Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Posts

Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#1

Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>It's time to mill the tang on some scrapers and skews. The stock is 5/16 thick, I finally had the sheet cut into strips 1/2, 3/4 1", 1-1/4.

The 1/2 and 3/4 wide scrapers/skew will have a tang 2 inches long, 3/8 wide.

The 3/4 and 1-1/4 wide strips will have a tang 2 inches long,

1/2 wide.

Now the question;

The plan right now is to make the tang straight OR should I taper it?

Would you change the width of the tang/ Remember the stock is 5/16 thick.

Thoughts or comments...

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#2

Bob Moffett

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Bob Moffett

>Doug, I think I would taper the tang. It seems like it would stay in the handle better if it were tapered.

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

keith tompkins

>Hi Doug, straight would be great for an aftermarket handle, such as a Kelton or Oneway. I may be interested in one of those myself......1 1/4" skew with a straight tang....feel free to email me with a price.

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#4

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Jorge Castaneda

>Hi Doug,

I second Keith's opinion, I like to make my handles so I can take the handle away when I go to the grinder.

If you have prices, ping me...

Thanks!

Jorge

By the way, due to too much work I had not a chance until this evening, I did open the tube with the spindle gouge and gave it a spin, very nice! thanks again.

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#5

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

john lucas

>Doug I don't see any particular advantage to an angled tang. I know that's the way they were done for years but I think a straight tang would be easier for most turners to mount in a handle. If you wanted to make a metal handle a straight tang would be much easier because you could simply drill a hole and install it with epoxy.

Please put me down for one also. I'd like to try a 1" or 1 1/4" skew.

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#6

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

robo hippy

>For my scraper handles, I make them 3 piece. The middle piece is the same thickness as the bar stock, and the outside pieces round out the handle. I cut the apropriate notch in the center piece to exactly match the tang on the scraper. Personally, the bigger the tang, the better, up to about 1 1/4 inch as that is how big I like my handles. I am very agressive on stock removal when bowl turning with them.

robo hippy

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#7

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>So far the straight tang is ahead. The reason I asked this question is because all the tangs need to be the same. Both have strong points.

Robo, that's the cool part about this I could make almost anything.

Tomorrow I'll decide.

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#8

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Fog Tanner

>Doug,

As long as there is a radius where the tang meets the main part of the blade, straight should work as well as anything else. I often round the corners of the tangs to fit the holes in the handles I make. I think the straight tang would solve a lot of problems in that area. I will have a handle made this weekend for when you ship ....

I'm in for 2 of the 1/2" and one of the 3/4" skews. Will send you and e-mail with more.

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#9

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Philip Duffy

>My vote is for straight tangs, for the principle reason that John stated, he got it right. Grinding off to a taper is a simple matter of a couple minutes on the wheel whereas you can secure a straight tang in a heavy, changeable handle. Sure to want a good solid skew! Phil

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#10

Why did the tapered tang start?

john lucas

>I'm guessing that is started when things were made my the blacksmith. You could drill a hole the size of the small end of the tang and then heat it and drive it in. This would make a rectangular hole which would keep the blade from twisting. Does this sound correct? With a straight tang you could still do the same thing but the hole would have to be larger. With our modern adhesives this isn't necessary.

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#11

You got that right

Jorge Castaneda

>

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

#12

Re: Let's talk TANGS - Poll

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I agree with John about straight tangs. Drilling a stepped hole for a tapered tang is a real pain and very easy to mess up. Straight tang are so much nicer.

Maybe that is why modern tools like bowl gouges come with straight tangs.