Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Wood ID help

Posts

Wood ID help

#1

Steve Kubien

Wood ID help

Steve Kubien

>Hi everybody,

Here is one of the logs I picked up in the neighbourhood and I don't know what it is. The guys I got it from was told it was a cottonwood but the pictures I've seen of c.w. are very different than this. I am think some sort of poplar but it didn't grow really tall or straight. When it was still in the ground it had me think ait was a birch of some sort. The bark is kinda thick and grey not thin and papery like a white birch. Wood is softer than walnut, harder than pine (not too broad a range eh?)

Thanks for your help,

Steve Kubien


img

Re: Wood ID help

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: Wood ID help

Steve Kubien

>Here's a shot of the end of the log. If you were me, would you pick up more of this stuff?

Steve Kubien


img

Re: Wood ID help

#3

Re: Wood ID help

joaz

>It appears to be birch. If it is, the bark should pull away in sheets as it dry's.

Just my dos peso's

Re: Wood ID help

#4

Re: Wood ID help

Don in Central Illinois

>It's not any kind of cottonwood grown in central Illinios. I'd vote for some sort of birch. I'm sure others will be more definitive.

Re: Wood ID help

#5

Re: Wood ID help

Randy G

>Couple comments on that... I've seen some of the higher branches on Cotton wood look like that before they develope the thicker Bark on the outside. I think it's a mating of poplar and cotton wood. The other option is if it doesn't look like birch it might be Aspen?

Re: Wood ID help

#6

Re: Wood ID help

James Duxbury

>Steve,

That center looks red almost like blood. If so it is box elder. It is kind of soft white wood with the pith area streaked with red. It is quite interesting in boards or turned in a bowl but the sunlight will turn the red to a brown unless sealed with a UV protectice coation.

Re: Wood ID help

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: Wood ID help

Steve Kubien

>Hi James,

Unfortunately, no. It's definitely not box elder. It's one of the trees I DO know. It's the poor photo that makes the centre look red. It's actually a dull brown.

Still thinking it's some sort of birch and will be looking into the aspen option.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Re: Wood ID help

#8

Re: Wood ID help

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Steve,

Here's a link that might help in the future.

http://www.dnr.state.oh.us/forestry/trees/default.htm

Re: Wood ID help

#9

Brad Vietje

Poplar/Aspen family

Brad Vietje

>Steve,

First, if you really want any help with a chunk of wood, you ought to tell us either where you live, or better, where the wood came from. There are trees that grow out in California that I've never even heard of, and Maine has different trees than Arizona, too.

there are also ornamental species that are planted as part of a landscaping scheme that are WAY out of place -- like the Magnolia someone gave my wife, which can survive and flower here in a sheltered, south-facing spot, but is certainly not a native plant to these parts.

All that aside, I'd say from the looks that you have some White Poplar, though I have even seen some Quaking Aspen that had that bark. These are closely related to the Cottonwoods. If the bark is quite soft, easily damaged with a thumbnail, and the wood has a characteristic smell (can't really describe), you would most likely be in the Populous family. A dead poplar that sits around a while will have a distinct, kind of nauseating smell to the wet, rotting, inner bark. Birch would have a wet, cork-like inner bark and a sharply defined thin, tightly-layered outer bark, which I don't think you have. The darker center is probably why the tree was cut down -- looks like a dying tree to me.

Another tree in the Populous group is the Balm-of-Gilead tree, or Balsam Poplar, which have very sticky, upright, resinous buds, and a strong, pleasant smell.

That's all I can contribute from your photos...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Wood ID help

#10

I Second That, Poplar-Aspen

Jorge Castaneda

>

Re: Wood ID help

#11

Re: Poplar/Aspen family

C.W.Stivison

>It looks like the fast growing hybrid popular we planted 20 years ago and cut down last at about 60 ft tall. We have quaken ash here at the farm in se ohio and it is very soft. Softer than pine.

CW

Re: Wood ID help

#12

Re: Wood ID help

Wolf Kiessling

>The texture of the bark looks like aspen. I can't tell exactly from the picture but if it is gray, it is not aspen. Aspen is a greenish colored bark with a white powder covering. Eventually the white powder comes off and you have the remaining greenish colored bark. Aspen grows above the 8000 ft elevation. Did it come from that high up?

Re: Wood ID help

#13

Re: Wood ID help

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Steve It dosen't seem to have any of the charactoristics that I know of Poplar. The pic makes me think of Maple

Re: Wood ID help

#14

Leo Van Der Loo

Steve, I call that tremblen aspen, it's closely

Leo Van Der Loo

>related to cottonwood, a lot of people that take a quick glance to those trees think often it's birch, as it is almost white in color.

Grows all over Canada except in the badlands in Alberta and south west Saskatchewan, also the eastern part of the US.

It's the ones that cover very large areas, like two hundred acres, and it's all the same tree.

Very soft wood, generally just like a Poplar

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Wood ID help

#15

Steve Kubien

Re: Poplar/Aspen family

Steve Kubien

>Hi Brad,

Well, Duh! I never thought to tell you where I live. Now that you mention it, yup, seems like pretty important information. I live just outside of Toronto. I am liking the poplar/aspen idea.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Re: Wood ID help

#16

Steve Kubien

Thanks for ther help everyone!

Steve Kubien

>Now, to turn something out of it.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Wood ID help

#17

Re: Wood ID help

Robert D. Macgregor

>Steve,

I'd vote for the poplar, too; ours look a lot like that.

A number of years ago I picked up some poplar blocks that a road crew had left at the roadside and stacked them on my deck; a lot of it sprouted in the spring and sent out leaves (which eventually died since there was no root system to support the growth). If the logs you have are reasonably fresh, you might try setting some out to see if they sprout leaves, which you can then use for a more positive diagnosis.

BOB

Re: Wood ID help

#18

Re: Wood ID

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Steve,

It appears from the photo that what you have is an American Beech tree. I have several in my yard and just compared your bark etc. Seems a perfect match. While I'm not willing to go slice mine up to further confirm things, I turned the stuff once. Enjoy it while it's wet, the older(and drier) it gets the harder it'll be.

mm