Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

Posts

Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#1

Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

Barry Irby

>Ruth had a face plate stuck and many of us tried to help. Then she discovered a noise that we suspect is a damaged bearing. With apologies to Ruth, I am borrowing her troubles to ask a few questions.

If there is a dimple or "Brunell" in the bearing race because of an impact to the shaft would it tend to "run out" or improve with use? I'm thinking that there might be a little dimple with the corresponding little "ridges" of displaced material around it. So if you ran the lathe, wouldn't the balls in the bearings tend to mash the little ridges back down and at least eliminate that part of the problem? That is, instead of the ball have to go up over the wall, down into the crater, and up over the other wall, it would just be left with the little dimple. Seems like it would smooth out a little. How bad would it have to be to cause the bearing to lock up?

Did heating the shaft have anything to do with this? How hot do you have to heat a bearing race to soften the steel and make it more likely to cause a dimple?

One of my suggestions was to file a notch in the edge of the face plate and set a chisel in the notch and hit it sharply. My thinking was that this would impart a rotary force to the faceplate with less of the force being perpendicular on the shaft and at right angles to the bearings, thus less likely to cause a dimple. The force needs to be rotary. I don't suppose there is any way to support the shaft while we give it a whack? On my lathe none of the shaft is exposed when the face plate is on. Wonder if it would help to put a block of some sort of metal or hardwood under the face plate and then put a wrench on it?

Just sort of musing here, I realize we should do those things necessary to avoid getting things stuck on the shaft.

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#2

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

TDaniel

>Barry, there are many ways to loosen parts that are bound. I think Ruth did everything possible before going to the heat and ice. There is always a risk of damaging the bearing seals when using heat. If a bearing is damaged it will not fix itself. I am guessing that the outer case (race) of the bearing was cracked by impact and this quickly caused wear on the bearings. To free a part it is best to start with steady rotational force along with some type of fluid for freeing parts, then try sharp impact (rotational again), and when all else fails go to the heat and ice. Sometimes the shocks are going to exceed the limits of the bearings.

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#3

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

Wilford Bickel

>Once I got my reversible lathe I put set screws in all of my face plates and chucks so I could reverse and sand. I soon found out that locking the set screw prevented the faceplate/chucks from tightening up and getting stuck. I now just snug the faceplate/chuck up on the spindle and then lock the set screw no matter what I am doing. The set screws have essentially stopped any stuck faceplate/chucks! Even without reverse I would recommend putting set screws to lock the faceplate/chucks for use on all lathes as this should stop them from getting stuck and causing all these problems! It is really easy to drill and tap the shoulders of the inserts and faceplates to install set screws. Much easier than what Ruth has been through!

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#4

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

Jimmy Edwards

>Barry I would like to help but here in the oilfield there are only 4 solutions to any malfunction--beat on it, run into it or stab it, or wash it down.

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#5

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

DD

>The dimple you refer to will start to create a stress raisor on the bearing race or rolling element. Repeated hits of the dimple by each of the rolling elements in the bearing, will, over time cause the material at the site of the dimple to fail in fatigue. Fatigue failure will cause a "spall" to occur at the site of the dimple and small particles of metal will be shed, creating a tiny hole where the dimple was. Over time the hole (or spall) will get larger, as the edges of hole also fail in fatigue and shed more metal. For sealed bearings, this is a problem because all of the bits of metal are now being circulated around all areas of the bearing race and rolling elements, with the potential of additional "dimples" being created as this loose material is trapped between a rolling element and the race (and hence more fatigue failure sites). For pressurized oil lubricated bearings, it is also a problem, but the particles get flushed out of the bearing by the oil flow. Over time however, the spall will likely grow, but is dependent upon a whole host of factors.

You're correct in saying the dimple will disappear, but in so doing, the hill of the dimple will turn into the valley of the spall and lead to the eventual failure of the bearing.

Doug

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#6

Barry, you don't have to borrow my troubles

Ruth Niles

>you can keep them, FREE!

This afternoon a machinist stopped by (to buy a handgun not for the lathe) he saw my shop, we got talking, when he told me he was a retired machinist, I asked him about my lathe. He turned the wheel and no matter where he let it got it rotated a bit or bounced back, he said there was no grabbiness nor rough spots. He said he thought when I heated the faceplate, the grease melted and dripped out. Someone here also made that observation, which made a lot of sense to me.

He suggested buying a bearing (or two if I want to replace both) and just keep them in the shop for 2 reasons. First I'd have the bearing before I took the headstock apart. Second, if I'm prepared and have the spare bearings, the General will run for 15 years and not get any worse.

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#7

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>IMO the problem Ruth had removing the faceplate was caused because she didn't have an extra pair of hands to hold the spindle while she gave the faceplate a good wrap. Two people could have done it easily.

IMO again, who cares if a bearing makes noise unless it drives you nuts. Bearings do go bad and there is no reason to stop using the lathe if you hear a noise. Plan to change them when you have time and if it does lock up you OK unless the inside/outside race spin, even if that happens it's not a costly fix. This is only a lathe with very little stress on the bearings, that's why they use cheap bearings... because they can.

It's been said before heat will melt a rubber seal but won't damage the steel. Bearings need lubrication to work... take that away they generate heat and fail.

If your replacing a bearing don't run a screwdriver, punch or anything through the seal. If you do buy a new one.

Now what was you question...

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#8

Re: Barry, you don't have to borrow my troubles

Bob Fawcett

>Ruth,

This sounds like good advice to me. Have them on hand and change when you are ready. They are not that expensive.

Re: Stuck Face Plate, damaged bearing Questions.

#9

Re: Barry, you don't have to borrow my troubles

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Ruth,

That reminds me of when we bought our '82 Nissan 4wd pickup. Not too long after we bought it, one of the salesmen at the dealership where I worked was telling me about the problems with front wheel bearings in that particular vehicle. Only a few thousand miles before the bearings would go out.

Naturally, I went and bought a complete set of wheel bearings for the truck so that I would be ready when the inevitable occurred. When I finally sold the truck it had over 300,000 miles on it and was still running on the original wheel bearings, as well as the original clutch. Which just goes to show, if you have the parts, Murphy is not as likely to show up.

Hope things work out as well on your General.

Gary