Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The jury is still out! Which of....

Posts

The jury is still out! Which of....

#1

The jury is still out! Which of....

Jamie Donaldson

>... these 2 feet do you prefer on these pieces and why?


img

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#2

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

Jason Clark

>The one on the right. The foot flows much better. The foot on the one to left is interrupted, it almost looks as if the tenon hasn't been removed yet.

Jason

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#3

The Right one.

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Jamie, I like the one on the right best. I just think it is less "formal" and goes better with the natural edge top. I like the smooth line that continues from the rim to the base too. Not broken by the detail of the other foot.

Jen

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#4

Right

Jake (SoMN)

>The right flows better with the lines. As stated already it looks like the tenon is still on the left one.

Lastly, I would like one with no tenon, just a slight dimple in the bottom to keep it from rolling around.

I do like both of them quite a bit.

jake

(remove the 2 for email)

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#5

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

Robert Henderson

>the right. if it was a more traditional bowl (not natural edged) and had a bead on or near the edge to match the one on the foot, I think the left one would work well.

The right has a more organic flow that works a little better with the natural edge piece

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#6

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

jeff myroup

>Jamie,

I perfer the one on the right. Mainly because of the subtle recurve and the tapper on the foot. The one on the left would work for me as well, but I think the little bead detracts from the nice form and beautiful wood.

Jeff

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#7

The one on the right because....

Ron in Drums PA

>there wasn't one without a foot

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#8

I'm with Ron.....

Dave Belser

>But if I have to choose, the one on the right.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#9

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

Gary Ljostad

>Jamie, I'm going to go against the tide. Not that I like the foot on the left one, I think it is too big and still looks like a spigot. But I have never liked the reverse curve for a foot. it usually makes the foot end square to the table and thus anchored looking. It disturbs the flow of the line of the bowl. On the reverse curve base, if you curved the foot under to separate it from the table, it would look even worse. I think one of the best pieces of advice I ever received was, most times a gentle curve under at the bottom of a foot will give the piece a lift and not look anchored to the table.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#10

Re: A different opinion...........

Russ Fairfield

>As shown, I have to say NO to the one on the right, and my preference is for the one on the left. I don't like bowls that look like they are growing out of the tab;e, but prefer those that have the appearance of sitting lightly on the table or floating just above it.

I like the foot on the left because it has the appearance of the bowl sitting very lightly on top of a separate pedestal. This gives it that appearance of floating above the table.

The foot on the right is obviously as integral part of the bowl that firmly anchors it to the table. It has the appearance of growing out from the table top, rather than sitting lightly on it. This appearance might not ba as obvious if the foot were shorter and smaller in diameter.

This is that difference of opinion and preferences that we were discussing in another thread. If I were judging, the ribbon would go to the bowl on the left. It everyone else were doing the judging, they would choose the one on the right. This is obviously only ONE persons opinion because, in this case, I am the only one who shares this preference.

It does point out why it is important to know who is judging the art before entering, and play to their preferences. Some would call that "politics". So be it, that's how things work in real life.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#11

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

John Lucas

>That's a tough one for me. I don't usually like the kind of foot on the right because they often look clutsy. This one has some really nice color to the piece which flows into the foot so I like it.

I normally like the bowl on the left because of the continuous curve where the sides flow through the bottom and make a full circle. It has such a great shape and like Russ said it just sort of sits on the little pedestal.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#12

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

C.W.Stivison

>Jamie,

I think I could make a better decision if the background was blue. LOL Really though given the two choices I like the one on the right better. I guess my preferece would be no foot as someone else suggested. I just think a bowl shouldn't have feet.

CW

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#13

I like the one on the right but...............

stacey s

>I think the one on the left could really be improved if the bottom "tenon"(don't know how to refer to it) portion was removed leaving only a small bead type foot. I think if it had the bead foot I would like the bowl on the left better.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#14

Steven Antonucci

I like the left because EVERYONE does the right!

steve antonucci

>The left shows some thought and originality. The right on is a NEB "cliche".

Steven

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

keith tompkins

>Jamie, the left piece has more opportunity to explore the foot. Here's a bad sketch of something I often do for the foot of my pieces. I only drew half, you get the idea. It serves to elevate the form , I feel. These pieces are very well done, by the way!


img

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#16

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

eaglesc

>The one on the right because there is nothing in the piece that suggests a straight line or a 90* angle.

(bear in mind there is not an artistic bone in my body I only know what looks "right" or to say it another way, pleasing to my eyes.)

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#17

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

Allen Neighbors

>Jaime, I don't know why, for sure, but the one on the right seems to flow better, so it's more pleasing to my eye.

Both are nice bowls! Well formed.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#18

Re: Keith- that foot detail is ......

Jamie Donaldson

>..elegant, but creates some serious production problems like cutting and sanding! I'm into efficient and easy!

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: Keith- that foot detail is ......

keith tompkins

>Jamie, once the basic shape is developed, the details are pretty straightforward using a very steeply ground detail gouge with swept back wings. The cuts are so clean, little sanding is required. This is really spindle turning technique applied to a bowl. It may be worth a shot, especially if you like the results.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#20

Bob Moffett

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

Bob Moffett

>I like the right one better, but I would like it even more if it were a little smaller.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#21

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>I like the one on the right because of the way it flows with the form. The left one gives the impression that the foot is stuck on?

They sure are pretty and of course well photographed.

Wayne

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#22

Re: Keith- that foot detail is ......

john lucas

>I would do it with the toe of the skew. Very clean and no sanding at all.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Keith- that foot detail is ......

keith tompkins

>Agreed John. I'm hesitant to post techniques such as that..I'll use such a technique in private, but don't recommend it online for obvious reasons. The finish left by the tool can be left as is, but I sand the surface to match the appearance of the rest of the piece.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#24

Re: Keith- that foot detail is ......

john lucas

>I find it very safe. It's a simple V cut like you do on spindles every day. The only problem is not having the tool rest as close as a spindle. I use this to turn details in goblets and undercut stacked areas on boxes. I regularly clean up the bottom of boxes,and goblets using this same technique.

I arc the toe of the skew in from the bottom starting with the handle high and lowering the handle. This is a little different than the V cut on spindles because you start with the handle low and raise it. I find the handle high gives a super clean cut and is easy to contol. With the handle high the tool starts cutting with the edge almost parallel to the spinning wood and it slowly increase the angle as you go in. This is a super clean cut even on spalted wood. If you start with the handle low like spindle turning the cut starts with the cutting edge perpendicular to the spinning wood which isn't nearly as clean and trickier to control on a cut like the base of a bowl.

I will certainly agree that most people are more comfortable with a spindle gouge doing this.

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

#25

Re: The jury is still out! Which of....

Don Orr

>I prefer the left foot because it seems to separate the bowl from the table giving it a sense of "lift", as if on a pedestal. The right foot flows all the way down and seems to "anchor" the bowl to the table. Easy and fast yes, attractive, no. My feeling is a foot should "elevate" a piece in more ways than 1 when used at all. These bowls may look even more spectacular than they already do with no feet. Finer details, as in Keith's sketch, may realy set them "above and beyond".

Just my opinion-worth every cent you paid for it!