Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

Posts

Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#1

Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

Greg Haugen

>Ok, I came home last night from a friends house to add another coat of finish on a box. When I put some Waterlox on a rag I noticed it had gone bad. Unfortunately 3/4 of the can was full and went bad. That hurts. I was wondering if any used Bloxygen or any other "practices" to try and prevent this. Are the "oil" finishes more prone to go bad than lacquers, etc??

Thanks for any advice?

Greg Haugen

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#2

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

Ron in Drums PA

>I decant the oil into smaller jars. I fill to the top so there is no air in the jar

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#3

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I tried Bloxygen and wasn't satisfied with the results.

I now divide the finish into smaller plastic bottles with good snap lids. I'll divide a quart into 8 oz bottles, then divide the 8 oz bottle into 2 oz bottles. I got the bottles at an art supply store (www.DickBlick.com)

For flat work where I need more finish, I've used pint mason jars with good results. I also tend to buy those finishes by the gallon, so the larger jars work better.

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#4

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

Claudia Hayward

>I've found I can extend the life of the finish by taking a lightweight plastic bag (the kind that you get in the produce section of the grocery store) and carefully tucking it inside the can. It should sit on top of the surface of the finish and be tucked down around the inside wall. Then put the lid back on. Easy, cheap and you only have to pull back the plastic a little to get a brush in.

Claudia

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#5

Bloxygen Users???? I do both.

Charles R. Smith from Victoria

>I do both. I use an inexpensive oxygen blocker (which I got from a do-it-yourself wine store), and it works very well. When the amount of finish that is left in the can starts to get down, I pour it into a smaller can, so that it reduces the airspace that the blocker has to fill. It has worked well for me.

And while I'm in the wine place, I look at their corks which are used for making wine at home. The corks -- especially the white rubber ones which are predrilled -- are great as a replacement for the worn-out rubber bumpers on my Coles jaws.

Charles in Victoria (who goes into wine stores for woodworking supplies)

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#6

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

robo hippy

>Another method I heard about it to take the finish and put it into one of the collapsible plastic wine or water bags. After pouring the finish in, squeeze out the air and close the spout. Pour out what you need when you need it and squeeze out again. No air left inside to oxidize your finishes. I heard this one from Roger Michaelson, now deceased, who also said,"you know it is time to clean up the shop when you have to get down on your knees to turn".

robo hippy

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#7

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

RevDoug

>Here's yet a couple of other ideas. Once you're done for that sesson, fill the empty space in the can with marbles. Less air in the can means less opportunity to gell the oil. Another thought, when through, cap the can tightly and store upside down. Even if the "top" surface gells over, you've got good finish to use since you are working off the "bottom" of the can.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#8

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

Russ Fairfield

>Now you know why I mix my own oil and varnish finishes. The separate ingredients have a long shelf life, but a short one afer they are mixed. I only mix them in quantities that I will use in a month or no longer than 2 months. Tung Oil by itself in a closed can will last 3-years that I know of.

I may be leading a charmed life because none of the normal methods ever worked for me. Decanting never worked because the shelf-life always started when the original can was opened and it was exposed to air. Rocks and marbles never worked. Besides being messy, all they did was to provide a surface for the finish to start curing. Squeeze bottles never worked for me because the caps always leaked air. Turning them upside down never worked because the finish always leaked out. Bloxygen was too expensive, the spray cans always leaked, and I always forgopt to use it. Gas from a propane torch always seemed too dangerous before I quit smoking. The torch made a good cigarette lighter, and I always figured that anything I used to light a cigarette was too dangerous to use in a container.

The only thing that really worked for me was adding water to the container because oil and water never mixed and the finish always floated to the top.

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#9

Ric Taylor

Waterlox Does Not Go Bad

Ric Taylor

>Waterlox doesn't go bad, it just forms a thick crust layer on the top. Don't throw it away. All you need is a pipette to stick through that layer into the good Waterlox underneath, and draw it up. Squirt the Waterlox from the pipette onto your work surface or onto a rag, and you're in business.

I've been using the same can of Waterlox for 2 1/2 years, poured into a jar. I keep a lid tight on the jar, but the crust layer forms anyway. It doesn't matter, I bought a box of 100 pipettes on eBay for a dollar.

There are several of us in my club that do this, and it works for all of us. Waterlox is too expensive to be throwing away, especially when there is nothing wrong with it.

Ric

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#10

Re: Waterlox Does Not Go Bad

Russ Fairfield

>The only problem with doing that is the crust will suck the varnish resins out of the finish. What you have left is a good quality polymerized oil finish, but without those phenolic resins, it is no longer Waterlox.

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#11

Re: Waterlox Does Not Go Bad

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Greg: Several good answers here. I've had the same problem and solved it by pouring my Waterlos into a plastic wine bag (be sure to get rid of the wine - somehow - and rinse well first. Press out every bit of air and close the valve. My last bag lasted for 3 years and was as good in the last drop as the first.

That said, I have a couple friends who get a vacuum pump from the local "fu-fu" store. That's the ones who sell all kinds of kitchen, bath, bedroom stuff. They pour the Waterlox into empty beer bottles, insert a special cork that they get at the same store, pump the air out and - wollah! Works great.

Last method is from a good friend who just takes the wooden hand clamps that all woodworkers have and squeeze the Waterlox can 'till the liquid goes to the top, caps it, and, again - wollah! Works great. I'm afraid of the can splitting but he's been doing it for years and has yet to have a failure.

Good Luck.

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

#12

Re: Bloxygen Users???? Finishes going bad.....

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I tried adding water to a can of finish (Formby's Tung Oil) and it turned the finish a pale pink. A pinkish amber finish wasn't exactly what I was looking for!