Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Santos Rosewood box....

Posts

Santos Rosewood box....

#1

Mike Stafford

Santos Rosewood box....

Mike Stafford

>Here is a box from a stick labeled "Pau Ferro" that I believe is really Santos Rosewood. This is a wonderful turning wood but requires care when sanding on the end grain as it is prone to heat checks. I usually use wax as a lubricant when sanding the end grain.

My concern is with the proportions of the box. As presented this box is a frog hair more than 2" tall and 2 3/4" in diameter. In the picture, however, it looks almost as if it is the same height as it is in diameter. It is my belief that the box would look better if the box were shorter in relation to its diameter. What say ye? Would the proportions be better if the box was 1 3/4" tall? How do you decide what is the appropriate height for a turned object of a given size when you are starting the turning on the inside such as when you are turning boxes?

Any comments or suggestions appreciated.


img

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

#2

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

Greg Haugen

>Your work is such an inspiration! Top Notch from the craftsmanship of the piece to the incredible picture. Well done. Thanks alot for sharing.

Greg

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

keith tompkins

>HI Mike, Nicely done, as usual. A couple of thoughts on this piece. Since the sides of the box are basically vertical, any problems with proportion are very evident...your profile is essentially a rectangle. It's not the classic "golden rectangle" but I think it is pleasing to look at. You made the cut for the lid in just the right spot...important in this case. Maybe make a few out of scrap to compare the differences, see which ones you prefer.

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

#4

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

dwr

>Mike,

It can be a challenge, especially with the shorter boxes. However, I personally think it is excellent as it is.

Great job, as usual.

Dave

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

Mike Stafford

>Thank you sir. To acheive the perfect golden rectangle this box would have to be shortened to slightly less than 1 3/4". That is still of usable size in that the internal height would be a little less than 1 1/2". I will give that a try on my next one. My problem is that I have to think outside the box while I am turning the inside if you know what I mean....

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

#6

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

Ed Moore

>Mike,

Nice box! It may just be my perception, but I think this box has thinner walls than some of your previous ones - and I think that is good. Experience leads us there as our confidence grows.

As Keith suggested, the joint is well-placed. Rectangular boxes may vary in height and proportion, but the joint placement makes or breaks it.

Ed

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

Mike Stafford

>Ed, with luck I strive to have the sides somewhere in the range of 1/8-3/16" where the there is no overlap of the flange. You are correct about the confidence level as many times I stop cutting when the chatter starts. I am learning to adust the speed and support the wood with my fingers. Thank you for the feedback. I do appreciate it.

Re: Santos Rosewood box....

#8

Sweet!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Lovely box indeed! love the dipped lid.

Beautiful job Mike!

Jen