Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

cryogenics and turning tools

Posts

cryogenics and turning tools

#1

cryogenics and turning tools

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>I need your help! What companies use a cryogenic treatment in the manufacture, heat treating of there turning tools?

Henry Taylor - Kryo line

Glaser triple tempers there steel.

Can you think of anyone else?

Thanks for any information.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#2

cryogenics and turning tools EDIT

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Glaser triple tempers there steel but don't use cryogenics anymore.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#3

Re: cryogenics and turning tools EDIT

Greg Haugen

>Just the parent company of Glaser, CET for the cryosteel line. I also know that Stuart Batty is working with a new company out of Denver. I'm not sure if they're cryo or heat treating them. May be worth an email to Stu.

stu@stubatty.com

Hope that helps,

Greg Haugen

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#4

Re: cryogenics and turning tools EDIT

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Greg,

Cryosteel is just a name that "sounded good" according to the owner and has nothing to do with the process. Matter of fact CET/Glaser is not on the vendor list for the symposium.

I will send a email to Stu and find out what he's is doing, Greg this is a very good idea, thanks.

Anymore ideas...

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#5

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Mike Brazeau

>Craft Supplies UK now have a line of Cryo treated tools. They are available in Canada through John at Woodchuckers. Quite reasonably priced. Colin Simpson has a review article on them in the current (June '07 No 175) issue of Woodturning Magazine. On a Jarrah burr (= burl) he felt that the gouge worked twice as long as regular HSS. On wet wood bowl roughouts he did three with HSS and five with Cryo before sharpening. He notes that the claim of three to six times longer between sharpenings, mentioned by manufacturers was not valid.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#6

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Mike,

Thank you, with so many tools on the market it's tough to find all of them. I picked up some tools today and asked again why cryogenics works better after the first temper then at the end of the process. This guy went into such detail my head is still spinning LoL

We now have a real spindle gouge YES! I'm excited about it.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#7

Send your tools here. *LINK*

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>This company treats metal with cryo. They are located in Decatur Illinois. I believe they will treat a minimum of 8 lbs for $75. Knock the handles off your gouges and have them treated, it will improve them. No affiliciation.


Cryo treatment

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#8

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Jorge Castaneda

>Doug,

Another toolmaker in WoodCentral is Steve Knight on the hand tools forum,I got a plane from him that was cryo treated and work very well, I don't know if this can help, but have a chat with him.

steve knight stevek@knight-toolworks.com

Good to hear about the spindle gouges, what ever happened with the skews?

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#9

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Wilford Bickel

>Doug,

P&N list their M2 tools at between 60 and 63 HRC.

Crown lists their M2 tools at between 61 & 63 HRC.

(Source Packard Woodworking catalog and website.)

I have not been able to find the hardness rating for any other brands or types of steel. Wish all the companies would give us such a rating to allow us to tell at least how the hardness of their tools compare. Can you give any such number for your tools?

Thanks!

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#10

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Jorge, I still can't get that sheet cut into strips... I'm still trying

Willard here's the way I describe the tools;

The tools are made from CPM 10V a powder steel manufactured by Crucible with a 9.75% vanadium content to hold an edge longer and has a proven history in woodturning. The steel is hardened to 60-62 Rockwell, triple tempered with a cryogenic treatment between the first and second temper. The cryogenic treatment at this stage transforms the bulk of the retained austinite to martensite and forms a very fine "eta" carbides much finer than tempering alone. Is cryogenics worth the extra cost... I think so. This is the only blade made in the USA that goes through a cryogenic treatment.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#11

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Mark Wollschlager

>Doug,

Will you be in Portland with any of your stuff?

Or do you know if HannesTools will be there?

I might need another bowl gouge to match the spindle gouges.

Mark.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#12

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Mark,

I'll be in Portland with some tools. Johannes Michelsen (HannesTool) will be in the Powermatic booth, stop by and look at his demo. He will have the new handle in three different sizes.

PS - Hope you see him rough a blank... the shavings go 6 to 8 feet in the air... very impressive.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#13

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Gordon Seto

>Quoting from Russ's Corner on Turning Tools:

"Step Five - Tempering

The steel is now very hard and very brittle, and it must be "tempered" or "drawn" back to whatever hardness we desire for the cutting tool. Here is where we have to make the compromise between hardness and durability. If the tool is too hard, it will take a sharper edge, but it will be very brittle. Less hardness and the edge will not be as sharp, but it will not be brittle. Think of it as being similar to the difference between a razor blade (brittle) and a carving knife (durable)."

I think just comparing the HRC figures alone is misleading. The lathe tools are subject to a lot travel. Where we should settle on the compromise between hardness and durability?

I am no metallurgist, but I think Russ Fairfield may forget more than whatever I can learn in this subject in my lifetime.

Gordon

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#14

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

john lucas

>Gordan Powdered metal tools are really different than regular steel. You can't really draw the same comparisons. The reason the various industries are using them is because they can be both tough and hard without being brittle. At least to a point. They can also make them pourous to hold oil and many other things you can't do with regular steel.

The way I understand cryogenics is that it changes the steel in a different way than heating and tempering does. Doug seems to be doing both to see how far he can take turning tools in the direction of holding an edge for a long time and still getting sharp.

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

#15

Re: cryogenics and turning tools

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Your both correct. When the steel is hardened the rockwell is a few points above the target. Tempering will change the structure of the metal and in the process lower the rockwell a few points.

The hardening process will form austinite that is brittle and not wanted in a tool steel. Tempering changes the austinite (brittle) into martensite which is hard, when this happens carbides are formed from each alloy in the steel. Cryogenics will do the same thing except it forms very fine carbides call "eta carbides"... this structure is better than tempering alone. That is why cryogenics is best after the first temper... you have more retained austinite to change over.