Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

"How long did that take?" (longish)

Posts

"How long did that take?" (longish)

#1

"How long did that take?" (longish)

John Pickett

>Upon showing someone my work, I am often asked "How long did it take to make that?"

My answer depends upon who is asking. Let me explain.

This question generally comes from one of three types of persons: the capitalist, the craftsman, and the artist/philosopher. (OK, I know that is stretching credulity, but just go with it.)

The capitalist wants to know one thing: How much does it cost vs. the value of the item. To this person, 'time is money,' thus the question: "How much time ..."

This question requires an answer because they probably can actually afford to buy it.

My answer, therefore, will include the time I spent in design, how long I had to work at my day job to buy the raw materials (or how long I spent in the woods) in addition to the time standing in front of the lathe, etc.

The craftsman wants to know the process / Can I make that? I actually enjoy talking to these people because we have compatible interests, and they understand craft. My answer is tailored accordingly.

I explain the technique, mastery of tools, etc., involved in the work

The artist / philosopher (who is the only one really worth talking to

anyway) deserves the truth, because they can appreciate it.

So I tell them: A lifetime ... in my case, 54 years.

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#2

Steven Antonucci

Very well said and to the point.

steve antonucci

>

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#3

Touch�!!

DWR

>

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#4

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

john lucas

>My good friend Curtiss Brock who is the glass instructor at the Appalachian Center for craft has a good answer. If it took 45 minutes to make he tells them 25 years and 45 minutes. 25 years to learn how to do it and 45 minutes to actually do it.

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#5

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

Curt Fuller

>A few years ago I found this poem and have saved it for when that question gets asked.....

How Long Does It Take To Turn One of Those?

Do you mean

not plant the tree, but find the wood,

just 'see' the piece, (as if I could)?

to find a highly figured burl,

a crotch, an eye, or pearly curl?

And once I spy it, perhaps buy it,

inventory, store, and dry it?

Then saw or cut it, possibly I kiln it'

glue, imbue with fill, or drill it?

You mean, that once I'm satisfied

it's stopped the warps, checks, cracks, once dried?

And mounted on the lathe, to turn it,

(which takes much practice, just to learn it;

and then employ a gouge, or two,

or use a skew, which I don't eschew,

to mold it, shape it (what's your pleasure?)

by all means, I'm sure to measure,

then sand it smooth, please wear your mitts,

from coarse to fine, 10,000 grits,

then braze, or burnish, paint, or polish,

(the goal: enhance, and don't demolish)?

Is that your question, start to end,

how long's that path, its way to wend?

Or do you merely want to know how long it turned?

Ten minutes, or so.

John A. Styer, The Lathe-meister

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#6

Re: Curt-that's a great answer but....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. its too long for me to remember!! (;-0)

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#7

I love it, Curt! Great poetry.

Ruth Niles

>

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#8

I always have a problem with this.....

Ruth Niles

>I never know what to say in response to this question. My mind reels; are they going to think I'm charging too much if I tell them it took an hour to make; will they think it's too cheap if it took 3 hrs.; will they care, or even understand, the before and after work not just the turning; are they interested in learning how to turn, etc. I really hate to just stare at people for 3 minutes while my mind is thus spinning with "what do I say? how should I answer? why are they asking?" So I smile and say "too long, after I get better it should go faster"

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

#9

Re: "How long did that take?" (longish)

David Breth

>For the one show I've done, I prepared a three-ring binder that gives a really abbreviated look at how bowl-turning is done in pictures. So it shows getting the wood, prepping the blank, letting it dry, turning the outside/inside, sanding, indicates risk of blowout and injury, and time required in finishing. It also shows the equipment needed.

I answered "the questions" plenty of times at the show, and have answered them numerous times for visitors to the house. The people who ask the questions: capitalist, craftsman, and artist-type were all satiated when they saw the book. The capitalist appreciated that significant time went into the entire process, and can see that there is intrinsic value to a piece because he can assess the artsy type too. the craftsman got to see an example in answer to his particular question(s), and the artsy-type got to see a little bit behind the curtain and appreciate a bit of the craft. All three have different question-types, but all three are going basically the same place - that's neat, I want to understand more about it.

I don't think I could feel comfortable with the "years to learn how to do it in a short time" response. That's part of the answer, and for some people it is all they really deserve to hear, but it doesn't really help somebody appreciate the work. If "appreciation" is at the center of a spoked wheel, each person has their own spoke to follow to get to the middle "ah-ha" point. (By the way, yeah, the guy who asks how many hours, is this your full time job, do you just do shows, how much does a canopy tent cost, how many do you sell a show, do you make any money at it - that guy is cruising for the short rebuff answer if not a crisp one across the chops),

I'm not suggesting that the capitalist isn't trying to do head math on you, he absolutely is, but at the same time, that's the way he can appreciate what is being done, at least it is his starting point. The craftsman appreciates the effort, but that is his starting point - he will eventually get to the "can you make money at it" part, and the artist will never understand the money end of it or possibly even the craft part, but they get the form. Ultimately, all three can appreciate what is being done, but what we see in their initial questions is the tip of their iceberg.

I'll give you one more example. I've been a fan of one rock band in particular for about 25 years. I've always enjoyed their music on a number of levels - capitalist, craftsman, and artsy guy. The capitalist has always done head math on these guys, because I find the industry so interesting and want to understand where their money comes from. The craftsman in me wants to understand the process of song-writing, arrangement, and concert production. The artsy type in me just closes his eyes and listens. I was first drawn in by the music, and got interested in the other stuff later on.

I guess I got on a high horse there, probably shouldn't have, sorry, goodness knows I'm ill-qualified and ill-experienced to do so....

David B.