I can shed some light on my preferences
steve antonucci
>I have made a hand full of different diameter bar hollowers and originally, I wanted "one side fits all" on my first bar- it has two holes in the end that intersect at a set screw to lock the cutter. The bar is 5/8" and probably 24" long in a large heavy oak handle.
The handle is wide enough to arrest any minimal axial torque with the smallest cutter at 45 degrees. That cutter is 1" long x 1/4" thick, and projects about 1/2" and I truly mean negligible axial torque.
When I finally get up to 2", the axial torque is enough to warrant some means of arresting it. I use the vice grip locked on the bar by the handle, and it really doesn't take any effort to hold on. If I'm 12" deep in a 10" wide vessel, I might get a hard jerk once in a while...
Back to my original point- I started with one bar, two holes. Since I've made a bunch more (10+) I don't have to kill myself to get that last little nub out like I used to do. When I was in Ellsworth's Studio last summer, he convinced me that hand held connects you to the work a little more closely, and that you can actually feel the ridges and irregularities with those style tools. If you look above at my Pimento Hollowform- it was hollowed out 99% with my straight bar with the 45 degree/straight cutter. Only the most extreme undercutting was done by a bent bar.
Steve