Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Posts

3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#1

3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Jerry Hall

>I have been turning some heavy (35-40#) green oak blanks and have noticed that the head stock is rocking fore and aft. At first I thought it was just an out of balance blank and my poor tool control on a very rough blank. I have made sure that there is no play in my spindle and the chuck is steady. A hand on the bed and legs show those to be steady. Now that I have narrowed it down I can see the headstock rock and a gap of maybe .01" or more in the front. I can even rock it by grasping the hand wheel and the spindle.

I thought maybe it was the headstock lock. Mine is square (not round like the 3520b) and sometimes it wasn't seated. Now I check that carefully. I really pull up hard on the headstock lock bar, and even tried a rubber mallet. I believe my ways are clear and clean, but haven't taken the headstock off.

Today I made a curved wedge to fit under the motor mount to tilt the headstock forward, and that did the trick. But this is no long term solution.

I am afraid I am going to have to take the headstock off, check it for flat, and maybe have it machined if possible?

Any thoughts and help would be appreciated. I don't like my chances at this stage. I have a feeling this has always been this way, but I have just now become clearly aware of the problem.

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#2

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Fog Tanner

>I have the 16" Delta steel bed lathe, which has a sliding headstcok. Mine doesn't rock, but if it did I would check the locking mechanism first, then the ways for flatness using a machinst rule. If those were flat, I'd check the bottom of the headstock for flatness using a machinst rule. I'd also move it to some other locations on the bed and check if it was the same.

Before I got is machined, I would try some of the metalized epoxy like J-B Weld first. There are a number of these for all sorts of industrial applications and they are quiet strong and have substantial load bearing (within reason). They can be drilled and tapped so they would probably stand up as a "shim". J-B Weld is just the easiest to locate.

It would be easy enough to either wax the ways or cover them with plastic and then mix some epoxy and spread it on the area where the gap is. Put back on the machine, check that the center of the spindle is the same height from the ways and lock it down. It would take several days (7) for the epoxy to fully harden and cure. But, it could save you from having to get your headstock and tail stock machined. If you take some off the head stock, they will have to indicate off the spindle and also remove some from the tail stock to keep it on center.

I have had my headstock unlatch while coring bowls several times, but that was just due to the excess vibration from the coring process. I never had any problems at other times. I solved the unlatching issue, by buying a fixed headstock Vic 300. I use the Delta for boxs and smaller bowls. Hopefully your issue turns out to just be some debri under the headstock.

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#3

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Ed

>Jerry

Hope the problem is minor??? I will hope for the best and bring the pine on Wednesday.

Ed

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#4

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Jerry, I would bet the head stock is not locked down. First slide the head stock to the middle of the bed so you can work on it. Second, is the head stock flat against the ways... if you can't tell use a sheet of paper and try to slip it between the headstock and the ways. If thats ok lock the head stock down and try to rock it. If it moves take the paper and make sure the clamp is tight against the rails or have a friend rock it while you look. Now adjust the clamp nut until it locks the head stock.

You said; "Mine is square (not round like the 3520b) and sometimes it wasn't seated." I don't think the clamp should drop down that far to twist.

Let us know

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#5

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Black Bear

>Jerry,

I would disassemble the components that comprise your headstock locking mechanism and look for a small crack in either the plate below the ways or in the components that hold the locking bar in the headstock. My old delta lathe took a shot in the move from Illinois to England which caused a small crack in the locking mechanism in the headstock. Did not find it on first inspection but could not believe my turning skills had gotten so bad just by living in the North of England. I did something similar to you in "I really pull up hard on the headstock lock bar, and even tried a rubber mallet" but all that happend in mine was the cracked component finally let go. Needless to say with the new ownership at Delta cutting costs everywhere, my lathe parts were no longer servicable. Luckly I have access to a machine shop here that made a new - and better - replacement. Good luck in your investigation.

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#6

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Jerry,

I had the same problem with mine. Mine was not as noticable as yours. I could not see any gap, but with large loads, it had a slight vibration. (I turned pieces over 100 lbs.) I could feel the vibration by holding my hand on the headstock and it bugged me while hollowing. I "fixed" mine with a 2436! I know of another one with the same problem. The owner sold his too.

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#7

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

Charles B. Watson

>As already mentioned, I would check each component in the locking mechanism especially the clamping plate. There were some problems with them at one time--so I've heard. Believe some were cast iron and some steel. Don't give up on a great lathe.

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#8

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

john lucas

>Jerry The first thing I would do is remove it and clean it well. Then look for any damage. Then check the clamp and the bottom of the headstock for flatness. When you reinstall the headstock make sure the clamp actually does clamp all the way. You may have to tighten the nut on the bottom.

I added 300 lbs of rock to the bottom of my lathe. The lathe will vibrate when you put big out of round loads on it. In my case I don't think it's the headstock I think it's just 40lbs of mass spinning out of balance.

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#9

Thanks all. Next Steps

Jerry Hall

>Wonderful, thoughtful responses. Thanks. I am going to in order:

1. Tighten the nut

2. Use the paper shim idea

3. Remove the headstock, clean, examine the locking mechanism

While I am at it I may grind and round off the corners of the locking plate so it doesn't hang up on the bed ribs so easily. I think I read years back that someone recommended this.

I will report back once I get a strong back to assist me.

Thanks again. I now have some hope!

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#10

Back turning.... *LINK*

Jerry Hall

>I think the Headstock is fixed. Won't know for sure until I put on an 18" D x 11" black oak crotch blank that is standing by. I noticed that the headstock rocked back as much as 1/4" when the clamp was all the way loose, way too much. But I took advantage of it to thoroughly blow it out along the ways. I then tightened the lock nut until the headstock just slides easily. When I really lock it tight the rocking seems to have disappeared. I still want to round over the clamp block corners, but I don't have time now that I am back turning. I may also turn a longish handle for the rod to make it easier to lock down.

Thanks all very much for your advice and encouragement. I have taken the "For Sale" sign down. The new lathe will just have to wait for awhile. I'm not sure I could have found a better one in any case.

I am going to post this thread on the AAW Tips site


PM3520 Tips

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#11

Re: Back turning....

john lucas

>Jerry The headstock will rock when all the pressure is off because of the weight of the motor hanging out the back. I wouldn't worry about that. I hope it quits wobbling when you have it clamped down.

Re: 3520a Head Stock Rocking: Help?

#12

Re: Back turning....

Bob Fawcett

>You might also want to see if the clamp block from a 3520B will fit. I believe I read that the A had a cast iron block and that some cracked. The B model has a heavy steel blocked that is round. I think it may fit the A.