Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Just an observation

Posts

Just an observation

#1

Just an observation

Ron in Drums PA

>I find it interesting that a lot that has been said in TD's Thread also applies to this forum.

For me this is my club and and I bet there are others like me. I'd like to hear from some of you.

Re: Just an observation

#2

Re: Just an observation

Stuart Johnson

>As of right now there have been 26 viewers of Ron's message with no response. I guess this sort of proves the point about many not wanting to participate or at least not participate at any given time.

I try to be an active member when possible but when a topic requesting help pops up I rarely have an answer. If a critique is requested my "I like it" is not going to be very helpful. As a result I spend most of my time "being entertained".

Getting everyone in our club (yes I'm like Ron this is my club) might have a few drawbacks. If a club has 50 members and 40 show up for a two hour meeting and 80% choose to be active they would have less than two minutes each to have their say. What would happen to our message club if 80% posted to just half the messages? I know the two minute example isn't all that valid but my point is most clubs couldn't handle that type of active participation.

Re: Just an observation

#3

Re: Just an observation

john lucas

>Stuart It's a little early to make the observation that no one is interested. It's saturday and people are probably out turning, working in the yard or like me just plain working. I just got of work and like always the first thing I do is check with WC. Yea I think this is like a club. You have several people doing a lot of the work, Ron, Ellis, etc and you have the serious core that likes to discuss what's going on and you have the ones that sit back and take it all in and offer an occasional suggestion or tip.

The good thing about this club is you can do it 24/7. The bad thing is that it's much harder to get together although TD did a good job last year and Jennifer is trying to get everyone to Indianapolis.

Re: Just an observation

#4

Re: Just an observation

john lucas

>Stuart Sorry I misred what you were saying. I thought you said no one was participating. What you said was people were reading but not writing. Ooops, my bad as the college kids say.

I think you are assuming that 80 percent participation would mean that they all have something to say. I take active participation in a club as simply being there and willing to help out. Not necessarily jumping in at every question. Yea that would be a nighmare and it does happen sometimes. Still I find it refreshing that people are interested enough to speak up. It's a whole lot better than when you ask the club a question and you could hear a pin drop.

I know sometimes when you open up WC and there is a really long group of posts it's hard to sit there and read them all. That's kind of like the 80 percent participation you mentioned. On the other hand if you happen to be on the computer when these discussions happen it's a lot of fun and quite interesting.

Re: Just an observation

#5

Re: Just an observation

jared

>I guess I too would have to say that this is my club. The closest one that I know of is a two hour drive away and the meetings are always on a saturday and I prefer to spend that time at home with my family. I dont post too often on this forum, I still consider my self something of a novice but most of the skills that I have developed have some sort of root right here. I guess I would rather read most of the time until I have something of substance to add. I would like to thank everyone for their fine information and willingness to help on questions. Jared

Re: Just an observation

#6

Steven Antonucci

Good observation, Ron

steve antonucci

>I guess that I kind of view this as an "online club" with a few annual meetings hosted around the country (Five Barns is the Northeast host.)

One of the techniques I use to engage my audience when I present is to pick out my volunteers (usually the quiet folks along for the ride...) I don't know if it would work here, but we might want to experiment in "our club" with volunteering people to particiapte in some way. You'd be amazed at some of the responses I've gotten with "You in the red shirt! How would YOU set up XXX at your company?" There are no free rides at my seminars...

As an example, I might suggest that one night John Lucas does an online "demo" of making a hand mirror. He could shoot a few shots, and participate in the chat as the leader, but encourage people to interact and answer for him (I try to moderate, not lecture).

When John is done, he might ask for a newbie to do the same for "newbie bowl turning". The newbie will need to show his/her technique, warts and all. Everyone participates, and everyone learns.

What do you think, Ron? Is there room for an online "AAW chapter"?

Steve

Re: Just an observation

#7

Re: Ron, this is as close as I get...

Allen Neighbors

>to being in a club. They're too far for me to travel. I went to one gathering... it was at TD's. It was there that I met some of the nicest people I've ever met. It was also there that I learned the most.

I don't know anything about normal club meetings, since I've never been to one, so I didn't comment on TD's thread. But I have read every post in it, with interest.

I've been involved with four woodturning forums. Only one is more laid back than this one. One of them seems to be very cliquish, and the other one seems to not care much for beginners.

I love to read everybodies posts, and I learn something from most of them, so don't anyone get bent out of shape when I don't mention yours. :) But,

John Lucas' threads always teach me something. Those lessons are like meat and 'taters'... most of it sticks to my ribs.

What I like more than anything on this forum, is when someone explains how they got certain results on a piece... or what tool they used to do this certain cut... Any post that is a teaching post is a good post, in my opinion. (Telling me how 'not' to do something is also a teaching post).

I'd like to see more explanations... from anyone... because I want to learn. Somethings are impossible for me to do, (using a steady hand on the skew, for instance) but there are a lot of things that are explained to such an extent that I can sometimes find another way to do the same thing.

Sorry this is so long.

When the folks on this forum welcomed this newbie, and invited me to come to TD's, it made me want to participate. What I received down there in Georgia far outweighed the cost of diesel. And getting good critiques on form and technique from this forum, have helped my turning abilities to improve. I think that type of attitude is necessary for this forum to keep newbies involved, and growing, so that they can help more newbies. Promotion and betterment of the craft/art, so to speak.

As Minnie Pearl says, "I'm through talkin' now."

Re: Just an observation

#8

Re: Just an observation

Bill Stehman

>Great post Ron and an interesting observation. I too am far removed from a club but think I would find one less than satisfying over time so WC has become my club with limited participation depending on the subject. I pick and chose subjects to participate in which fits me and my experience. Ellis carried on and has created a wonderful means for turners to communicate and share. With people like yourself willing to carry the ball further makes this the premier online experience and a club within itself. Thanks much to everyone.

Bill

Re: Just an observation

#9

Re: Just an observation

George Van

>Ron, I guess I'm the very interested member type who wishes he had more time to turn. I am building and finishing my last house which is coming along well, we started by dropping the trees on our woodlot. I should be able to finish the tile in a month or so and hope to be finished in a year. When the house is done I look forward to giving back a little and contributing more.

I am treasurer of a great two year old AAW group which meets monthly but I still use WC as my daily fix over coffee. Most days I barely have time to read all the posts much less reply to many. Even though I am a very slow typer, I do reply if I see an unanswered question or on subjects I feel my experiences give me information to contribute. Once in a while I even find time to turn and then I post photos to show that I am a turner and the progress I am making. I am grateful for the leaders in this group for �carring the ball� while I complete my project!

Re: Just an observation

#10

Al, when I get discouraged....

TDaniel

>because of those who are always ready to critisize anyone who does things differently from the way they were taught, either in our club meeting or here, I frequently think of you. The look on your face when you made your first real curls here at the Gathering was priceless. This is a club....no doubt about it, and in any club there will be givers and takers....there will be those who enjoy helping others to learn and there will be those who only want the world to recognize how smart they are...egos, fame seekers, etc. Each member of "this club" has to sort it out for themselves but there are a lot of people who come here to learn and to help others learn; there are also some who I have learned (finally) to just ignore; it is the same in our local club meeting. I used to read every post; now I only read posts from those I do not know or those who I have learned to respect, (I always read yours). The 80% of each club that several have mentioned as doing nothing is the backbone of any club, this one included. Beginners are not going to step out in front and lead and they should not. There is a time to listen and a time to lead. We have people in our local club that have sat quietly for 3 years as they absorbed info and now they are becoming confident enough to participate more in the functions of the club. I don't like hearing the phrase that 10 or 20 per cent do all the work. Sure, there are some who enjoy leading more than others but all are important. Remember the phrase "too many chiefs and not enough Indians"?, this applies to turning clubs too. Maybe what we need is more "Indians".

Re: Just an observation

#11

PS

TDaniel

>A special thanks to Wally and Russ who I think are a couple of the best "givers" in this club. They have unselfishly shared their knowledge with us for a long time and I never get the feeling that it is to build their "resume'. They are just good guys!

TD

Re: Just an observation

#12

Re: Just an observation

Ron in Drums PA

>Jared

A lot of what I learned came from WC also, so I know what you are saying. Please don't hesitate to speak up, there are always newbie turners that can profit form your help.

Steve

You have some good thoughts there. The online AAW chapter has been kicked around before, how would you go about organizing one? The �online� demo is something I tried to get off the ground before. I asked a few turners if they where interested, while they said ok it never came to fruit. (If anybody is interested about doing an online demo please contact me)

Allen

I remember when you first started posting on WC, you�ve come a long way. I also read with interest how you modifications you made. The problem is it is lost. Would you like to work with me to setup a webpage with some of your ideas?

Bill

You are one of my favorite lurkers, you turn some awesome segmented forms. Maybe you would be interested in doing something online, or maybe a featured turner on a chat?

George

I�ve been swamped at work, so lately I�ve only have had time to read. I�ve always wondered if there are two John Lucas. How else can he keep up?

Re: Just an observation

#13

Ditto on Wally and Russ

john lucas

>

Re: Just an observation

#14

Re: Just an observation

jeff myroup

>This is about as close to a club that I have been. I approached the closest club to me, about an hour away. I did not get a very good impression of them. I had to email the president 3 times about info. I did not get much back. They have no website, and are very small. Do to the fact that I work on call 24/7, I can not make plans for today let alone a week or month out. I am completely self taught. Well thats not true, all my training is from websites and books. Like alot of others I read more than I post. I have only met a couple of other turners, they happen to work at the local woodcraft. I have been kicking around the idea of getting one started here in NW Indiana, but have no idea of what needs to be done. Any way sorry for the ramblings, I am trying to wake up and have only had a half cup of coffee. Some day I hope to be able to give more than I take, but for now I am just a sponge.

Jeff

Re: Just an observation

#15

Re: Ron, this is as close as I get...

C.W.Stivison

>I have been turning for 4 months and I have learned alot on WC and don't post as much as I should but I agree with Allen about John Lucas. He must be as old as Wally to have gained that much knowledge about so many things. I admire Wally's work and the ladies of WC are also very talented.There are so many talented craftspeople on this site and they all are willing to help. Thanks for having me.

CW

Re: Just an observation

#16

Re: Ron, this is as close as I get...

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>John is not older than dirt! Wally may be. I feel that way most days because I'm almost as old as dirt. John is just a fast learner. HaHa

Bill

Re: Just an observation

#17

Re: Just an observation

George Van

>Ron, I also have been wondering about John. He sure helps a lot and just shortly mailed out all those photo lessons. Maybe he doesn�t have a real job but just pretends so we don't get jealous because he�s retired and we still have to work? ;-)

Re: Just an observation

#18

Re: Ron, I appreciate the ...

Allen Neighbors

>compliment. I'm still trying to improve a little each piece, but sometimes I fail, sometimes I win.

Most everything I've done is just a modification of someone else's idea or invention. I'm not very creative in my own right, but I am lazy, and if something will make things easier, I'm all for giving it a shot. :)

I'm not sure which modifications you're talking about... not even sure that I should have posted some of them... but if you'll let me know which ones you're referring to, and if you think someone would get some good out of them, I'd be glad to let you set it up. You can email me if you like.

Re: Just an observation

#19

Re: Ron, I appreciate the ...

Ron in Drums PA

>I wrote that this morning before my coffee kicked in.

Two things come to mind.

one was a tool rest and the other was a hollowing tool rig you made

Re: Just an observation

#20

Re: Understood... let me know the time.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Just an observation

#21

Re: Ron, I appreciate the ...

Bob Fawcett

>Allen,

Your post reminded me of the old master machinist I once worked for between HS and college. He was an amazing man. He once said if you want to know the easiest way to get a job done, put the lazy man on the job. He will soon figure out the easiest way to do a job.

We had a rolling machine. A large set of rollers that would roll a sheet of steel into a cylinder. It was turned manually with a large "ships wheel". He sent the "lazy man" out to roll some steel for navigation buoys we were building. This guy rolled about 2/3 of cylinder, went into the shop, got a short piece of 1" square stock and welded it to the center of the wheel. Next, he pulled the Rigid pipe threading machine out and connected it to the rolling machine with a drive shaft we had for the oversize pipe addition for the Rigid. In 15 minutes we had a powered rolling machine.

Re: Just an observation

#22

Re: Ron, this is as close as I get...

Bill Crommett

>And What's the matter with dirt ?

Re: Just an observation

#23

email sent

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Just an observation

#24

Re: LOL, Bob.

Allen Neighbors

>He sounds like my kind of guy!