Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Maple HF with finial *LINK*

Posts

Maple HF with finial *LINK*

#1

Maple HF with finial *LINK*

Roger Smith

>Been working with HFs lately and this is the first I tried with a finial and wanted comments and critiques.

Maple HF is 2.5 inches high and 6 inches wide.

Finial is from Sapele and approx 5 inches tall.

Does it work? What changes would be an improvement?

thanks,

roger


img

http://www.overtrimwoodworks.com

Re: Maple HF with finial *LINK*

#2

Re: Maple HF with finial

Ron McKinley

>Looks good to me. Is the finial the lid? ......Ron

Re: Maple HF with finial *LINK*

#3

Re: Maple HF with finial

Roger Smith

>Yes and thanks

Re: Maple HF with finial *LINK*

#4

Re: The finial is too thick and heavy....

Jamie Donaldson

>... looking in proportion to the body of the HF. Thin, dainty finials are the style de jour, a la Drozda and disciples.

Re: Maple HF with finial *LINK*

#5

Thanks Jamie

Roger Smith

>Now back and try again.

Re: Maple HF with finial *LINK*

#6

Re: The finial is too thick and heavy....

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Roger,

Thinner and more delicate would be great as Jamie advises if you can, but to me the finial's shape is OK although it needs sharper detail. Try another one with the same shape, and sharpen the inside and outside corners with a honed and polished tool. Lay off with the sandpaper except for a little 400 grit sanding with the grain (lathe off) and that should make a big improvement. If you work on your tool technique and use scary sharp tools, you don't need less than 400 grit to start with.

To polish a tool's edge, use white diamond buffing compound on an MDF wheel mounted on an arbor chucked in your lathe or drill press. Or just a flat piece of wood, rubbed with the compound, and used like a hand strop works fine.

Re: Maple HF with finial *LINK*

#7

Thanks Ken

Roger Smith

>I will be spending some more time working on this.