Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Tear Drop Cutters

Posts

Tear Drop Cutters

#1

Tear Drop Cutters

dwr

>I bent up a bunch of bar stock for some hollowing tools and need a good source for Tear Drop Cutters and the round Swivel (with the groove for square cutters) ... that won't break the bank.

What does the rest of the DIY crowd use? Do you just pony up the money to Craft Supplies or other retail outlets or do you have another source? $30 each for a Tear Drop, plus shipping, is a bit steep.

Thanks!

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#2

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Craft Supplies has teardrop scrapers in HSS for about $15 or the $30+ teardrop which is tantung steel which keeps an edge for a much longer time. I wouldn't have any other kind...they last a long time if you grind them properly. The myrtlewood turners on The Oregon coast is where I learned about tantung steel...most of them use it.

Wally

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#3

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

dwr

>Wally,

Thanks for the info. I was wondering about the Tantung and whether it was hype... I'll take another look-see.

See you in a couple of weeks.

Dave

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#4

Steven Antonucci

You can make the "holder"

steve antonucci

>It's just a bit of steel with a hole in it and a ground groove to hold the cutter. I did mine with a Dremel and a cutoff wheel.

Steve

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#5

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

John Lucas

>I make mine from old planer blades. You can cut a slot in them with an abrasive wheel. I have a 3" angle grinder that I use to cut and shape them them.

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#6

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Dave, you might check with Dennis Stewart on the use of tantung steel. He lives near Beaverton. Tantung is so hard that it takes a lot of grinding to just change the shape of the cutter.

Wally

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#7

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>104 today...I'm off to Portland next Monday hoping to cool off.

Wally

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#8

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

Don in Central Illinois

>Yeah, but I hear it's a 'dry' heat. Kinda like a sauna.

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#9

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

Thad Parker

>John,

can post a picture of an example of the cutter and it is fatened to the holder/shaft? Do you resharpen or just replace the cutter?

~ Thad

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#10

I didn't realize...

dwr

>... that Dennis was still in the area. I met with him several times many, many years ago, just as he was getting his innovative tool system developed. I will look him up.

Thanks Wally...

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#11

60� and cool...

dwr

>... today, with a high of maybe 70�... just about right...;)

Dave

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#12

Yeah, Steve...

dwr

>... $35-$40 for a small round with a slot is tough. Think I will drill a hole and grind a slot in the end of some stock I have and then cut the end off...

Dave

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#13

John... I remembered that I had some... *LINK*

dwr

>... 10% Tungsten Cobalt M2-HSS rectangular cut-off steel similar to link. I think I can cut it into several pieces and shape some cutters...

I think that the Tantung Stewart cutters might be similar of a composition... but not sure.

Dave


M2-HSS Cutters

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#14

Re: John... I remembered that I had some...

Russ Fairfield

>Not the same at all. It is neither high speed steel nor carbide. It is unique.

"Tantung is a cast alloy cutting tool material composed principally of chromium, tungsten, columbium, and carbon in a cobalt matrix. These elements combined in the proper proportions and cast in chill molds give Tantung its most important characteristic -- the ability to retain its cutting hardness at temperatures of up to 1500�F. "

It takes a finer edge than carbide but is more delicate. It's tougher than high-speed steel. For the above reasons it can make a great cutting tool for woodworking applications, but is completely inappropriate for cutting most man-made materials.

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#15

Re: John... I remembered that I had some...

dwr

>Well... that clears it up!

The $30 doesn't sound so bad after all... for a once-in-a-life purchase!

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#16

planer blades

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Years ago I bought some HSS planer blades from Frank Lynn, who advertised in the AAW Journal. I think he still does. In one of the blades, I drilled some 3/16" holes using a Vermont American glass drill from the hardware store. I got 2 holes done before the drill went too dull to cut the HSS.

I cut the cutters with a 4" angle grinder, and ground them to an irregular egg shape to get a variance in the curve from tight to wide.

They screw into the end of a 5/8" mild steel shaft, angled at about 45 degrees for a nice shear cutting action.

It takes a pulling cut from inside out and the shavings go straight down. I can rotate the cutter on the shaft's axis to give different angles of attack, and either rub the bevel or have a straight-across scraping action. I've been meaning to take a short video clip of it in action, maybe I'll get around to that this evening.


img

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#17

No way as good as tantung, but...

Ron in Drums PA

>I've used Grade 8 washers with success

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#18

Re: No way as good as tantung, but...

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>This actually sounds like a good idea. Most likely the washers are case-hardened, with a tough, non-brittle core. Get some Kasenite, shape your cutter from mild steel, and case-harden the skin to maximum hardness. It would take a few applications of the stuff to get it deeper than a couple thousandths, however.

Re: Tear Drop Cutters

#19

Re: John... I remembered that I had some...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I haven't visited the Oregon coast myrtlewood turners for several years, so I don't know if they've made changes. Many of them used very long, very heavy duty scrapers (no Bowl Gouge) to do almost all of their bowl turning. They brazed on a tantung steel cutter. They could rough out a bowl in just a few minutes. Some even had cutters shaped for certain bowl shapes to save time. They could do a lot of bowls before going to the grinder so the cutters lasted a long time.

I spend the $30+ bucks for tantung scrapers for my Stewart tool. Because they hold a good edge for a long time they last a long time.

Wally