Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

It feels good to finish something

Posts

It feels good to finish something

#1

Steve Kubien

It feels good to finish something

Steve Kubien

>This wood came from the massive maple burl I posted about back in February or March. It is the first thing to come of that. 6.5" wide and 2.5" tall. 3 coats of tung oil for the finish. What do you think of the rim? It is an area I am trying to get better at and I am not sure I like this look.

Opinions and critiques are welcome and appreciated.


img

Re: It feels good to finish something

#2

Steve Kubien

bottoms up

Steve Kubien

>Thanks,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario


img

Re: It feels good to finish something

#3

Re: It feels good to finish something

Bruce Forrest

>I think I'd go with either the slope up or the slope down of the rim, but not both. Otherwise, a nice bowl.

Re: It feels good to finish something

#4

Re: bottoms up

Jim Rutten

>Hi Steve,

Bowl looks great. I like the rim. I was wondering if you have something sticking proud of the bottom or if that was just a flaw in the picture.

Re: It feels good to finish something

#5

Nice bowl but I agree w/Bruce

Bernie

>

Re: It feels good to finish something

#6

Steve Kubien

Re: bottoms up

Steve Kubien

>Thanks for the comments Jim. The bottom is flat but I am useless as a photographer. :)

Steve Kubien

Re: It feels good to finish something

#7

Steve Kubien

One vote against

Steve Kubien

>Ok, one vote against the rim. Thanks for your thoughts.

Steve Kubien

Re: It feels good to finish something

#8

Steve Kubien

2 votes against

Steve Kubien

>Thanks Bruce.

Steve

Re: It feels good to finish something

#9

it could work

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Maybe you just need to vary the proportions a little, like lessen the outer to half or a third as wide as the inner. I think it is worth playing around some. Heck, look around; lots like it have already been done. Try the inner flat horizontal or very gently sloped and the outer more steeply sloped. There are plenty of variations to look at. Don't stop experimenting!

Re: It feels good to finish something

#10

Re: it could work

John Lucas

>Steve I agree I don't mind the shape of the rim but think the proportions should change. I would consider making the outside rim about 1/3 and the inside 2/3rs. I would use the outside portion as a sort of shadow line for the main part of the rim.

I love the undercut on the inside of the lip. I think that not only looks good but makes a bowl easy to pick up. I've always liked that shape.

Re: It feels good to finish something

#11

Make that 3 against

Jim Swank

>I'm with Tom & John. The step up-step down rim will work, but not with those proportions and angles. Even though I can see otherwise, that rim informs my eye that the bowl is rather crude and clunky, and doesn't invite my fingers to caress it.

Re: It feels good to finish something

#12

Re: It feels good to finish something

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>Steve,

Overall the bowl looks good but the rim seems a little busy? I think if you pick one single rim form it would be more appealing IMHO.

Wayne

Re: It feels good to finish something

#13

Re: It feels good to finish something

Barry Turner

>I'm not sure I should even respond, since I have problems with getting just the right rim effect, too. But, to me, it appears that the rim detail on this bowl is out of scale. That is, the detail is "too large" for the bowl. I like the simple rim details. Try turning the rim flat and straight across. Then, try it with a gentle crown on it. You might like using a very gentle cove detail on the inside of the rim. Usually less is more. Just my thoughts and preferences.

Re: It feels good to finish something

#14

Steve Kubien

Thanks everyone!

Steve Kubien

>That's the first time I've had a piece referred to as clunky. In one way that kinda stings (but I did ask for it:)) and in another way, I really appreciate your comments. Hey, I want to get better at this, even the truth hurts a little. Thanks. I will experiment with the rim shapes on other pieces. Eventually i will find something that I like, and others too!

This is the kind of feedback I've been looking for. Thanks everyone.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario