Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

I need opinions regarding this bowl

Posts

I need opinions regarding this bowl

#1

Steve Kubien

I need opinions regarding this bowl

Steve Kubien

>Hi everyone,

I am in the middle of sanding this box elder bowl and I need your opinions... Should I clean up the foot and keep it or remove it entirely? It has served as a tenon for mounting in my chuck but the more I look at it, the more I think maybe it should stay. The bowl is around 7" across and 3-4" tall (sorry can't remember at this point). Thanks for you help.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario


img

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#2

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Don in Central Illinois

>I'm not a real big fan of feet on bowls. But that's just me. I would prefer a small flat or concave on the bottom. To me it would flow better. Just my .02 cents worth.

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#3

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

robert davis

>i would leave appx 1/8" foot.just enough for a little lift.

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#4

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Bruce Forrest

>If you want a foot, try sloping this one inward towards the top for a kind of Oriental look. It might look even better if the foot was even taller than it is now. Of course, if you don't like Oriental looking bowls, then you can always turn it off.

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#5

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

John Lucas

>Steve I'd make the foot half that tall if it were me.

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#6

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Bill Howatt

>My opinion and that is all it is:

I don't usually like feet because I think they look like, of all things, chuck tenons. Given the shape of your bowl which is relatively flat on the bottom and there is some merit in trying to make a bowl look like it's floating on the table, I'd go for a very small lift (around the 1/8 someone else suggested). I would also try and blend it into the bottom, ie, no sharp edges. Sharp edges draw your eye to the sharp edge - try to keep changes in direction flowing. However, you may find the bowl tippy but if it is a display piece that usually isn't much of a problem.

Bill

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#7

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Steve,

If there's a problem, it's that your bowl and foot don't operate as a unity because the bottom of the bowl form flattens out. If your bowl were a continuous round, the visual effect would be very different. Example is the photo attached of an 11-1/2" oak bowl. The other way to handle the issue is with a full ogee profile as in the second pic.

Hope this helps.


img

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#8

Re: No. 2 

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>


img

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#9

Maybe that 1/8" for lift

Jim Swank

>

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#10

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Carole Valentine

>Hi Steve. If it were me, I would have a very tiny foot - barely enough to float the bowl off the table. Play with a picture of the piece on the computer until you find something you like.


img

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#11

I agree with Carole *LINK*

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>A tall foot doesn't do a thing for me and I wouldn't make one unless someone asks for it.

Terry


Vacuum pump

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#12

I'm with Carole, too.

Chip in Plano

>I looks like my bowls with the tenon still on just before I reverse it and turn it for a minimal foot.

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#13

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Chris LaPine

>Steve,

I would drop the foot altogether. It makes it look like a squashed goblet.

Chris

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#14

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Wayne Leach-NW Ontario

>Bowl shape looks very good to me but I am not a big fan of footed bowls. I would rather see the bowl without or with barely any protrusion and not looking like the tenon for a chuck.

You are doing some terrific work. Keep showing it on site.

Wayne

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#15

Jesper, Denmark

No foot..............

Jesper, Denmark

>None of the lines in the bowl shape lead to a foot. A foot will look like an additional lump on an otherwise nice shape.

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#16

Steve Kubien

Well, I thought I'd ask...thanks

Steve Kubien

>I thought since I still had the tenon on it I would ask about leaving a tall foot. I've seen a few similar bowls in books I kinda like the look. Overwhelming consensus is to remove it completely or leave something like an 1/8" to add some lift. I will go that route.

Thanks for all the help. I think I can take a decent cut with my tools and I am needing less sanding with each piece I make. I think I am doing ok with finishing. I am happy with those parts of my turning.Design is still a hurdle for me to haul my b*tt over.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#17

Lose the foot...

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>it makes the bowl look too upright and flat. Losing the foot will soften the curve and IMO the bowl will seem rounder.

keithz

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#18

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Normaly on a bowl of this shape I find a round bottom works. However, your form tends to flatten out as it approaches the foot. No foot at all would make a large flat area that would give the bowl no lift. I suggest that you make the foot about half as tall and create a reverse curve into the foot. Curves are more attractive than a flat surface.

Wally

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#19

Re: Well, I thought I'd ask...thanks

Bill Howatt

>Steve,

There are some other comments other than to remove the foot completely. If you are inclined you might try them which will gradually cause the foot to disappear but you will have a chance to see the suggestions on you piece.

Just because I and others say we don't like feet it certainly doesn't matter a darn if your preference is to have the foot. At our turning club I have seen a lot of pieces displayed that have feet and a lot of people like them but in many cases I would have gotten rid of it. There are general guidelines like making flowing curves etc but there is no single right way to shape a piece. After all, not everybody thinks a Picasso is great.

If you think you will significantly evolve in the area of tool control, it will be no more than your evolution in what you find to be a pleasing shape after more and more turning.

Bill

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#20

Steve Kubien

Thanks Bill

Steve Kubien

>I appreciate your comments, truly. Yup, everybody's tastes are different and I suppose since I haven't been at this as long as many around here, I'm still trying to determine what my tastes are. I generally know what I DON'T like (asparagus for example) :) but when I'm not sure, I like to get the opinions of others such as yourself.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#21

Re: Knowing What You Like

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Steve,

I suggest a trip to a good library where you'll find stacks of books on pottery and ceramics going back thousands of years in many different cultures. First thing you realize is that most any shape you can come up with has already been done. But then you start seeing relationships between bodies, rims, feet, etc. Bet you'll find a combination of these things that will pique your interest, and you'll go back to the shop fired up with permutations and translations spinning in your head.

mm

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#22

Steve Kubien

Re: Knowing What You Like

Steve Kubien

>Excellent idea Mark. I think I'll make that trip this week and copy a few pages of what I like to hang above the lathe.

Thanks!

Steve Kubien

Re: I need opinions regarding this bowl

#23

Re: Another Brilliant Idea

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hunt up an adult ceramics class in your area, and learn to "throw" on the wheel. You will develop a real spacial sense of form as you move the pliant clay around, but you won't have the tension that comes from worrying about screwing up a special piece of wood; after all, "it's only mud." I suggest you introduce yourself and your turnings to the instructor and explain that you're there to work out shape and form studies rather than play with glazes or make things for Mommy.

|;-}}}

mm