Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Thompson gouges

Posts

Thompson gouges

#1

Thompson gouges

john lucas

>I have given the thompson gouges the acid test in the last few days. I turned a solid brass spindle for a client and and then turned the brass ferrule for a tool handle and I was still able to turn the tool handle. I know I couldn't do that with my HSS tools without at least 2 sharpenings.

Today I worked with a beginning turner. His son had given him a laminated Baltic birch blank and wanted a vase turned out of it. I put him on the lathe with the half inch Thompson tool. He turned the whole outside portion with that tool without stopping to sharpen. Anyone who has turned plywood knows that it's hard on the tool edge.

I mentioned earlier that I didn't think they were as sharp as the HSS tools. Right off the grinder they don't seem to be but I started touching the edge up with a fine diamond hone and they cut just as clean as the HSS. Takes a little longer to do this but the benefit of a clean cutting tool with an edge that lasts longer is worth it.

Re: Thompson gouges

#2

Hunter tool systems, Kinda long.

john lucas

>I've been turning with a couple of the new Hunter tool. I have the #4 hunter tool and the #1 hunter tool with 3/16 square shank. See the link below for a look at these tools.

This is a somewhat new concept in the carbide cutting tool concept. These are round cutting bits with Nano carbide particles. This allows the tool to be polished to a sharper edge than the carbide cutting tools we are use to. He claims they will last 25 to 30 times longer. The concept is that they hold an edge must longer than normal tools and when the edge gets dull you rotate the round cutter to a sharp area. I'll have to admit I'm skeptical but will hold off until I've used them awhile.

I haven't had them long but they sure are intersting to use. He mentions that you use them like a scraper and they do work well that way. I find however that they work better for me when used in the same way you use a hook tool or ring tool. It's also pretty similar to the way I hollow a box with a bowl gouge. The cutting action is the same. Start from the center and rotate the tool so it's about 45 degrees or so. When you find the right cutting angle move the tool to the left cutting the bottom and the sides. This tool cuts really clean. I turned a spalted maple box and it cut as clean as my ring tool and my hook tool. I also turned a very dry burl box. I had some slight tearout but coated the inside with Johnsons paste wax and made another final pass and it was extremely clean. I like using this tool.

I'll have more information on using this tool with some photos in the near future. I turned a part of a spindle with it while rubbing the bevel (which he says you don't need to do). The cuts are as clean as my skew but your limitied because it wasn't designed to ride the bevel. What I wanted to see was how well it cut in this mode. I also used it as a scraper to turn part of the spindle and it worked superbly.

The small one works very similar to the John Jordan 3/16 HSS tools except the cuts are much cleaner and yet you can still be agressive with it. My beginner friend used it in a captured boring bar to hollow his Plywood vessel. It was 9" deep. He didn't have any trouble using the tool at all. It's not very grabby when used this way. Before I gave it to him I used a hand held boring bar with the Hunter tool and found it a real pleasure to use. I'm still skeptical of the longevity claims but I plan to use it a bunch. It has a nice feel when your cutting with it.

Re: Thompson gouges

#3

linK  *LINK*

john lucas

>


http://www.huntertoolsystems.com

Re: Thompson gouges

#5

oops, sorry, thanks for correcting

john lucas

>

Re: Thompson gouges

#6

Re: Wife LOVES hers

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Purchased a #3 at Louisville last summer. She hollowed at least fifty 2 inch, hand-bell Christmas ornaments before we had to turn the cutter. Most were spalted, worny red maple that was still hard. The rest were tropical hardwoods like purple heart, A. blackwood, and yellowheart. The amount of rotation for a fresh edge was only about 1/16". We have now purchased a #1 w/square shank. We mounted it in an angled grizzly hollowing tool that came with a very poor steel insert. Although this tool looks expensive it is worth every penny we paid for them. I think that you would have to try to get a catch to get one. I plan to purchase several more and mount them at different angles as $$ permits.

Mike Hunter did not take plastic. He sent the tool, received it in two days, on the promise that we would send a check. He said that he had NEVER been stuck by a woodturner! How about that for CUSTOMER SERVICE.

Re: Thompson gouges

#7

Re: Thompson gouges

Fog Tanner

>I roughed out a 19" pecan bowl which is 10" using a 5/8" Thompson. I started with a 20" cylinder about 11"-12". I cored it getting four more bowls. On each coring I would clean up the inside. I then roughed out another 19" pecan bowl from another blank the size. I never went to the grinder for any of that time. And on the outside I took some time practicing the "finishing cut" to get a smooth surface - basicly practice finish turning evenough though it was for drying.

I have a round 3/8" skew from Doug which I am learning to use. I use it straight off my Tormek and it is the sharpest skew I have. I chucked up a piece of wood and used both it and one of my 1/2" flat skews to see what kind of cut I could get. With the 3/8" round skew, I was getting shavings which looked like dust. I wasn't able to get that fine with my HSS skew. Its now my finish cut tool for boxes. When I sharpen my 5/8" Thompson on my Tormek I get the same kind of edge. I am definately sold on Doug's tools...

Fog

Re: Thompson gouges

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: Thompson gouges

Steve Kubien

>I am absolutely loving my Thompson gouges. I picked up the 3/8" and 1/2" u-shaped bowl gouges and a 3/8" (I think) detail gouge. Marvelous tools which are holding the edges really well. I would recommend these to any turner of any experience/skill level.

Thanks Doug!

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Thompson gouges

#9

Thanks John!

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>They also work well when you hit those annoying face plate screws or a nail... DAMHIK. There is no perfect tool on the market. I'm glad you let me know what works. What grit did you use?

Fog came up with a good idea for a round skew and because of that I'll sell hardened round stock so people can make there own round skew or three point tool.

With a little luck the scrapers/skews will be back from the heat treat next Wednesday so I'll have a spindle turner try them Wednesday night then report. Talk about hot off the press...

Also I made a short run of a new spindle tool that needs to be tested before anything more is said, this will be outstanding if I can keep the cost down but if I can't it won't be made.

Thanks Steve for the good words.

Re: Thompson gouges

#10

Re: Thanks John!

john lucas

>Doug I didn't tell you about taking the hard edges off the jaws of my chuck. Not on purpose mind you but fortunately no real damage to the gouge. Just a quick resharpening.

I've been playing with the fine and ultra fine diamond hones for honing the tools. My fine is about 600 grit and ultra fine about 1200 grit. I also use a diamond fish hook sharpening tool to hone the flute. Between these two the tools cut excellently.