Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Dye- Fade Proof?

Posts

Dye- Fade Proof?

#1

Dye- Fade Proof?

George Van

>From what I read by searching archives I assume all dyes will fade somewhat over time and exposure to oxygen and UV light. Which dyes are the most fade resistant? I believe there is a difference between water and alcohol dyes. Our club has the chance to do a group buy on smaller quantities but I would not want to get the wrong dye and regret it.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#2

Dye- Fade Proof?

nailshooter

>George - I do a lot of finishing as a repair and remodel contractor. For cabinets and stained/dyed woodwork, I only use dye when I can get away with it. I have found it to be quick, easy to apply, and with a little fine tuning you can turn out some beautiful, natural looking finishes. I started using dye to speed up the wood coloration processes in the field.

After a lot of testing, including testing for color fast ability in a high UV environment, I only use Behlen's Solar Lux. It is alcohol based so it dries rapidly, and it shoots well with a gun. To get more natural colors with the product, I only shoot it on, I don't wipe. YMMV.

I looked and and tried other products, but the only other close contender was J. Jewitt's Trans Tint product. But I was warned off of this on a finishing forum as one of the guys there had problems with fading on a table top that was sitting in a window are that got a lot of sun. In about three years most of the top was a different color than than the legs and sides.

I pointed out to him that there is a disclaimer on the bottle that says it isn't UV/light resistant.

I put Behlens SL on exterior doors, cabinets, etc., and have never had a problem. It seems like $12 for a pint is a little expensive, but I cut it by 2/3 to 1/2 with anhydrous alcohol to shoot it out of a fine nozzle or air cap. Never had a problem.

Robert

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#3

Re: Dye- Fade Proof? *LINK*

Rick Allen

>I use MX reactive dyes. I am more interested in bright colors than color matching some existing wood.

The reactive dyes react with cellulose at the molecular level. So these dyes are very colorfast.

The amount of powdered dye you use is very small.

Here is some information about reactive dyes from the cloth dyeing point of view. Note that many good links are provided.

http://www.pburch.net/dyeing/fiberreactive.shtml

The link below is to a place that I have purchased MX reactive dye from in the past. This is NOT the only place to buy MX reactive dye!


ProChemical MX reactive dyes

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#4

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

George Van

>Thanks Robert, I will look at the Behlens site.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#5

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

George Van

>Thanks Rick, I assume you use the Pro MX reactive? After viewing the site I felt led in that direction.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#6

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

Rick Allen

>Yes the Procion MX reactive dyes.

After using the Prismacolor pens and having the color run when I wiped on an oil finish I was ready to give up coloring my turnings.

The MX dye has made a huge difference. Bright vibrant colors (white wood is a lot brighter than tan or darker woods). The dye will follow the grain. So you have to block the transmition of the dye with something. I have found wood burning to be effective at stopping the bleed of dye.

For $20 you will get 4 or 5 colors to use. Those 2oz jars will last you the rest of your woodturning life.

Good Luck

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#7

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

John Lucas

>George Gary Sanders from Texas did a test on dyes fading. He placed several boards with dye patches of all colors in the dash of his truck. After a month none but the metalized dyes were even recognizable. I don't what brands he used however. I believe Binh Pho did some research and came to the same conclusions.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#8

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

Chuck Engstrom

>I attended Binh Pho's demos last year in Louisville and he mentioned dyes discussed at www.lmii.com. Look in the FINISHING drop-menu at upper left and go to DYES then DYE CONCENTRATES. At the bottom of that page is a discussion of their characteristics. I haven't tried them so I can only report the link.

Also on that site is some good discussion of water-born lacquer-type finishes.

Best--

Chuck Engstrom

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#9

Thanks Rick!

George Van

>

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#10

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

George Van

>Thanks John, that is good information. I will have to read on metalized dye. It would be a shame if a lot of the great dyed pieces I have seen here lost their color in a couple of years after all that work and effort.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#11

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

George Van

>Thanks Chuck. I missed a chance to see a Binh Pho demo recently while visiting my daughter in AZ. I am glad I got to see my daughter but wish he had demoed before/after the time I was gone. I glanced at the site and will spend some time tonight reading the information.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#12

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I recently completed a one-month fade test of various dyes and coloring materials.

- Prismacolor markers were the big losers.

- Transtint and Procion-MX held up pretty well and were about comparable. Some colors lasted better than others.

- The big winners were artist colors - Higgins Fadeless ink and Liquitex acrylics (the good/expensive ones). Both were thinned with water to give the same color density as the dyes and neither one showed any change in color.

In a secondary test, I tested the ability of the inks and acrylics to "pop the grain" of some curly maple. A thin wash of artist grade acrylic (thinned with about 5 part water) penetrated just as well as the dyes and was just as transparent.

Guess what I'm going to be using.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#13

Oops! TransFast wood dyes, not TransTint

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Also, the TransFast dyes were slightly more fade resistant than the Procion-MX dyes.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#14

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

George Van

>Thanks Brian. Looks like I have some testing to do! I would have never thought of thinning artist grade acrylic but that would open up the door to a lot of archival grade finishes.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#15

It certainly opens a lot of options.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Not only do artist grade acrylics give you a very full range of colors, but they also can be used in various interesting ways.

Right now I'm experimenting with adding a glazing medium to get very clear wash coats. I'm also going to try adding a little pearlescent medium. Air brushing is a popular technique that I plan to experiment with as well.

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#16

Re: Dye- Fade Proof? *LINK*

Chuck Engstrom

>Hi again folks -- another supplier I just thought of is Kremer Pigments. Steven Gleasner discussed them in an article somewhere, IIRC; he uses their shellac-based inks as dyes for his pieces. Link attached.

Chuck Engstrom


Kremer Pigments website

Re: Dye- Fade Proof?

#17

Thanks

George Van

>Thanks again for the help Brian and Chuck. This is an interesting study with lots of variables. I was wondering what to do with all those small, plain bowl blanks out in the pole building but now I know why I saved them!