Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

bandsaw tensioning

Posts

bandsaw tensioning

#1

bandsaw tensioning

John Lucas

>I've always had trouble getting the right tension on my bandsaw blade. I've used the method illustrated in FWW which uses 2 pieces of metal clamped to the blade and then use a feeler gauge to measure the distance between them. Adjust the blade until the gap increases "X" number of thousandths and them mark it on the saw housing. This is close but not perfect.

Then I tried running the saw guard all the way up and watching the blade flutter. Tension until the flutter stops and add 1 more turn. That worked pretty good but still not great.

I have a riser block on my lathe and the guard that covers the exposed portion of the blade on the left side is open so I can see the blade. If I watch the flutter on this portion and then do the same 1 turn increase I get a much better cut.

Has anyone else done this. This is a relatively new saw for me so I'm still getting used to it.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#2

That's one scary lathe...

dwr

>... that can run a bandsaw blade!

However, the efficiency of cutting a bowl blank on the lathe and then go straight to turning without skipping a beat makes it worth the risk...;)

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#3

Re: bandsaw tensioning

Peter Hyde

>John, I have an older Canadian Rockwell/Delta with a riser and have used the same procedures for tensioning. I really can't say which one I prefer and currently it is a matter of if it sounds right and cuts right then that's good enough. The flutter system certainly seems to be the most technically right way to do it, especially for me as someone who recycles used blades from a bigger machine and resizes and sharpens as needed. I found the best thing I ever did was to get the Duginski bandsaw book and do a tune up.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#4

Re: bandsaw tensioning

John Lucas

>Peter I've always tuned my bandsaws using his method. I just haven't had time to do this one yet. It cuts better than anything I've had so far. It's about an 8 year old Delta 14 with riser block.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#5

oops: I meant riser on my bandsaw. :)

John Lucas

>

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#6

Technically....

wilbur

>Technically, you could say it's a lathe with a very large diameter spindle that is also very short. :@)

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#7

Re: bandsaw tensioning

wilbur

>John,

The flutter procedure that you describe is exactly how I tension bandsaw blades on my bandsaw as well (16" Walker-Turner).

The other thing to keep in mind is that the range of useful tensions for any given blade is very wide. You do have to get the blade into a useful range, but this is not a precision engineering type of adjustment. As long as you are getting the type of cut you want, you've got the right blade tension.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#8

Re: bandsaw tensioning

Russ Fairfield

>Re: bandsaw tensioning

Russ Fairfield -- Friday, 25 May 2007, at 1:37 p.m.

The best tension is the least tension that will keep the blade so you can follow a straight line without it wandering. There is no way to find the best tension for any given circumstance before pushing the wood into the saw. All of the published methods will get you close, but the desired tension will be different for different species and cutting depth, and for different blade widths. tooth profiles, TPI, and how sharp the blade is. The only way to sort out all of these variables is to fine tune the tension while cutting in the wood. This is easy to do. If the blad wanders, there is not enough tension and I crank in a little more. If I get those wavy lines at 45-degrees across the wood surface, there is too much tension and I need to back off until it goes away.

How hard the wood is pushed into the blade has a pronounced effect on the surface of the cut wood. A blade that is pushed hard enough to load up the gullets can't vibrate. A light touch and a lightly loaded gullet will always vibrate. This makes the balance between feed rate and TPI and important variable.

Then the width of the blade comes into play. I always use the widest blade possible that will follow the smallest radius I want to cut.

All of this works best on a saw without a riser block. Add the riser block and the dynamics of the saw frame change, the frame is more flexible, and it is more difficult to find the "sweet spot" on the tension knob, if it is possible to find it at all.

Another problem with almost every 14" bandsaw that that has ever been made in the old Delta-Rockwell style, is the top wheel slide. If the top wheel cannot travel up and down freely in the slide, there is no way that the tension spring can follow the changing length of the blade from temperature and load. Take the top wheel off, clean up the castings with a flat file and a slipstone, lightly lubricate it (I use Lubriplate lithium grease) and you will find that tensioning is much easier and doesn't change as the blade gets warm. While the top wheel is off, a good investment is the Inturra or Olson tension spring. Woodcraft sells the Olson. These spring have a spring constant that is more constant across a normal range of movement than those from the factory and they will not relax with age like those that come with the saws.

There ain't no simple answer.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#9

It all depends

Russ Fairfield

>It all depends on what you are doing. If it cuts, doesn't bind, and removes sawdust, it is good enough for roughing green wood into turning blanks.

I can follow what I have described and make bandsaw cuts that are glueable with Titebond-2 straight off the saw blade. It can be done.

Most folks will be somewhere between these extremes.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#10

Re: It all depends

John Lucas

>Thanks Russ. I'm always fighting a little because I'm sawing green wood into blanks one day and trying to resaw wood or cutting delicate curves the next. I change blades of course. I really need a better bandsaw but this one will have to do for now.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#11

Sniff!, Hurt my feelings

Barry Irby

>I have the same bandsaw. I thought it was a fine tool. NOT! I guess I need a better one too. Actually, two or three more. One for resawing and one for bowl blanks and another for whatever else a bandsaw would saw if a bandsaw would saw wood.

I have the Iturra spring on mine. And several other "upgrades". I think the spring was a good thing. I just crank up the tension. I need lessons. Did not know there were all these subleties.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#12

Re: Sniff!, Hurt my feelings

John Lucas

>I'm with you Barry. I need a metal cutting bandsaw also. Never pass up a chance to buy a new tool.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#13

JL

Re: Do you have good relative pitch?

JL

>Mike "tunes" his blades to a particular pitch depending on their width. It seems to work for him. I don't know if he carries a pitch pipe or not :).

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#14

Playing the tension tune

Russ Fairfield

>Plucking the tensioned band is the surest way to determine its tension.

What we are trying to measure is the stress level in the tightened band, and that is defined in Pounds per square inch (PSI). There are differences in opinion in what the actual tension level we are using should be. Mine is 12,500 PSI. Plucking the unsupported band on the back side of the wheels while twisting the tension wheel until I hear the low E-flat below the bass clef will always be 12,500 PSI. Raising the tone to the low bass clef G tone will bring it in at 14,500 PSI that others recommend. There is nothing to measure, nothing to buy, nothing to calculate, and it is dead-on accurate every time, regardless of the blade width, thickness, the tooth profile, or the steel it is made from.

All of the other measuring methods depends on our accurately measuring something, the distance the blade is stretched, the deflection, the bl;ade, or whatever, and then calculating the tension in PSI from the blade dimensions.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#15

Re: bandsaw tensioning

Jim Eddy

>The proper tension depends on the blade. Different manufacturers and blades are spec'd to go to different degrees of tension. The Lenox blades I run on my saw are high tension blades, and typically run at around 30,000 PSI. The Timberwolf blades are supposedly designed to run at a low tension. Timberwolf is the blade that is tensioned by the "flutter" method. Many people have had great success with them, tensioning as recommended. I was disappointed with them when I tried them. The Woodslicer blades I run are spec'd to tension at 15,000 PSI (according to Louis Iturra).

You may wish to call the manufacturer of the blades you're running to get the optimum tension. I use the "feeler gauge" method of tensioning someone referred to earlier, except I use a cheap dial indicator that I spring clamp to the blade, bearing on a long piece of scrap that is clamped with another spring clamp 8-10 inches from the first clamp. It's now a poor man's tension gauge that works quite well. The one truth is that the tension gauge built into the saw is worthless for setting tension on a blade initially.

Louis Iturra of Iturra Design puts out a catalog that has a wealth of info on the bandsaw--especially the Delta and Jet saws. He's a good guy to work with.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#16

Re: bandsaw tensioning

John Scheideman

>John,

I agree with Russ. There are many factors involved and no one method is sure-fire for everything you want to cut. I had that same saw with a riser for years and never could seem to get the tension exactly right no matter what I did. I finally sold it and bought a MiniMax a couple years ago and have been much happier. I did use Timber Wolf but have recently switched blades. I now buy them through MiniMax and tension them somewhat like Russ described.....more by feel than by any particular method. That seems to work for me. The "tone" method is useless for me. I never could get that to work (even before my hearing started to worsen after too many years in the shop!) Good luck......and save up for that MiniMax!!!

John

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#17

I'm also thinking of getting a new TS....

Barry Irby

>Just like on a bandsaw, once you get a tablesaw setup, you are better off leaving it alone, all tuned up for that one job, at least until the temperature or humidity changes. So from now on, once I lock the fence in place, I'm leaving it set up, in case I need to rip something just like that again. For my next cut, I'll just get a new TS. Soon, I will have one set up for any cut I might need to make. If I could just figure out which one it is.

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#18

Re: Playing the tension tune

Barry Irby

>My brother plays the guitar. With five thumbs on each hand, I don't. I saw him tune one with a little device that I believe listened to the tone and displayed what it was. The gadget was not as big a pack of cigarets. If that is indeed what it did, I wonder if you could use one to "tune" a bandsaw?

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#19

Re: Playing the tension tune

wilbur

>The gadget was probably a guitar tuner. Many of them come with a built in microphone and will display the note that is being played.

This is the one that I have, although I haven't tried tensioning my bandsaw with it. The microphone is in the lower left hand corner.


img

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#20

Re: Russ- do you have a hearing aid....

Jamie Donaldson

>... tuned to the E-flat you prefer? Adjusting the tension by pitch does require a standard for comparison, and I would rather use a blade adjusted to B-sharp! ;-)))

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#21

Re: Read all about it *LINK*

Russ Fairfield

>This article by Lonnie Bird takes the BS out of tensioning.


http://www.taunton.com/finewoodworking/pages/w00013.asp

Re: bandsaw tensioning

#22

For the DIY gadget freaks *LINK*

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>With a metal lathe, you can fabricate a hydraulic tension indicator for your bandsaw. At the page linked below, scroll down a ways past the "show and tell" pics. It reads directly in pounds of tension, using a standard pressure gauge.

At the very bottom of the page, is another gadget for the wood lathe whose usefulness has been debated many times: an RPM indicator.


Bandsaw Blade Tension Readout