Update: Straight from the horse's mouth...
Gary Evans Tallassee, TN
>so to speak.
My engineer buddy tells me that the distance from the work surface is unimportant in determining the amount of usable light that you will receive from LEDs versus halogen lights.
Halogen lights may be rated at 10,500 lumens, but that is a measure of the total light output by that bulb in all directions. In order for that light to be usable, it has to be focused by the reflector. Reflector designs are notoriously inefficient. Consequently, your work space is only receiving approx. 30-40% of the light that the bulb produces.
LEDs, on the other hand, are already focused to some extent by the fact that they are mounted on a flat surface facing the area to be lighted. If the lens design is good enough, LED lights can be more than twice as efficient in delivering usable light to the work surface.
According to my friend, for your purposes you should be able to get by with LED lights that are rated at half the lumens of the halogens.
Gary