Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Poplar natural edge bowl

Posts

Poplar natural edge bowl

#1

Poplar natural edge bowl

stacey s

>Well after trying out my new photo tent here are some recent pieces that I have done. This one is poplar. About 8-9" dia. finished with oil(I don't remember what kind). Comments/Critiques please. Also please tell me how the picture is and what I should change to make it better.

Stacey


img

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#2

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

Cyril Griesbach

>It's a very nice well shaped bowl, Stacey. I'm sure the experts will provide you with info on the photo.

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#3

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

Jimmy Edwards

>What did you use to keep the bark on. CA or something else.

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#4

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

Dinyar Chavda

>It's a very nice piece, and you've done a great job of retaining the bark---I usually have bags of bark of different woods to glue onto pieces where I've lost the bark!

Some comments, as you had asked for them:

The picture has 2 lighter colored areas in the front (see arrows on photo at bottom (I haven't figured out how to get the photo in the middle of the message), which really distracted me, and took a lot of my attention away from the piece. If this is in the piece, I'd suggest either darkening them to blend them with the rest of the piece, or emphasizing them.

Re the shape, some alternatives that you could try on future pieces (or by printing the picture you have and drawing on it to show different shapes) would be to either continue the curve all the way to the bottom, resulting in a smaller base. Another option would be to do what you have done, and make the base shorter. Try them and see which pleases you most.


img

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#5

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

Charles B. Watson

>Nice form. The 2 lighter spots look like lichen.

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#6

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

Allen Neighbors

>Nice piece, Stacey. I love Natural edges. Ditto, what Dinyar said.

Dinyar, you give good critiques.

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#7

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

stacey s

>I didn't use anything to keep the bark on this one. It has stayed on exceptionally well all on its own.

Stacey

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#8

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

stacey s

>Thanks Dinyar and Allen,

I think those light spots are lichen. and the base is actually smaller than what it looks in the picture. Thanks again for the critque. I can't get better unless I know what to fix.

Stacey

Re: Poplar natural edge bowl

#9

Re: And again, move 1 light further away.

Jamie Donaldson

>