Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

swan neck or angle tool?

Posts

swan neck or angle tool?

#1

swan neck or angle tool?

eliot d

>When hollowing through a smallish hole, near the shoulder, which do you generally reach for, a swan neck tool, or a straight tool with, say, a cutter at 45 deg.? The swan neck will have no axial torque, but the overhang has to be long enough so that the tool rest is behind the point where the swan begins to curve. The straight tool does have axial torque, but the overhang can be minimized. (I've been arguing with a turning friend about it.) Let's assume, for the sake of this argument that you are holding the shaft of the tool by hand -- no constraining rigs, torque bars, etc.

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#2

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

robo hippy

>I am still a novice when it comes to hollow forms, but I will go with the swan neck every time. Having to set the tool rest back a bit isn't a problem, only a minor inconvenience. The angled cutter has too much torque to control outside of a caputred system, and you can't be nearly as agressive in removing wood as you can be with the swan/goose neck tools. The potential for those destroyer catches are way to high. DAMHIKT

robo hippy

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#3

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

Allen Neighbors

>Eliot, I have a small bent 3/8" shaft, with the end shaped like a fingernail ground scraper (top of the end of the shaft is ground flat). I put an old craftsman 12" handle on it. I use it to go into a 1/2" opening, getting under the shoulder, as far as about an inch deep inside. Then I can use the other tools that are designed for normal hollowing.

The commercially available tools are not designed to get just inside a very small opening... you'll have to engineer one.

Some folks make theirs from an allen wrench, by sharpening the short leg and glueing the long end into a handle of sorts. When I get this one worn down enough that it's not doing the job, I'll try an allen wrench. :)

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#4

Re: I should have added...

Allen Neighbors

>that I turn the speed up pretty fast... around 1200-1400 rpm... and take light cuts.

I used to take more agressive cuts by holding the shaft with a pair of vice grips. But I found out the higher speed and lighter cuts make smoother work.

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#5

Steven Antonucci

Ellsworth Style hollower

steve antonucci

>The straight bar with a cutter at an angle is my go to tool for hollowing. I have progressively larger cutters as the undercut gets deeper that I just install in the boring bar. The axial torque issues usually mean you are either cutting to aggressively or your cutting bit is dull. (Both of these issues are easily fixed :-)

For extremely undercut vessels, I have a bar that has a 90 degree bend in it and a cutter installed. As Allen mentioned, I can arrest the torque issue here by holding the bar with vise grips. If I'm doing it right (and paying full attention!), there is no noticable torque at all.

My home made swan neck almost never gets used...

Steve

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#6

Re: Ellsworth Style hollower

eliot d

>Not to get picky, but with the angled tool in a straight bar there certainly IS axial torque. I take it that you mean that you can create sufficient counter torque to keep your tools from twisting. With a swan neck that has the cutting tip in line with the shaft, and supported on the tool rest behind the curved part of the tool, there literally is zero axial torque. But I still find it interesting that you prefer the straight tool. My friend does too, and that was what I was asking about: why isn't the swan neck preferred -- hands down -- because there is NO axial torque?

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#7

Steven Antonucci

I can shed some light on my preferences

steve antonucci

>I have made a hand full of different diameter bar hollowers and originally, I wanted "one side fits all" on my first bar- it has two holes in the end that intersect at a set screw to lock the cutter. The bar is 5/8" and probably 24" long in a large heavy oak handle.

The handle is wide enough to arrest any minimal axial torque with the smallest cutter at 45 degrees. That cutter is 1" long x 1/4" thick, and projects about 1/2" and I truly mean negligible axial torque.

When I finally get up to 2", the axial torque is enough to warrant some means of arresting it. I use the vice grip locked on the bar by the handle, and it really doesn't take any effort to hold on. If I'm 12" deep in a 10" wide vessel, I might get a hard jerk once in a while...

Back to my original point- I started with one bar, two holes. Since I've made a bunch more (10+) I don't have to kill myself to get that last little nub out like I used to do. When I was in Ellsworth's Studio last summer, he convinced me that hand held connects you to the work a little more closely, and that you can actually feel the ridges and irregularities with those style tools. If you look above at my Pimento Hollowform- it was hollowed out 99% with my straight bar with the 45 degree/straight cutter. Only the most extreme undercutting was done by a bent bar.

Steve

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#8

Re: I can shed some light on my preferences

eliot d

>I guess it's because I started out with the swan neck Dennis Stewart tools and moved on to similar ones from John Jordan, and most recently, the Rolly Monro articulated hollower, that I 'm most comfortable with them. And, because I know that they present zero axial torque, I tend to favor them. But I'm very interested in your observations. I know that David Ellsworth has his students make their own straight tools with angled cutters, and I will be participating in his class this June. So I am looking forward to learning a whole new approach. I'm getting spoiled by the laser- guided constraining rigs, too; and I wonder how I am going to make out without them. Well it's all firewood!

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: swan neck or angle tool?

Brad Vietje

>I use 'em both, but I only use a small allen wrench tool for the 1" or so surrounding the opening, and I generally do all the finish turning and smoothing with the goose neck tool, if the size of the opening allows. If the opening is real small, close to the diamater of the curved-neck tool, I don't have the same level of control, since I can't get the tip above center as easily. In those cases, I usually go to a smaller, angle-tip straight-shaft Ellsworth-style tool. My smaller ones have 3/8" shafts.

Safe spinning,

Brad vietje

Newbury, VT