Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Posts

Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#1

Steve Kubien

Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Steve Kubien

>Hi everyone,

Without getting into brand specifics and loyalties, I need help selecting a saw. This will be my first chainsaw nad I would like it to last a few years.

The question is, how big a saw do I need? I currently have a mini lathe but hope to upgrade to a Nova 1624 in the fall/winter. I can't see myself taking down any trees, just scavenging what I can from stuff already felled. My thinking is that I can get by with something in the 45cc, 3 hp class with a 16" bar. Does that sound reasonable or am I going to wanting a hemi-sized saw really soon? With the new lathe, I want to look at bowls and plates in the 12-18" range, with the odd piece even larger.

Bearing in mind that price is a consideration, I know I can go Husky or Stihl for about $400Cdn (Husky 340 or Stihl MS250) or I can go Craftsman (made by Poulan) for about $250. As a casual user, how much further ahead will I be going with one of the 2 big names?

Thanks for your help,

Steve Kubien

P.S. I've already got the $$$ set aside for safety gear like chaps, helmut/faceshield, boots, gloves etc. I'll make those purchase before the actual saw!

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#2

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Don in Central Illinois

>I purchased a 16" Stihl last fall and have never looked back. There was a thread last summer on this subject and the overall consensus was the Husky or Stihl would outlast a cheaper saw 2 to 1.

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#3

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Darryl Hansen

>try norwalk poser systems. www.npeco.com ( I think) You probably won't need to spend as much as you inidcate for a good Husky. They usually give tow free chains with a purchase as well and when i bought mine oil too. If you call them you can get good advice also..

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#4

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long *LINK*

nailshooter

>Couldn't agree more with Darryl. I just bought a Husky from Norwalk (if you call, as for Mark Leonetti - he has been there 20+ years!) and it was cheaper than buying from Lowe's! The Husky is a full featured saw, as is the Stihl, and they have a lot of different features (decompression valve, visible primer, etc.) that you will grow to appreciate very quickly.

To me, the most important difference between the Husky and Stihl was parts availability and service. Stihl cannot legally be sold over the internet as a new saw from a company. They are dealer products only, and as such, some parts are not available either except from a certified dealer. When checking prices on air filters, clutch covers, bars, etc., this made a pretty big difference. The dealers here in San Antonio TX have a heftly bench fee for the Stihl.

Husky is now the largest supplier of lawn and garden equipment in the world (at least according to them!) and they no longer want that kind of exclusivity of dealing with the public. You can buy parts all over, and saws as well.

That being said, there are two divided camps on the chainsaws I found when I was looking to buy. One is Stihl, one is Husky. You won't go wrong with either. I decided to bite the bullet and buy a better chain saw after about 5 of them that were good for two seasons, then I couldn't start them, something broke, they were underpowered, and on an on.

Some good advice from another turner on what size to purchase for most people's needs was to buy a machine that had a bar about 2-4 inches longer than the swing of your lathe. That should do most chores as well as give you maximum sized blanks.

One more thing, something that put me over the edge with Husky. They have a two year guarantee on their saw, Stihl has a one. Since I bought it with my American Express, the automatically extended the manufacturer's warranty by two years, to four!

Norwalk has a great set of charts comparing Stihl to Husky, and even their prices to other internet vendors. The extra chains, the low shipping, and the fact they didn't gouge on extras made Norwalk my choice as a vendor. They shipped from Pacific coast to South Texas in just 4 days, so they don't wait around on shipping, either.

See the link.

Robert

(BTW - I bought the Husky 460 with the 24" bar - I love it. I took down a 36" diameter live oak a week after I got it and it ran perfect, started easy and made short work of that tree.)

Robert


http://www.npeco.com/index.html?lang=en-us&target=d12.html

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#5

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

robo hippy

>Since I got a Husky with a 24 inch bar, I never use the 16 inch bar. You won't go wrong with either a Stihl or a Husky.

robo hippy

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#6

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>Last year a friend and fellow turner purchased a new Sears saw. I do not know what model. We were trying to use it to cut green ash. We took the saw back when it would clog up almost as soon as we began cutting. Many years ago I had a Sears saw. I will say it served its purpose. It was difficult to start after sitting around. Other than that I had no complaints. When I got rid of it after hearing so much about Stihl I never looked back I now have two Stihls one electric and one gas. After reading threads about chainsaws for quite a while it seems that if you can afford it Stihl or Husky is the long term way to go.

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#7

Steve Kubien

What about engine size?

Steve Kubien

>Ok, you guys have got me sold on a higher-end saw (Husky or Stihl). Is a 45cc engine going to be adequate? I know I would love something larger but it starts getting out of the budget pretty darn fast. Will a 45cc get me where I am trying to go...albeit a little slower?

Thanks,

Steve Kubien - who just picked up a pile of wood from a neighbour who took down a tree last night. Not sure of species but older bark is grey and newer growth looks like white birch.

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#8

Re: What about engine size?

Barry Elder

>After the 2004 hurricanes severely damaged the county I reside in, I searched the internet for a Stihl dealer, but their locator didn't work! I wound up buying a little Husquvarna #141 at Lowes as that was all they had left. While it is really a home and garden saw it has worked all the time until last month when it refused to start. I took it to an authorized repair shop and for $30 for parts and $64 an hour for labor, I can pick it up or junk it. I'll have it repaired this time but from now on I have to go "cheap"!!

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#9

Re: What about engine size?

Ken

>From what you say on how you will be using it a 45 cc should handle your needs without any trouble.

Ken

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#10

Personally, I really like the Dolmar

Jim K in Trappe PA

>Fast start, Pretty Good mileage. Much more power than a four cylinder.

Jim K


img

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#11

Re: What about engine size?

nailshooter

>I have used and owned several saws. I have been sick of the smaller motors that come with the Poulans, McColloughs, Sears, etc. When you have a chance to use a saw with a motor that will really run the bar and chain it is a really pleasing experience.

But the motor size is directly related to the chain, and that should help you with your decision. For a 16" bar, I wouldn't go anything under 45cc. With a good saw that will develop decent torque that should do you fine for most chainsaw chores.

OTOH, when I bought the Husky with the 24" bar, I went to a 60cc engine, and it is a good fit. I would think 50cc or better would be the best bet on anything over 16" bar length.

One thing that will make a differnce on this (besides keeping the chain sharp!) is the to make sure you used the best fuel mix oil in the saw. I had been told this before, but didn't pay that much attention to it. (Why don't I listen the the repair tech? I dunno...) I am here to tell you it does indeed make a difference. Lowe's started carrying the Husky brand oil, and after using it in the saw I could really tell a diffence. Almost NO smoke, and rarely does it have irregular idle or run speeds.

Another thought since you seem to be ready to go on this. Make sure you identify which bar you are going to get with the saw. For example, the Lowe's 455 Rancher saw at Lowe's has the less expensive laminated bar. In reality, this should do almost everyone (including me!) just fine. But you can get the saw with the "pro" bar which is machined from a piece of flat stock and the sprocket is hardened and replaceable without replacing the whole bar. According to the tech and sales guys I spoke to when shopping, the "pro" bars are much sturdier and have less friction due to the sprocket being able to take in more lube than the laminated type bar. The most important thing to me about that though was that less friction means more tranferable energy to the blade for cutting, not movement.

I don't work for NPECO so don't think I am pushing them, but they were spot on their game when I asked about the different issues and components. In fact, it was those guys that suggested the 460 when I told them that I would be doing not only cutting, but some ripping (bowl blanks!) when I used it. It wasn't much more than the 455 (which is 5 cc less displacement) but they said their feedback from the field indicated that the 455 needed a little more *umpf* in the field for the bigger stuff, so the 460 was born. They even put me to the right chains, and told me I could mix and match as needed on the free ones.

If you go with one of these more expensive saws, I would say get the biggest motor you could afford on it. Like any other tool, if you have to work a saw to death to make it do its job you will wear it out that much sooner. More power at your finger tips never hurts on a chainsaw.

Robert

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#12

Re: Personally, I really like the Dolmar *LINK*

nailshooter

>Yeah, sleek looking no doubt. But as you probably know, Dolmar brand chainsaws are not available in the US on a retail level any longer.

Maybe these guys could help out (see link).

Robert


Real saw power

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#13

Re: What about engine size?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Steve, You will be fine... a larger saw is good for bragging or really big logs but they do get heavy after a while. For a standard size turning blank a large saw is "overkill"... the pictures that Joe Ott posted a while back showed a good size log cut using a Stihl 440 with a 24 inch bar. This could have been done with a smaller saw. I also have a very small Echo trim saw that is just fine to knock the corners off the blank.

A sharp chain is the secret to any chain saw you buy.

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#14

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Curly Smith

>You've had some good advise, now I'll give you mine.

You should only buy a chainsaw from a local dealer (and Lowes and Home Depot don't count as dealers). If you need warranty work you'll discover that the local dealer will not repair a unit ordered via the internet or purchased at the big box stores (in fact the big box stores sell different models than the dealers). You'd have to send your saw to the factory for repairs. Either a Stihl or a Husky will serve you well for years with proper maintenance, the other brands are cheap but disposable.

You want to match a chainsaw to the task. If you'll be routinely cutting 18" diameter stuff then you need a chainsaw with a cutting length of 18". You can cut diameters twice the length of your bar but it requires burying the tip and greatly increases the chances of getting a kickback. From what you've said I think the MS 250 might be a bit small with a max bar length of 18", you might want to bump up to the MS 270 (or Husky equivalent) with an 18" or 20" bar. FWIW, I've got an Stihl MS-290 that I've abused for 8 years and it's still going strong. Under no circumstances should you get a bar length greater than 20". Chainsaws with +20" bars should only be used by very experienced users.

By visiting a local dealer you'll be able to handle the various models in their various configurations. Pay attention to the weight and the weight distribution. Saws get heavier with use, or so my tired body tells me. Chainsaws are dangerous enough without buying one that's too big and too heavy for your routine needs. Remember that the weight quoted for the saws is without the bar, chain, oil and fuel.

Since you said you won't be felling trees, is your only intended use cutting disks for bowl blanks? If so, I'd seriously consider a hand saw. They're much safer and chainsaws can be a serious PITA for occasional use. Chainsaws don't like gas left in them, they don't like old gas, and they don't like the gas you use for your string trimmer (for best results use the 2-cycle oil that the manufacturer of your chainsaw sells). Some places to buy hand saws are:

Timber and Log Saws

Purveyor of Fine Hand Tools for Discerning Craftsmen

Again, FWIW, I cut a bunch of my firewood by hand. It's safer, quieter, good exercise, and relaxing. I only use the chainsaw when I have a bunch of wood that I must cut in a short period of time or trees that I need to take down.

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#15

Re: Personally, I really like the Dolmar

Fog Tanner

>I think it would be safer if they used nitromethane instead of nitrous oxide. A little leak of the NO2 and you probaly wouldn't be in the best condition for cutting wood. Besides nothing beats the throaty rumble of nito....

Cool pic...just needs a blower on top and a set of zoomies

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#16

Steve Kubien

Does Tim the Toolman come to help set up?

Steve Kubien

>LMAO

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#17

Re: What about engine size?

Jorge Castaneda

>Steve, Doug advice is good,

I said this before and I said it again,

Husky or Jonsereds, one orange the other red, both made in the same factory with the same parts, last many years, Stihl goes to repeairs often. The only time I had to take my trusty Jonsereds in 18 years, was because I did put the oil in the gas tank, of course it did not start, a friend borrowed it put straight gas no oil mix and that was the end. So I went out and got a Husky because that is what the dealer in this island has, 8 years so far, it starts at the first or second pull. I have a Husky 353, with a 15" bar, I felt the dealer play dirty when he sold me that saw with that bar, but so far it has done everything I asked to do, my advice, go Husky, stay away from big saws and big bars.

I heat our homestead with wood, so I am a serious wood cutter.

my $0,03, (adjusted for inflation)

Jorge

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#18

George Balock

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

George Balock

>Steve,

You have a bunch of good advice here. The one thing I can add though is that buying a saw is like buying a lathe--you can cut little stuff with a big saw, but you can't cut big stuff with a little saw. Buy the biggest saw that you can afford. You won't regret it. I bought a Stihl MS440 a couple of years ago with a 24" bar. At the time I had the lathe you are thinking of getting and I cut a fair amount of wood for that lathe with the MS440. Good Luck!

George

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#19

Steve Kubien

This is why I shop here

Steve Kubien

>Thanks for all of the advice. I really appreciate it.

Curly, as a semi-neanderthal woodworker who really likes his handplanes and doesn't own a power planer or jointer, you've got me thinking about the handsaw idea. A chainsaw will not sit idle for long periods of time around here (2 weeks max.) so I don't think I have to worry about old fuel. Still, heaven knows I could use the exercise! Maybe I'll stick to a 15 or 16" draw chainsaw and pick up a timber saw when I've something big to handle and thus avoid burying the tip. I will be thinking of that.

Again, thanks a whole big pile.

Steve Kubien

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#20

Re: This is why I shop here

Bill Crommett

>Steve : The good advise is not yet all over. Here is mine: Use only premium gasoline in your chainsaw, It doesn'r degrade with age like the regular grade gasoline. A petrolium chemist explained it this way: Regular gasoline is made with "dirty" technowlogy, because many fractions are used to get the 97 octane so much in demand, but the premium stuff is a less 'Blended" product. I use premium gasoline in all my outdoor equipment, because some of the engines don't get a wokout for months at a time, lke lawn mowers, garden tillers, and especially chain saws who only get the call when a special tree is damaged in a storm.

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#21

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Peter Hyde

>Steve

Look at Makita chainsaws that are in fact made by Dolmar. Available all over Ontarion in Home Hardware and other tool places.

Personally I use a handsaw at the tree and an electric when I get the logs home.Some of us Canuckistanis are strange that way:-)

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

#22

Bob Moffett

Re: Need chainsaw advice...a bit long

Bob Moffett

>I have had 2 Craftsman saws. One lasted 1 1/2 season and the other lasted 1/2 season. After the second one I got a Stil 029 with 18" bar. There is no comparison. I recommend getting a Stihl.