Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

What sharpening system to choose...

Posts

What sharpening system to choose...

#1

What sharpening system to choose...

Stephen Gehres

>I've read what I could find about sharpening systems in the archives, but they were a bit dated and there are some new machines out now... So here's that $64,000 question again.

Currently I only have a 6" bench grinder with the cheap grey wheels. It looks like this will be of no use for turning tools. So, I guess I need to start from scratch on something that will work. It looks like my options are to get a complete Tormek or Jet slow water-cooled system, or a slow or VS 8" bench grinder along with a system of jigs such as the Wolverine. Which route will make the most sense over the long haul?

Here's a few items that I've been looking at:

- Until the end of this month, Hartville Tool has the complete Wolverine system (basic sys + vari-grind jig, skew jig, and dressing jig) for $199, INCLUDING three $20 DVDs for free (Turning Wood, Turning Boxes, & Turning Projects).

- PSI has a clone of the Wolverine complete system for $114, but it doesn't offer a dressing attachment.

- CSUSA offers the WoodCut and Kelton systems, but the Kelton doesn't offer a dressing attachment, and the Woodcut's doesn't look as precise as the Wolverine's.

- If I go the slow water route, the Jet system is $100 cheaper than the Tormek, and another $50 cheaper for the turning accessories. Are these two systems comparable?

- Rockler has the "Work Sharp Wood Tool Sharpener" (http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=17398) that is a flat platter type system for $200. It is 'air-cooled', not 'wet'. It doesn't say anything on their website about turning tools, but it is mentioned on Hartville's and the manufacturer's sites. Not to any detail though. Anyone know anything about this puppy?

- Rockler also has the "Delta Industrial Model 23-710 Sharpening Center" for $160 (http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=10087) which has a horizontal wet, and a vertical dry wheel. It DOES mention lathe tools, but doesn't say much about them. Comments?

- Woodcraft has the "WOODCRAFT Horizontal Wet Stone Grinder" for $95 (http://www.woodcraft.com/family.aspx?FamilyID=4866&cs=4605). Again, it doesn't say anything about turning tools. Anyone?

- PSI has the "Slow Speed Wet/Dry Grinder w/ Accu-sharp grinding jig" for $200. It has both 10" wet, and 5" dry wheels. Again, nothing about turning tools. Comments?

- As for bench grinders. Would I prefer a VS or slow 1725 rpm unit? Or will the standard 3450 rpm unit do just as well.

Also, I've got the Beall 3-on buffing system (for the lathe) so I won't need the bench grinder to do double duty. Unless I use it for honing.

Oh, my pen turning tools have carbide tips (about 1" at end of each tool) so what do I do about them? There was no documentation with them (Benjamin's Best from PSI).

Thanks,

Steve

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#2

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I sharpen a lot of tools and the oneway wolverine is the only jig you'll need.

An 8 inch grinder works well with this jig because the centerline is close to the height needed to set the jig up. Besides the wolverine was made to use with a 8 inch grinder but you could adapt a 6 inch grinder.

High speed or slow speed... that is the question. I have a wolverine setup on both and find a slow speed grinder more relaxing to use. The slow speed will touch up the edge in the same time as a high speed grinder and remove less steel.

Burning a tool is not caused by wheel speed but by using to much pressure and that needs to be learned.

I grind 40 or 50 tools from scratch at one sitting so a high speed grinder is the only way to go. For your turning needs a slow speed is best.

To grind my personal tools I have a old 6 inch high speed grinder with a 120 grit green wheel... no jigs.

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#3

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

RevDoug

>All the thoughts you have are good ones. I can only tell you what I use. For a grinder, I use the Woodcraft slow speed grinder with white wheels, 80 and 120 grits. Attatched is the Wolverine jig with the vari-grind for the bowl gouges and skew attatchment for my skew.

If you go this way, have the salesperson at Woodcraft plug up the grinder so that you can make sure that it is balanced. Some aren't. This step will only save you a second trip to the store to exchange it.

Turn 'em round,

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#4

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

Ron McKinley

>Rev. Doug, what does "plug up the grinder" mean? Thanks......Ron

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#5

Re: What sharpening system to choose... *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Get an 8" grinder. Slow or fast will work. Look at this site and make a jig, or purchase the Wolverine.


Darrell Feltmate's site

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#6

Re: And the Woodcraft 8" grinder is on sale!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#7

Bob Moffett

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

Bob Moffett

>I agree with RevDoug. I use the same setup and have found it very servicable. By Plugging up, he means to have them plug the grinder into a power source and turn it on to check that it runs smooth.

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#8

Visions of V8 commercial running thru my head.....

RevDoug

>

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#9

Re: Kentuckian for, "plug in". :)

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#10

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

Cyril Griesbach

>I use the Woodcraft 8" slow speed grinder with the Wolverine system and I don't think it can be beat for the cost. If the grinder is now on sale that's surely a plus. They do go on sale frequently and the wheels that come with it are just fine. It would appear that the Hartville deal on the Wolverine is a good one especially if you really want the DVD's. If you'll be going to turning schools to learn from some of the many teachers available, I'd bet that you will run into more Wolverine setups than any other jig based sharpening system. Therefore, you can just take your vari-grind and some measurements from your base arm and easily reproduce the grind you like to use.

Beyond that, it also depends on what other kind of wood working tools you will need to sharpen. The Work Sharp system is made by the folks who make the Drill Doctor and you should be able to find a video of it in action on their web site. I will sharpen turning and carving tools but without the use of jigs. If you're new to sharpening turning tools free hand sharpening can become a costly, although worth while, learning experience.

I surely would not suggest the Delta system. My experience with it indicates a lot of instability and again, free hand sharpening.

If you want the wet system I'd at least look closely at the new Jet clone of the Tormek if for no other reason than the reduced cost. My guess is the Tormek patent has expired and thus so has their hold on this market.

I hope this helps.

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#11

Tormek vs. Jet

wilbur

>I bought a Tormek. The main reasons I went with a Tormek as opposed to the dry grinder systems were:

1. I am very happy that I am not spewing grinder wheel and metal dust all over my shop.

2. I felt that I had more control over the sharpening process, since it was slower. Some will see this as a disadvantage. But I have been able to take a completely dull tool to shave-your-armhair-sharp in about 5 minutes, and I've learned that touchups frequently is a much better way of keeping your tools sharp. It seems to me that for quick touchups, there really is not much of a speed difference between a grinder and a Tormek.

As far as the Tormek vs. the Jet, the Jet is cheaper, but one of the keys to this style of sharpening is ensuring that the tool rest bar is perpendicular to the wheel. I've read more than a few reports of the Jet not being made to the same level of precision as the Tormek.

Re: What sharpening system to choose...

#12

I have a Tormek and Woodcraft

Stuart Johnson

>slow speed with the Wolverine. Since I bought the Woodcraft and added the Wolverine system the Tormek is only used for my Wife's sewing scissors, planer blades and knives. It can't be beat for those items.