oil which is more common on the grocery store shelves. It is not considered a drying oil, but like RAW Linseed Oil, it will eventually, in about a year, become dry enough that it can be oilished to a soft satin gloss. It also has a more pleasant "seedy" odor than Olive Oil.
BOTTON LINE:
There are SOME oils on the grocery store shelves that can be used as a finish, but not ALL oils on the grocery store shelves make a good finish. Rather than try to sort it out, I would recommend letting the finishing manufacturers determine which are or aren't a suitable finishing oil.
A QUESTION:
Why would anyone want to use a non-drying vegetable oil, and run the risk of it turning rancid and having a foul oror, when they could use Mineral Oil to do the same thing. Mineral Oil is inert, it doesn't dry, it is odorless, and nobody is allergic to it. Mineral Oil is the perfect neutral oil for adding scents such as citrus, nut extracts, flowery scents like lavender, or anything else that you think might entice people to buy.
Raw Linseed Oil....
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>Back in the 50's the NRA sold a lot of Springfield and Enfield rifles that were WW1 vintage. Almost everybody who bought one ($15) sporterized it for a hunting rifle. I got into gunstock making as a sideline. All of those rifles had been soaked in raw linseed oil many years before...it never completely dried. Put the stock out in the hot sun and it often would bleed oil.
I don't know why anyone would finish a woodturning or any other wood with an oil that never completely dries.
Wally
Re: Raw Linseed Oil....
keith tompkins
>RAW LINSEED OIL DARKENS TREMENDOUSLY OVER TIME....TO THE POINT THE WOOD SPECIES IS NO LONGER RECOGNIZEABLE. RAGS ARE ALSO A FIRE HAZARD, DISPOSE OF IN A METAL CONTAINER. BOILED LINSEED OIL IS BETTER AS A FINISH COMPONENT, STILL THE FIRE HAZARD.