Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

VS Questions

Posts

VS Questions

#1

VS Questions

Stuart Johnson

>I added a 2HP 3 phase motor with controller to my Nova 3K and have a couple questions.

1. The controller reads mhz not rpm. Is there a reasonable way to determine the rpm? For example if it reads 30 mhz and the pulley set up is for 1440 would the rpm be 720 because the max is 60 mhz?

2. Is it better to have the belt set for a high speed and slow the lathe down to normal turning speed with the controller or set the belt lower speed and turn at a higher mhz? I don't turn large out of balance items.

Re: VS Questions

#2

Re: VS Questions

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Stuart,

What follows in what I have heard from various good sources, and my own experience.

1) Few digital readouts on lathes report actual RPM since that function would require a sensor on the headsock spindle. For instance, the readout on my Vega shows motor RPM. Actual spindle RPM will differ depending on the two different pulley setting. Fact of the matter is, I seldom look at the numbers. I just adjust the speed while looking at the bowl and use the "that's about right" method.

2) I too do not generally turn large out of round pieces, and I have kept mine on the high range since I got it. It that, I can still ramp the speed down to almost nothing when I have over sprayed a piece with finish, and want to keep it from running. You don't get as much torque, but I don't need it, and have more than enough when I put it down in the sub-500 range for sanding. Good thing is - it is easy to change if it does not work for you.

Mark

Re: VS Questions

#3

Re: VS Questions

Bill Howatt

>I would think it would read hz not mhz which is a milli-hertz unless they are using the m to indicate some other parameter in the controller. I never worry about the actual RPM and just adjust mine to what seems the right speed. You could maybe borrow a tach and make a calibration run at each pulley setting.

The best way to run the motor is with the belt on the pulley that provides the spindle speed you want with the highest motor RPM. This provides the most torque and the real benefit of better motor cooling since the fan is turning faster. Having said that there usually is a fairly broad safe operating range so you don't have to keep swapping the belts. My General has 4 steps in the pulley and I probably tend to run mostly in the middle 2. I use the lowest for out-of-balance "heavy" blanks and the highest step for small things like pens.

If I wanted to run at a very slow speed, even with little load, I would put the belt on the lowest one to keep the motor speed up.

Bill

Re: VS Questions

#4

Re: VS Questions

Fog Tanner

>Stuart,

If you are wanting the actual spindle rpm, you need a tach of some sort. I mechanical tach will be the easiest but cost more. A scrap piece of wood with either a simple of code (depending on the drive on the tach) will give you a readout for each pully setting and each speed setting on the controller.

An alternative is a cheap digital tach for model airplane engines. These can be had for a lot less than the mechanical tachs. The inconvience here is you need a two bladed prob or thin flat board that can be fixed to the spindle. around 9" is good enough and for such low rpms it doesn't need to be balanced. You have to have flash light as the light source (on the other side of the "prop")and turn off all the florecent fixtures - otherwise it will read 3600 at any setting.

You can make a chart an put on the wall so you would know what the spindle rpms are for any given setting.

Re: VS Questions

#5

Re: VS Questions

Don Evans

>There is one other source for a tach. Go to a good bicycle shop and look at the one's they have. They have some very accurate one's for small amount of money. I once used one that used a small magnet and sensor which I mounted on the handwheel on the lathe. Works great and I think it was around $20.00 then. I swapped out the magnet that came with the unit for a round 1/4" neo type from one of the wood supply places like CraftUSA or Woodcraft, this allowed for less critical mounting. I once flew models also and preferred the bike over the prop for reasons of keeping fingers out of the spinning prop.

Don

Re: VS Questions

#6

Re: VS Questions--Thanks

Stuart Johnson

>Thanks for the quick answers. The rpm was just curiosity as I start at zero and turn it up to what feels right. And, yes it is hz not mhz.

Re: VS Questions

#7

Re: VS Questions

Fog Tanner

>Don,

For my models, I have a not so cheap "light tach" or one with a photo cell. I can keep my hands and fingers 6"-8" away from the blade. It has several ranges with the lowest being what most lathes turn and the highest being 30,000. I only needed 24,500 and occasionally 26,000.

I do like the bicycle tach with the magnet. I could see putting that on the handwheel without any problem (I would not want to put it on anything spinning 24,500 though). Even with two mechanical tachs I will have to look into that. Thanks for the info, that is a cool idea.

Re: VS Questions

#8

Re: VS Questions--Thanks

Peter Hyde

>This one was less than $30 from Princes Auto in Toronto. East to use. Put a small piece of reflactive tape (provided) on the rim of the faceplate and shoot with the laser for instant read out.


img

Re: VS Questions

#9

Re: VS Questions

Dennis Vallianos

>I did the same thing with a Teco FM 100 controller from Dealer's Electric a little over a year ago for a Vicmarc 300 benchtop lathe purchased from Craft Supplies. The controller came with a manual that showed (among lots of other things) how to convert the time base from hz to rpm. Let me know if you have a Teco and need help.

Dennis

Re: VS Questions

#10

You want me to read the manual?????

Stuart Johnson

>I'll pull out the manual and see what it says. I did sort of read it when i received the motor and controller but just for the wiring.

Re: VS Questions

#11

Re: VS Questions

Bob Fawcett

>Stuart,

Your assumptions would be correct if the motor speed with direct wiring is the same as the original. For example if your original motor was a 1725 rpm motor and your 3 phase is the same, you could use the speeds for the original pulley settings and do the math for 30hz/60hz to get the speed as you did. If the 3 phase has different native speed, say 1100 rpm, then its more math this time 1100rpm/1725rpm etc. All this should be on your motor plates.

My PM 3520B actually has a spindle speed indicator on it. There is some type of feedback from the spindle that is converted to rpm. It even reads if I spin it by hand. You could achieve this by mounting one of the tachs everyone suggested to the lathe.

In the overall scheme of things, it makes little or no difference. The right speed is what you are comfortable with.

Re: VS Questions

#12

Re: You want me to read the manual?????

Dennis Vallianos

>The manual isn't exactly on any best seller list. I learned more than I ever wanted to because the defaults aren't near optimal for our needs. I changed a number of functions in order to get it to perform the way most of them do when you buy the lathe & motor/controller as a package. The advantage we have is that we don't have to wonder what to do with all the buttons and don't lose our warranty by changing things to our liking. Again, if you have the Teco unit and need help - give a yell.