Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Accepting Art Show Results

Posts

Accepting Art Show Results

#1

Accepting Art Show Results

TDaniel

>For those who are contemplating entering juried art shows let me relate some recent experiences so you can see what to expect. I just did a show in Florida which was billed as a good show with about 60,000 expected attendees. Prior to setting up my booth I visited the museum that contained their collection of items purchased at previous shows. I commented after seeing the exhibit that I might as well turn around and go home because my work was too "normal" for this show. I soon found out that I was correct. Wood art won nothing in this show. Neither did water-color. After the judging I had several people come to me and tell me that I should have won an award because I had some of the best things there but I came home empty, discouraged, and with a smaller balance in my checking account. Yesterday I got a call from one of the visitors to the show. This visitor happened to be a scout for another art show about 40 miles from that one. This "visitor" was a qualified art judge. To make a long story short I was invited to participate in an invitation only art show with 9 other turners and woodworkers. I was told by this person that she had picked up 7 business cards from artists at the show I was in and that of the 7, five were "wood-art". This lady loved wood. The other judge did not. This is what you can expect. Two of my pieces at that show had previously won "Best of Show" awards yet they did not even get "Honorable Mention" at that one. (Needless to say, I have started a log on judges for art shows and I will skip the shows where these judges that appear to not like wood are doing the judging.) In considering why wood items did not do well at that show I remembered a statement that Ray Key made in a class I took with him a few years ago. He said "the best thing you can do to improve sales and interest in wood-turning is help other woodturners around you to improve their products". Ray went on to explain how a few poorly made items sold in an area can hurt the other turners in that area. I think he nailed it with that statement. Some judges just skip over items made from wood because they have seen a lot of "flea market" quality items at prior shows and they just don't consider turned wood to be worthy. On the other hand, there are those judges who recognize the importance of knowledge of woods and wood characteristics and appreciate the skills that are necessary to produce pieces of art from this medium. Wood, unlike paint or clay, has the "art" already in it. You can use the wood as a blank canvas if you like or you can appreciate the art that is in the wood and strive to bring the best out of it with a good form, good finish, and whatever else you can do to enhance what is already there. There will always be judges that like to see the envelope pushed to the limits, and beyond, and there will always be judges that like a simpler approach which recognizes the natural beauty of wood and superb craftsmanship needed to get the most out of what is already there. Also, there is frequently politics involved but we can't talk politics here......

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

Mike Stafford

>Terry, I also enter art shows. The shows I enter are not of the magnitude of the one you describe but nevertheless juried art shows held by the small communities and cities near where I live. Wooden art is lumped in with the pottery, sculpture and other three dimensional work which it should be but is hardly ever given the same weight as those other media. We have a juried show called "Handcrafted" at our local art gallery and it is devoted to art created by craftspeople. This includes jewelry, fabric, needlepointers, potters, etc. There is no painting in this exhibit. It is judged by different judges each year and in the 5 years of its existence wooden objects have been included only twice. If a potter is judging the exhibition pottery gets in, if a ceramicist is judging ceramics gets in, if a ribbon maker is judging ribbons get in...I guess wood artists constitute a minority in the art world and when people think of our work they think of the tacky bric-a-brac seen at all the craft shows and on HGTV. I go back to the show on PBS "Craft in America" where no wooden objects were shown except furniture. The work of Sam Maloof is art for sure but so is much of the work I see on the various woodworking websites. How could anybody deny that When I hear about people doing a craft show I shudder because I fear that by participating in what is seen at many of the craft shows the expectation of quality in what we do is lowered....Of course there are craft shows and there are craft shows...When the show is put on by a woodturning or woodworking guild you see wooden art but seldom do shows like that receive any press. But the other kind of craft shows receive full page ads.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#3

3 observations:

Ruth Niles

>Regarding juried craft shows or higher end shows (I did a number of juried in the past, too much work for one woman):

l. Like our critiques in the Instant Galleries, it's all OPINION of the judges (critiquers). They don't like it, you're not in. That does NOT (repeat NOT) mean your work isn't the best in the show, it means the judge isn't into wood.

2. There are a lot of excellent art shows where turners do fantastic. Please don't say "people don't spend in my area", every area on the planet has it's wealthy residents, just drive through the gated communities or mansion area and you will see they are there. They just may not attend the type of show you are doing.

3. The vast majority of people do not think of wood as ART, we do, they do not. Talk to everyone you see in a day, at the grocery store, Lowe's, Wall-Mart, Lord and Taylor, the dentist, Jiffy Lube and tell them you're an artistic woodturner, your work is better than David Ellsworth's. I'll bet you will not meet one single person who will have any idea who David is and, more important, what woodturning is. Say "wood" (no matter in what context) and they either picture furniture, a log or a cutting board.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#4

Re: Many of these comments and.....

Jamie Donaldson

>... observations are right on, and represent why we must continue to build a reputation for wood as a viable ART medium. Within the last 10~15 yrs. woodturning has begun to be recognized, and in part that recognization is due to entities like Collectors of Wood Art, AAW, the Woodturning Center, and the individual collectors who have championed the cause thru their high profile efforts. I have done many juried shows where wood is an ignored/illegitimate medium, but I am involved in raising the perception of woodturning thru my show exposures to the public. Its often a good thing that I made a good living as a photographer so that I can now afford to be a woodturning artist who doesn't make functional items like salad bowls.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#5

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

Curt Fuller

>For me, the best perspective for understanding the why's and why nots of getting selected into a juried event is to just walk through any art show yourself. There are going to be things you like, things you don't care for, and things that make you wonder who in their right mind would call that art. But all of it is someone's work that they're poured heart and soul into. The juror is just human, one person making the same judgements based on their own likes and dislikes and perspectives. Acceptance has some bearing on the quality but mostly hangs on the whims, moods, and fancy of one person at one moment.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#6

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

john lucas

>It is very interesting to hear all the peoples take on juried shows. I won't deny anything TD says because it easily could be possible. His work is very nice and I wasn't a juror at that show. Here's my take. I've sat through quite a few juries running projectors for them and I've been a juror several times. I also shoot for 100 or more artists and get to hear all the stories, both good and bad, about jurors and show directors and the process of getting into shows.

When you have 500 or more people submitting work for a show that has 180 booths you see a lot of slides in a very short time. Here is how our local show works. It usually has at least 4 woodturners (Jamie was one last year). All the slides are shown 5 at a time through completion so the jurors are aware of what is out there. Kind of a preview. We have 3 jurors from different mediums. Then the slides are shown again and the artists statement is read. The jurors give them a score 1 to 5 and you can't give a 3. When all the jurors are ready we go to the next artist. This averages 20 to 45 seconds depending on how long the artist statement is. Occasionally someone will ask a question to verify something about the statement but usually we give a score and move on.

A plot is created on the computer that makes a bell curve and the top 180 are selected with some alternates just in case someone backs out. The reason our director threw out the number 3 on the score sheet was because too much work fell in this category and the bell curve was too flat. By forcing us to say this piece is better or worse than average it created more lift to the curve. That makes it hard on the juror but kind of fun at the same time. You can't be lazy and say Oh that's another 3, you have to concientously make a decision that you know may affect the artist lively hood. Our director feels this is the best method for removing bias from the process. I might not like glass and may rate it lower as a 2 but the other 2 jurors might rate it in the 4 category. All jurors I've met are very serious about this process because they have been in the same boat as TD and don't like bias. That doesn't mean that it doesn't happen but I think it's outside the norm.

We discussed this at the last artist meeting and all agreed that it's pretty easy to find the 5 (good) and 1's (bad) but most work falls really close to a 3. Good form, good technique, very saleable, and often quite original. Now you have to ask yourself, and be honest here. Is your work that much better than everyone else at the show. that's a tough question to ask because we obviously favor wood and as Jamie said most people like it but won't necessarily rate it any higher than a glass or ceramic piece.

I've heard rumors about shows that limit the number of certain types of work like ceramics for instance and I could see this as a possiblilty. You don't necessarily want a show that has a very large percentage of one type of work. Our director won't do that unless it becomes a problem.

Most of what I hear about shows is a lot like gossip. someone didn't get in and they conjecture about why, then it gets amplified by the next person telling the story and so on.

Just because you get best of show at one place doesn't mean you will at the next. You have 3 or more different jurors and they will see things differently. You got in the show which means your in the upper class of your group but you are competing against 180 or more other artists for that coveted award. I like TD's work and might tell him that I think his work should have gotten the best of show, but my glass artist friend might tell his glass buddy the same thing. You can't go by what people tell you who weren't there to be a juror.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#7

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

Ron in Drums PA

>Dropping the 3?

Wouldn't be the same to just use a scale of 1 to 4? :-D

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Many of these comments and.....

keith tompkins

>I agree Jamie....many in the wood turning field criticize the art turners who, in their opinion, are ruining the craft. The simple fact is the art turners are the ones who are elevating our craft to the higher levels, and are the driving force behind the wood art movement. The art turners are an important part of the turning community...like it or not.

In Terry's case, winning isn't always the most important aspect of a show....the invitation to another show may prove to be even more beneficial to his career than this one. Each event brings opportunities to network and make new connections.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#9

Thank you for a very lucid ...

Ed Moore

>account of how the process works. Eliminating the 3's makes you give each artist a thumbs up or a thumbs down. No one likes to do that, but I'll bet that if that were not the case then 60 per cent (or higher) of the scores issued would be 3's. It's human nature to avoid the tough decisions.

Thank you John.

Ed

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#10

Juried show

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>How many of you are willing to enter a juried show that has only one judge?

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Juried show

Mike Stafford

>Gil, I have never entered a show that had more than one judge. I guess my experience is limited to what is around here and the shows are small and sponsored by the local art galleries and such...

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#12

Mike....

TDaniel

>I think you are correct in all that you said. I think you can go one step further though.....when a woodworking guild does the judging a wood item is more likely to win but then, in my opinion, more politics comes into play also.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#13

Re: Juried show

Russ Fairfield

>I have entered a lot of juried shows with only one judge, and I have also been accepted by several of them. Many shows are sponsored by only one person. Sometimes it is a gallery owner, and sometimes it is just a patron. whatever the reason, it is their show, and they choose what they want to be in it. The show will be successful for many years if they choose well. It will soon disappear if they don't. I don't have a problem with that. Don't enter if you do.

I always try to visit a major show before I enter so I can see if there is a preference in art forms, and if there are woodturners, and how well they are doing, and how many years they have come back. If I can't visit, I will at least investigate the last years entry list and where they put them. If they won't furnish that information, I forget about them. If I don't like the atmosphere or the theme, I don't enter. It has nothing to do with how many jurors there are.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Juried show

Mike Stafford

>I agree totally Russ. I just have noticed that there is a bias by most of the judges I have encountered toward their specialty. I guess that is to be expected. The first piece I ever sold in an art show was to the judge. He owned a gallery and later contacted me and asked me to sell in his gallery. I did for a number of years. I have not had any success with turned objects in art shows; just flat work artsy fartsy boxes. I don't think I am creative enough for turning artsy objects.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#15

Steven Antonucci

Whose work is best: Ellsworth, Miro, or Chihuly?

steve antonucci

>How can you complain about "losing" to another medium without disrespecting the "winning" artist and his or her medium? Even if every word you say is true, it still doesn't sound very respectful of the other artist who probably worked as hard on their entry as you did on yours.

Given that all of us are influenced by our own personal tastes and experiences, I don't see the jury process ever changing. If I like wood, I'm more likely to vote for it. If I like metalwork, then I might vote for some metalwork piece.

Whether you think your work was the best in the show or not is irrelevant. You need to be on the jury for your vote to count, and the jury may or may not be qualified to judge all mediums. I wouldn't be so bold as to suggest that I was "robbed" by the jury. When you won best in show, do you think some painter or potter complained that the judging was biased towards wood?

You may have been "robbed", but your story would have been better told in the third person.

0.02 cents

Steve

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#16

Robbed?

TDaniel

>Who said robbed? My point was that no medium will win every show with every judge. As you say, some like wood, some like metal or ceramics, some like oil paintings. But more importantly are the reasons behind what they like or dislike. Have they been influenced positively or negatively by the woodturnings they have seen? As an organization we strive to promote the "art" of turning. In some areas of the country we have done a good job of promoting wood-turning as an art and in some areas it is still considered a craft. Entering shows is costly. My point is that if you can check out what has won there in the past you might save yourself some bucks that will enable you to go to another show where wood is welcome. Now if you have a fat checkbook then this may not be important to you but I have to at least make break-even in order to go back the following year. A combination of sales and prize money is how I afford to go to shows. But the other point you missed is that there are scouts at each art show and although you may lose at one show it doesn't end there because as I pointed out, I was invited to another show that obviously likes wood.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Whose work is best: Ellsworth, Miro, or Chihul

keith tompkins

>I've thought about this topic for a while, and a couple of things come to mind. First most people selected to serve as judges are craftsmen or artists; even thought they work in their chosen medium, they are usually acutely aware of what constitutes successful work, and what does not. Good form, balance, scale and proportion, and other factors are just as important to the metalworker as they are to a woodturner. You can rest assured the judges have these things in mind when they make their decisions...a good judge will compare a piece in the show with accepted standards for that particular field. Many judges are a bit bored with their own field, and look for something new, bold, and exciting in a different field.

Sometimes, having a judge with the same background can work to your disadvantage....In one large woodworking show about five years ago, one of my pieces won a "Judges Commendations" award. In this case, my piece was judged against such things as cabinets, windsor chairs, canoes, and musical instruments, not to mention other turnings. One of the judges was Ernie Conover, the well known turner and instructor. He approached me later, and explained that 4 of the 5 judges voted for my piece as Best of Show. He was the only holdout, feeling that my wall thickness was 1/8" too heavy, judging the piece against accepted turning standards. I was more than happy with the results, and gained a lot of respect for Ernie as well. My pieces got a bit thinner after that, too!! :)

That show draws about 5-6,000 spectators annually. Now if the show TD mentions draws 10 times that amount, and is open to all fields of art, I would think being judged in is a remarkable feat in itself, and winning a best in show damn near impossible. In a show that size you can bet the best of the best are competing for any available slots.

A similar situation occurs when a turner makes the journey to his first national symposium....they may be a "big fish" locally, but when they see the quantity and quality of the works displayed at a national event, any hopes they may have had of making the critique rapidly vanish. In Louisville, about 1,200 works were on display; only 30 made the critique! The odds are not good at all. The selections are at the discression of the judges; there were several pieces on display that I felt very worthy of mention that received none. Sadly,a piece that won a best-of-show locally probably won't even garner a second glance at a national event.

If anyone wants to be completely blown away, visit SOFA Chicago or SOFA, NY.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#18

Exactly right Keith

TDaniel

>I started this thread to give those who are contemplating showing their work an idea of what is before them. I am learning by doing and it is as you say. As some have said, each judge will see things from a different viewpoint. To find a starting place I think you just have to roll the dice and pick a place and put your best things there and hope for a win or some sales or hope you are discovered there by someone who will invite you to another show that might be more suited to the work which you have presented. Not winning a show is not necessarily a dead-end. Now if you enter 10 shows and don't do well in any of them then it might be time to go back home and practice.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#19

Re: There has been some confusion...

Jamie Donaldson

>.. here between the jury process and judging done during a show for awards. Juries are most often, and should be, composed of a mix of knowledgable jurors from different art/design type backgrounds. This selection process should assure a varied representation of artists for a show, just what the show promoter and the buying public wants. Judging during a show is a different matter, and anyone who selects shows expecting to gualify for "best of" awards is better off playing a lottery!

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#20

Re: There has been some confusion...

Nelson

>After doing shows for 6 years and competing with all art mediums the chance of winning best of show the odds are like winning the lottery, and it dosen't matter if its Art or Craft people will only pay top price if its good or unique and the artist does a good job of selling.One should never enter a show if they are not willing to sell themselves along with their product.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#21

Re: There has been some confusion...

john lucas

>Jamie is right. Often the judge for the best of show is someone other than the jurors who selected you to begin with. In our TACA group the best of show award is given by a lady who raised the funds for the award. It finally got to be too much work so she quit doing it. I don't know who the new judge is.

One other thought. When the show promotor is the juror they are not necessarily interested in the best pieces or the "art". They are interested in what sells in thier venue. If they are successful in picking that kind of work then the show is successful and the artists are happy. If they aren't successful then the artists go home mad because thier work didn't sell in that venue. That doesn't mean that thier work wasn't good. It only means that it didn't sell well in that location.

Craft shows are very much like farming. What sells well one year might not the next and each show has a personality all it's own. The really successful artists have figured out which shows are the most profitable and what products sell at those shows. That's really tough to learn and only experience gets you there.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#22

Steven Antonucci

I must have missed the intent of the original post

steve antonucci

>Still, I'd guess that your motivation for entering shows is very different than most turners. Based upon my experience, most turners should treat the show as a marketing/selling opportunity. On the back-end, you can "beef-up" your CV.

I think it's probably safe to assume that winning any award at any juried show is an honor to ANY craftsperson/artist, regardless of the medium. Treat it as a bonus, and do not rely on it to make attendance decisions. Assuming that you won't win Best of Show, is it still a good opportunity to attend? Or might you be better off finding shows that "like wood"?

As a sales and marketing professional, I can tell you that winning best in show at the "wrong show" may stroke your ego, but won't contribute to your W-2's. Conversely, being passed over by the judges at the right show, may just lead to some income.

I met a guy at the Chester Spring Craft Show last weekend who was at the wrong show. In between the painted rocks and scrapbook supplies, across from the chip dip guy, was the most spectacular marquetry I've ever seen. No chance of selling anything, but Best in Show...

Steve

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#23

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

Don Orr

>Very interesting topic of discussion TD. I for one, value your, among others, perspective and input. While I am in no way ready to try and get into a juried show, the information presented here by everyone is food for thought. I have learned a great deal reading this thread and if I ever head down the road to a jury I hope I remember the excellent advice.

Thanks.

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#24

Thanks Don! That was the purpose of

TDaniel

>the thread. I was passing on things I had just learned hoping we could share our combined wisdom from various perspectives. We always have one or two that want to take the side of the devil's advocate but the rest of us benefit by sharing knowledge.

Thanks again for your comments.

TD

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

#25

Re: Accepting Art Show Results

ET

>TD, This has been a stimulating thread, but, I don't quite understand the situation that prompted your original comment. I understand that you went to an event in Florida and set up your display/sales booth. Was this a sales event? Why were your products being judged? were you selling to the people in Florida? How were the sales?

I have had the humiliating eperience of entering a juried display show and being turned down. I found it useless to try to compete against college trained potters and their friends and instructors who are the jurors. Jurors are interested in presenting a show/exhibition that stimulates the audience. Not my objective, as a maker and seller. So, now I don't waste my time with the local juried craft scene and concentrate on another aspect of woodturning. ET