Re: Motor speed control?
dwr
>Bill,
Here is my rational based on responses from the TB Woods Applications Manager for their VFD's. I had a choice between a 2HP Inverter Duty three phase motor and 5HP three motor. Since the TB Woods VFD was rated for 5HP motors, I went with the 5 HP Leeson I had on hand and decided to build the Phase Converter to get the full 5HP along with the full torque� as you see below, my actual torque is less than that of a 2HP motor because of the single-to-three phase conversion taking place at the VFD.
Here is his answer to my question regarding the two motors and the issue of HP vs. Torque:
"HP is strictly a reference number. Drives work or don�t work based on current draw. When single phasing a drive, we say derate by 50% but that derating is current not HP. The input size of the drive will now see double its normal current rating due to the single phase power versus the three-phase power. The DC buss portion of the drive will see a significant increase in ripple due to the single phase and trying to pull more current than 1/2 the nameplate can cause damage to the power capacitors."
"The other problem is what is called magnetizing current. A motor needs so much current just to make it turn whether is has load or not. In a given motor, approximately 20% of the actual current is magnetizing current. So if we assume your 2 HP motor is rated for around 7 amps and your 5 HP motor is rated for 15 amps, then the 2 HP motor has 1.4 amps for magnetization and the 5 HP would need 3 Amps. So during a run condition, the 2 HP motor has 5.6 amps to work with at full load and the 5 HP motor only 4.5 amps since we have to cut the rating of the drive in half. Bottom line, the 2 HP motor will get more available current to develop torque."
As for being able to stop the spindle with my hand, I had custom three step poly-v pulleys made so I could have three variable speed ranges which would narrow the torque curve and allow me to have a 0-875 rpm range, a 0-1750 rpm range and a 0-3500 rpm range. On the low-end pulley, 0-875, I have excellent torque because of the narrow torque curve. On the high-end, 0-3500 rpm range, I can actually stop the spindle.
TB Woods confirmed that the reduction of torque during the single-to-three phase conversion is the reason my torque drops off so severely and that if I could produce a three-phase input at the VFD, I would retain full torque. Hence, the construction of a phase converter.
I also contacted Oneway regarding their VFD�s and the issue of de-rating torque characteristics. I was told that they actually supply VFD�s that are rated for more HP than the motors they install on the lathes, so that the de-rating of the torque has less of an impact. I could have achieved the same thing by using a 3HP motor with the 5HP VFD... but only had the 2HP and 5HP motors on hand.
I am not an electrical technician. I am just going with the flow based on the VFD manufacturers technical expertise and what they recommend for their VFD, as well as the electrician doing the installation wiring and phase converter.
The net-net, is you need a three phase AC motor and VFD or a DC motor and DC Speed Control to run variable speed. I have three lathes and run both AC and DC motors and Drives... not sure which I prefer right now, just enjoy turning the dial and not swapping the belts around all the time!!
Dave