Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Toolrest Recommendation

Posts

Toolrest Recommendation

#1

Toolrest Recommendation

David Breth

>Last night I snapped the toolrest on my Jet-1236. The base is fine, but not the rest. That soft "Pling, ling-a-ling-a-ling" on the floor told me something had gone awry.

I've been debating going to a modular toolrest with round bars anyway, and am wondering your thoughts on getting a straight-up replacement Jet-1236-36 versus going round bar modular. I'm thinking the round/modular would be

1) more durable, 2)

easier/smoother to use, and

3)would be less subject to scoring marks from parting tools, etc.

My biggest concern is that it could "unscrew" itself a little with a catch or normal vibration and turn itself into the line of fire.

I'd certainly appreciate any comments or recommendations in general!

Thanks very much -

David B.

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#2

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Brodie Brickey

>Depending on how old your 1236 is you may be able to get a replacement from Jet at no charge. Its worth a shot at least.

I wouldn't dream of standing in the way of any person buying tools. You may very well decide to get a modular system for the various options it offers when bowl turning anyway. You can also opt to make your own which may give you the bes fit possible. There have been times when I really wanted a 3" curve to the left and straight on the right. Unfortunately, I haven't bought a welder yet so I won't be making my own anytime soon.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#3

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

John Lucas

>David I went with the modular tool rest from Bestwoodtools but I find that I never use the modular part. I just bought stems with each tool rest so that I don't have to change them. I started out with 3 tool rests and 1 stem but very quickly learned that I didn't want to take the time to change them. I've had them for about 5 years now and as far as I can remember only had one come loose in all those years. If I was really concerned with it I would use some locktight on the threads.

The real advantage of the modular system is if you change lathes and have a different tool post size. Then you don't have to buy all new tool rests just replacement tool posts. Been there done that.

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#4

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Leppikallio

>One option, specially if one has welding equipment or a friend who does, is of course make your own toolrests. Then again not everyone is willing to have such a "junk yard monster" as I do :) However I have made three rests so far, short, longer and longish offset rest... some scrap bolts as stems for toolrests and some scrap metal for the rest itself.

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#5

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Dave Belser

>John summed it up pretty good. The modular systems offer a false economy/advantage - just like changeable chuck jaws, the right rest is never screwed on to the post when you want it. My own experience is that I have a number of production procedures that require me to use 2 different rests. I immediately ended up buying a second post. (I also have 2 chuck bodies!). Never had one unscrew and if I was demoing on different lathes I could just by a post if needed.

The Bestwoodtools rests are more durable than cast rests that come with a lathe. As far as the rest getting marked up, you want the rest to be softer than your tools else wise your tools will get marked up! Dressing a tool rest is part of regular maintenance. I know what you mean about parting tools and they will also score the bar rests.

Here is a trick to save your tool rests:

Get a short piece of stiff durable plastic tubing - I used PEX tubing, the kind used for radiant floor heating because I had it lying around (I'll send you a piece if you want). Slit the tubing lengthwise, pry it apart and slip it over the bottom of your parting tool. Works great.

- Dave

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#6

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

David Breth

>I've got a new question based on the responses so far. I was thinking that the round bars would be easier to work with in general, but given the responses I'm not so sure that's true. Is it? Also, when that thick round bar gets dingers in it, it must be more difficult to file out those dingers than it is with the cast tool, right? I was thinking initially that the round bars were hard enough (compared to the cast/standard bar) that it would be harder to get a dinger in the bar. Maybe not...

By the way, Dave, thanks very much for the offer to send tubing. I'll poke around to see what I've got to use for that. Thanks for sharing the idea and your willingness to help!

David B.

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#7

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

John Lucas

>It depends on the bar. Mine doesn't ding very easily but it files right out if it does. There are several brands on the market and I would guess that some could ding easier than others.

So far the only problem I've had with round bars is when using really small tools like 1/4" or 3/16 gouges. There's too much tool hanging over the rest so vibration can be a problem. I haven't had that problem with any other tools.

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#8

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Rich Egan

>David: I purchased a modular system from Woodcraft. They offer several straight and curved rests, and posts to fit most lathe sizes. The posts are not expensive, so you can afford to buy a couple rests and not worry about separating the parts. I've been very happy with it.

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#9

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Ed Heuslein

>Dave, I've tried most of these recommendations. BestWoodTools is a good system. However, I don't care for the round tool rests when doing smaller stuff, as mentioned before - too much tool overhang. At Stuart Batty's recommendation, I purchased some rests for all 3 of my lathes from James Johnson of Kerville (I think), Texas. You can get contact info for him at the AAW web site members page. You can get two of his rests for what you'll pay for a modular system. Ed

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#10

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Pete LaBelle

>Made several tool rests for my old 1236, and now my 1642, out of 1" diameter cold rolled steel. One is 3" wide, one at about 6", one about 5" but offset to one side, and an S-shaped one. Welded the pieces together and have been happy with them. Most steels (unless they are hardened) file easily with a sharp file. Dull files need to be tossed or reworked into new tools.

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#11

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Bill White

>Iusr the Sorby inside, outside, and straight round rest with the screw-on post. Like it a bunch, and have no problems w/ it.

Bill

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#12

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

georgetroy

>In my opinion do not get a cast iron tool rest again like the one that broke on you. Free replacement from Jet or not. You could have had a serious accident. The modular tool rest works, you may need super glue to glue at the shaft to keep from coming loose. Robust Lathes will soon, if not already be making tool rests with a harden steel rod across the top. You can check here for that.

http://www.turnrobust.com/Comfort_Tool_Rests.html

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#13

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Garrett in Victoria BC

>If you have access to a welder - machine or friend - making tool rests is really fast and easy. I took a welding course a few years ago, and the photo below shows my first attempts at putting something together. The welds are very strong but ugly, and I vowed to re-do them when I got better. I did get a lot better at welding, but the rests work well so I never bothered to re-do them.

The post is 1" rod and the rest is 5/8" rod. The gated rest has a pair of removable 1/4" pins.

The first thing I did was drill a 5/8" hole through the 1" post, then I cut through the hole to create a groove for the rest. Set the bar in the groove and weld away. If/when I get around to making another set, instead of drilling a hole in the post material, I'll grind a shallow groove in its face and weld the rest so that it can go tight to the turning.

Cheers, Garrett


img

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

#14

Re: Toolrest Recommendation

Bill Crommett

>Garrett: I have done the same thing, and have found that grinding off the edge makes a good groove for the top bar. I have done many of these, some as long as twelve inches with end pins for getting into deep vases. For the long ones I use one inch cold rolled.