Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Undecided!!!!!!!

Posts

Undecided!!!!!!!

#1

Undecided!!!!!!!

Barry Scotton.... on SaltSpring

>I want to do more end grain hollowing, vases etc up to 10 or 12 inches deep. I am torn between the oneway Termite and the Martel hook tool. Both seem to do the job, but throw into the mix the Hunter tool and the eliminator tool, both using carbide cutters. What do any of you use? What do you like or dislike about any of the above? Are there any others I should consider? All comments will be greatly appreciated.

Regards... Barry .... on SaltSpring

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#2

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

Russ Fairfield

>My advice is to buy Mike Hunters tool and forget about the rest of them. It works very well on end grain, and is easier to use than a "termite". As for durability, I have just completed hollowing the 57th goblet without having to rotate the carbide from its original position, and there is no noticable evidence that it is getting dull.

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#3

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

Bruce Forrest

>Once upon a time I used to use a big Termite (put together from parts available from Oneway), but since I got/built a boring bar/laser setup the Termite is gathering dust. You need something long and substantial when you're hanging that far over the tool rest. My 2 cents.

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#4

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

Russ Fairfield

>I have been using both the Hunter and the Eliminator, and I come down on the side of the Hunter tool. The eliminator is a similar tool with a larger and longer tapered shank that has 2 flats milled at 45-degrees to the cutter. These flats are there to automatically position the tool at 45-degrees.

I think which is the better tool will depend on what you want to do with it. Both have their benefits. Personally, I don't like the flats on the Eliminator because I like to do my own positioning and that is not always at 45-degrees. The long shank is ideal for use with a Stewart Armbrase, but is too long and not at all maneuverable when a handle is attached to it, and in its present configuration is not at all adaptable to a captured hollowing system for really deep hollowing, or not in the way that I use mine.

I prefer the Hunter tool because it is more versatile. The 1/2" shank in a long Oneway handle is a good combination for freehand hollowing goblets, or anything else in the range of 3" to 4" depth, and I have worked with it up to 5" past the toolrest in hard dry Maple. It is now available in a 3/8" version that is a perfect fit with a Stewart Omnitool with an Armbrace, and it also is available in a shorter length (or can be cut to length) and used in any of the larger captured hollowing systems.

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#5

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

Brodie Brickey

>I can only speak for the termite as I haven't used the other tools. The termite works, but it does have issues with rough insides. In my experience it doesn't leave a good finish. I mostly do dried endgrain and that could be part of the issue. It works for what I need but if I was exposing the interior to a finger or eye view, I wouldn't use it exclusively.

It will move a lot of wood, but you can actually remove more from one side than another.

Regards,

Brodie

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#6

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

Bill Howatt

>I usually rough with the Termite but I always clean up the surface with a scraper. I like the Termite but I don't see hanging it 10" or more off the rest being a highly controlled environment!

Bill

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#7

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

John Lucas

>Barry I have the termite tool and have used a homemade hook tool. I use them mostly on vases. For hollow turning I prefer the John Jordan tools. The bits are easy to sharpen, easy and cheap to replace and allow you to take big cuts or small cuts in endgrain or side grain.

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

Dick Hines

>I use the Jamieson rig. Also have a Kelton I put into service once in a while.

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#9

Mike Hunter

Re: Undecided!!!!!!! *LINK*

Mike Hunter

>My interest is to provide cutting tools for the various hollowing systems ... please check out the 3/16 round shank tool at hunterwoodturningtool.com


http://hunterwoodturningtool.com

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

#10

Re: Undecided!!!!!!!

Barry Scotton.... on SaltSpring

>Thanks to everyone for your comments and advise

Regards Barry .... on SaltSpring