Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Finish help needed

Posts

Finish help needed

#1

Finish help needed

Peter Hyde

>I am about to start using a water base lacquer. So what can i use to "pop the grain' before the lacquer goes on? I normally use BLO and then either wipe on poly or Deft lacquer so ther have been no compatibility issues. Can I still use the BLO and then maybe shellac or something similar.

TIA

Peter

Re: Finish help needed

#2

Re: Finish help needed

Russ Fairfield

>Mine will be a controversial answer.

I don't use waterborne finishes because they don't "pop" the grain as well as other finishes, and I have never been able to get them to bond very well to Boiled Linseed Oil, or any other oil or lacquer finish.

If you are intent on using the waterborne finish, give it a try without any preparation other than sanding to 600 grit. Water will wet the grain and give it some accent or "popping", but it will also raise the grain and require sanding again. You might find the result is pleasing enough, and there will be no hassle or concern about making incompatible finishes stick to each other.

Some waterborne finishes accent the grain better than others. "Enduro", a waterborns polyurethane finish that is now sold as a polycrylic finish by General Finishes, does a better job than any other waterborne I have used. It also has the least blue haze of any waterborne I have used. I haven't used it since the change in ownership.

"Popping" the grain requires differential penetration, and the darker color that comes from the deeper penetration into end grain. Since waterbornes impart the least color change of all finishes, there is little to no color variation, and little to no "popping" of the grain.

BLO and other oil finishes are traditionally the grain "poppers" of choice because they impart the most color to the wood, and BLO imparts the most color of anything that can be put on a piece of wood. However, waterbornes don't stick to an uncured oil finish because Oil and water really don't mix. There are 2 choices. One is waiting at least 6-months for the BLO to totally cure; the the other is a barrier coat of shellac between the oil and waterborne finish. The problem is that the shellac will have to be sanded without going through into the oil. That usually means several coats of shellac to insure a continuous film. By the time I have done all of that, it is faster to go with a shellac finish, or forget the shellac and go with several coats of an oil finish.

Re: Finish help needed

#3

Re: More finish help

Russ Fairfield

>The best bet for accenting the grain under a waterborne finish is with a water soluble analine dye. An application of a Dark Orange works very well on Maple. Apply the dye, and then partially sand it off, leaving the color in the open end grain. This is faster, and there are no problems with incompatible finishes. I use water soluble dye because it is easier to get an even coat; and it raises the grain before the finish is applied, and that means less sanding after the 1st coat of the finish.

Re: Finish help needed

#4

Re: More finish help

Peter Hyde

>Thanks Russ. I had more or less come to the same conclusion and am in a quandry. At our Guild meeting last month there were some very nice pieces finished with water based lacquer and I was impressed with the finish. So I purchased some semi-gloss and have used it on some birch ply drawer interiors. Works great and is very clear. Now the quandry. I have just turned a Natural edged bowl from some Box Elder and it has some nice red colour in it. The sapwood is almost stark white and very bland. I tried some BLO on some scrap and it really "popped" the grain and the colour.

Hence the question. I think I will go ahead and use BLO and shellac and then the Lacquer just to see how it works.

Re: Finish help needed

#5

Re: More finish help

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Peter,

I used some water based finish and it was very thick and it said not to thin it. I put it on and do not like the results. You can see the brush marks very plainly because it was so thick. Would you tell me what brand you are using? How did you apply it?

Gary

Re: Finish help needed

#6

Re: More finish help

Mike Brazeau

>Peter - on Box Elder, Waterlox gives a not bad finish with only a small amount of amber effect. I also like the General Finishes Salad Bowl Finish. Both give a pretty good depth effect. I have done one bowl with Min Wax Polycrylic water base once as an experiment, but prefer either of my first two choices.

Re: Finish help needed

#7

Re: More finish help

Peter Hyde

>Gary,

M.L.Campbell Ultrastar Water Borne Clear Lacquer C599 14 Satin.

Spray only. No thinning. Note this is lacquer, not a polyurethane or a polyester.

I have used a W.B. Polyurethane many times in the past and always used a foam brush for small areas and a paint pad for larger areas. A paint pad on a mahogany ply hollow core door will give an almost perfect unblemished finish similar to a good spray job.

The move to a W.B. Lacquer has come about through exposure to the product on finished kitchen cabinets and also because of a price factor. Also I have now got an adequate HVLP conversion spray gun that makes finishing a lot quicker and easier.

Re: Finish help needed

#8

Re: More finish help

Peter Hyde

>Hi Mike,

If you recall we chatted about Waterlox at the meeting and I was very interested. The downside for me is the spoilage rate unless the marbles and decanting are used:-) Also availability and price. The trouble is I am looking for a universal do all finish that meets all my requirements and is infallible:-) Yeah I know, but we can always dream. Anyway the particular piece of Box Elder in question needs some amber effect to really set it off and also I need something to give the natural edge a bit more oomph! So I am still thinking BLO, shellac and then the lacquer. I will post pictures and also hopefully get it to show and tell if successful. If not then the worse thing that can happen is a very tedious sanding job.

Re: Finish help needed

#9

Thanks Peter

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>

Re: Finish help needed

#10

Was More finish help

Peter Hyde

>Well here is the bowl sanded to 1500, BLO and buffed.

10.5" x 9.5" x 5" x 3/8" thickness. Huge worm holes had occupants that were killed first with an injection of lacquer thinners into each hole. Some of the corpses were 1" long and 1/4" fat.


img

Re: Finish help needed

#11

Re: Was More finish help

Allen Neighbors

>Peter, that is an awesome bowl. Truly a nice one. I love the holes and the red! Finish help must have helped! :)

Re: Finish help needed

#12

Re: Was More finish help

Peter Hyde

>Thanks Allen. I have the other half of the log still and am trying to decide on another NE or a regular bowl. The wood came from our Guild's monthly wood donation raffle so it was really expensive, I think about $3 :-)