Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Beading Vs Fluting

Posts

Beading Vs Fluting

#1

Beading Vs Fluting

Bruce Forrest

>I'm posting this to show the dramatically different effects that can be achieved form beading vs fluting. I've posted the one on the left before(5239), but not the one on the right(5240). These pieces were nearly adjacent to each other in the log and were turned to the same shape and size. (10 1/2 inches tall and 6 1/4 inches in diameter.). Then one was beaded and the other fluted. Then both were identically dyed with yellow aniline dye and treated with black patinating wax. I think it's quite striking the difference in the grain of the ash which is made by beading vs fluting.

Comments welcome.


img

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

#2

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

Cyril Griesbach

>Dramatic indeed. Forced to make a choice I'd have to go with the fluted one.

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

#3

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

Bernie

>Both are great, I would also choose the fluted one

if I have to.

Bernie

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

#4

Steve Kubien

Love them both but...

Steve Kubien

>...the fluted one a little more so.

Steve Kubien

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

#5

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

jeff myroup

>Bruce

I think the are both very nice, altough for some reason I am drawn to the beaded vessel more. I am not sure why, maybe it is the color. I think the beaded vessel has more warmth, and a richer tone. But then again maybe I am a bead person (lol). It is a nice contrast between the two, considering they have the same finish.

Jeff

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

keith tompkins

>HI Bruce, I would like to see a beaded vessel with larger beads, perhaps progressively getting smaller towards the base and rim. First, it would give a dynamic feel to the piece, and also would allow the color and grain to show through. On the beaded piece in the photo, the beads, being all the same size give a machined or manufactured appearance. That's exactly the opposite effect the fluted piece gives....imagine the fluted piece with each flute only 1/4" at its largest width....it wouldn't work as well as it does now. Hope this helps.....

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

#7

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

Bruce Forrest

>Keith, I've thought about doing larger beads and will probably give them a try. I'm not so sure about varying the size of the beads on a piece of this shape though. It might end up looking as strange as it would if the space between the flutes was varied. I think varying bead size could work on some bowls, but I'm not sure they would work here.

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

#8

Re: Beading Vs Fluting

Bruce Forrest

>Thanks to everyone for the comments. It would seem that flutes are more popular than beads on a piece like this.