Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Pushing you own limits

Posts

Pushing you own limits

#1

Steven Antonucci

Pushing you own limits

steve antonucci

>I think that there is an evolutionary process that almost all woodturners go through during their lifetime, and I though it made sense to define my experience as a woodturner.

In the begining, we are happy if what we are making can come off of the lathe in a single piece, regardless of shape, form or composition. "Finish" work takes very little time.

At some point, we typically become aware of "better" work in one of two ways- finish or form, but almost never both at the same time. We either make finely crafted dog dishes and UFO's, or poorly finished more refined forms. In most cases with the people I've met, form follows finishing skills much later. I think this is because it's much less expensiveand easy to buy a few tools and learn how to use them than it is to study "art" and learn good form.

Once we've made good shavings and shapes, we start to push ourselves outside of our comfort zones. We turn thinner. We turn through smaller holes. We turn more complex shapes. We augment our work with burning, color, inlay, carving and a myriad of other methods because WE MISS THE CHALLENGE. If you've turned as many things as I have (or more) over the last 10 years, it gets kind of boring to constantly produce the same bowl or hollowform over and over again.

So we work on refining our technical skills to become more and better at what we do, and eventually, we can achieve more and better. I remember when I was proud of hollowforms with a 1" opening and 1/4" wall thickness- now they feel like bowling balls to me.

What happens when you can turn any shape with relative ease? You are forced to find your own voice- or be relegated to the eternal damnation of "production work" until you do.

Below I've attached a shot of my latest "failure". It started with a 2" longer neck and I hollowed it through a 1/2" hole. When I lost the neck, I cut it down to the shape you see here. I probably had 5 minutes left to remove the thickness from the bottom when I felt the 1/8" thick section in the neck. Since the rest of the form is 1/16" thick, it would have placed too much weight in the top of the vessel. I decided to take one more cut, and brought the wall thickness down to zero in a microsecond.

When I was a "younger turner", I would have curse and stomped around the shop for an hour. I had at least 4 days in this pot, off and on. I used to try to figure out how to save them- CA glue, cutting tops down to make bowls... As I "matured", I saved them for experimenting with burning, color, etc- but eventually they would end up in the fireplace.

Nowadays, I will most likely leave it in plain sight of the lathe for a day or two, before smashing it with a hammer to "move on". I don't really get mad like I used to (ok, a little bit on this one...), and I try to learn from every failure. Lesson on this one is simple- measure, measure, measure! when you're down under 1/8"

Still looking for my voice, though.

Steven


img

Re: Pushing you own limits

#2

Re: Pushing you own limits

eaglesc

>OUCH!

Re: Pushing you own limits

#3

That is CRAZY thin!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Okay...next project. A chip and dip tray. You already have the chips made :)

Sorry about your mishap. Chalk it up to another lesson at the lathe.

Jen

Re: Pushing you own limits

#4

Re: Pushing you own limits

Allen Neighbors

>Looks like you pushed a little hard there, Steve. :( Sorry for the loss. I like your explanation of the turning growth process.

That form I messed up the other day... I tried to finish it inside (Had it down to about an eighth), while watching very carefully what the cutter was doing... that is, until I brought the tool out the last time. It shattered, and went all over the shop.

I hope, someday, to be able to get some 'almost' as thin as you made that one!

Thanks for posting.

Re: Pushing you own limits

#5

Re: Pushing you own limits

john lucas

>Steve Nice description of the learning process. I was discussing this with one of the wood students at the craft center the other day. I told him from my experience you start out and you are the weak link, the tools do the job. Then you get better and the tools are the weak link so you either buy new tools or you learn to tune up the old ones. then you once again become the weak link. You work on the skills and then the tools are the weak link again so you learn to improve them or buy better ones and then you become the weak link again.

Eventually Your tools are good and your skills are there but now your imagination and artistic technique become the weak link. then the process starts all over but this time it's learning to see and be creative which I guess is a never ending process.

Bummer about the vessel. I don't cuss anymore when I lose a piece (yea right) but I did quit throwing things.

Re: Pushing you own limits

#6

Very True

Ron McKinley

>Very good explanation of what happens to most of us new turners. Thanks......Ron

Re: Pushing you own limits

#7

Re: Pushing you own limits

C.W.Stivison

>I guess now I know what to look forward to in the next 20 years.

CW

Re: Pushing you own limits

#8

Yup!

Ron in Drums PA

>Well put Steve, I gotta agree.

I've had my share of failures like this and always use the opportunity to inspect the inside up close. There's always something to be learned.

Re: Pushing you own limits

#9

Re: Pushing your own limits

DickAnderson

>Steve:

In the use of tools, familiarity breeds confidence. Sometimes over-confidence, which with any tool can lead to unwanted results. In woodturnng I am a strong advocate that beginners should first learn and develop the skills (technique) to use the tools and that design, form and creativity will follow. Many of the top woodturners I have taken classes from have agreed with me on this premise.

Many of the top turners have moments like yours and I cannot begin to count the number of pieces that I accidentally or deliberately destroyed. I have dropped some pieces on the concete floor with more than usual speed, which allows it to then fit better into my garbage can.

We all enjoy and find comfort in the end result of a successfully completed turning, however, I can revert to childhood memories of hide-n-seek looking for those elusive broken pieces scattered throughout my shop.

Re: Pushing you own limits

#10

Good time to think things over...

Jorge Castaneda

>Steve,

Every time we have an accident, in traffic or in the shop, we must stop and think. What are you trying to prove turning, as Jen put it that crazy thin? to me that is just to "impress" other turners, in my limited experience people buy something more substantial, then again I am ignorant of what happens in the rarified air of the art world.

Good time to think things over...

Jorge

Re: Pushing you own limits

#11

Re: Pushing you own limits

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Cool, you almost had it. If it was easy it wouldn't be fun and I think you did a great job hollowing it out. The next one will be easier yet and I would cut it half and see how you did... that's what I do when I break a hat.

Let us see the next one!

Re: Pushing you own limits

#12

Steven Antonucci

I'm trying to prove that I can turn that thin...

steve antonucci

>to myself. I know that I can just about close my eyes and get 1/8"-3/16" and I want to do "better".

While another turner might be appreciative of the thinness, I'm not really looking for approval. It's about constantly pushing myself to try new things and like the man says:

"If you want to make an omelet, you're going to break some eggs."

In my estimation, it is better to try and lose than to not try and continue to produce "the same thing over and over again".

Steve

Re: Pushing you own limits

#13

Steven Antonucci

The piece that hit me didn't even hurt :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#14

Steven Antonucci

Crazy? I've been called worse :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#15

Steven Antonucci

Happens to everyone-even us "old turners"

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#16

Steven Antonucci

That's what kills me- it was almost perfect!

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#17

Steven Antonucci

I still haven't found it all.

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#18

Steven Antonucci

I did cut it in half, just not longways :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#19

Steven Antonucci

Won't take 20 years...

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#20

Steven Antonucci

I am "The Weakest Link" - Goodbye!

steve antonucci

>

Re: Pushing you own limits

#21

Steven Antonucci

I always stop the lathe before removing tools

steve antonucci

>I've done what you did, and stopping the lathe eliminates that. Tool comes out with no big bang.

Steve

Re: Pushing you own limits

#22

Steven Antonucci

Update- Now I'm just showing off... :-P

steve antonucci

>I went out to the shop and put the calipers on a remnant. It was not 1/16", but 1/32" +/-.

Yeah, I deserved to blow that one up...

Steven

Re: Pushing you own limits

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pushing your own limits

keith tompkins

>HI Dick, I take the opposing view. I think form should be taught from the very beginning....right along with tool technique. Here's my reasoning...many turners focus on technique only initially; unfortunately, this approach has a major drawback. New turners tend to turn poor forms, and get locked into turning familiar shapes.When the time comes for them to expand their design horizons, they find they have a hard time visualizing new shapes, and an even harder time turning them. The net result is good technical abilities, almost no design skills. It's sad that I meet so many students who believe they need to turn bad forms for YEARS before they can even imagine turning good ones. Doesn't it make more sense to set a goal of producing a good form right from the start?

Re: Pushing you own limits

#24

Re: Pushing your own limits

DickAnderson

>Keith:

No one needs to turn bad form before turning good form. They can learn form while learning technique, but I still maintain that the emphasis should be on technique without concentration on design and form for the beginners. I have found in working one on one with some turners that they don't seem to want to learn good form, but are simply satisfied with continuing to turn 'doggie dishes' and odd shaped pieces. They apparently enjoy turning for the sake of turning without concern for improving their understanding and knowledge of the aesthetics of the final product. Those that want to progress will learn design and form and will be much more proficient and satisfied with their ability if they have first achieved good skills and technique.

However, the most important element in all of this is safety and safety is improved when the turner understands and has achieved good technique.

Dick

Re: Pushing you own limits

#25

Re: I did cut it in half, just not longways :-)

Don in Central Illinois

>And not on purpose!