Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Motor speed control?

Posts

Motor speed control?

#1

Motor speed control?

Jerry Klug

>I have wired my house and shop but motor and controller wiring is beyond me. I need some explanation from someone who understands variable speed controllers.

I am considering buying a lathe that has no motor. I have a motor (Dayton Capacitor A.C. Motor, Mod 5K967C, 3HP, 1740 RPM, 60 Cyc, Cont Duty, Type T, Serv Fact 1.0, FR L184T, Max amps 40 and rated at 14.5 amps for 208-230V, Code H and Insul Class B). I know little of what is important in all that except it is a 3 HP motor that possibly could be a good unit to power a lathe.

Can this motor be equipped with a variable speed control and if so where should I look for one? Would it have good low speed torque? I am assuming it could be set up to operate in both directions.

Any assistance would be appreciated.

Re: Motor speed control?

#2

Re: Motor speed control?

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>One important factor you do not mention. Is it single phase or 3 phase?

Re: Motor speed control?

#3

Re: Motor speed control?

Jerry Klug

>I will have to go to the storage unit tomorrow and look. I thought I wrote down everything that was on the data plate but it isn't in my notes. I take it this is important.

Re: Motor speed control?

#4

Re: Motor speed control?

dwr

>Jerry,

If you are running an AC motor, it needs to be three phase in order to run a Variable Frequency Drive or Inverter as they are called. Single phase motors cannot be run on a VFD.

If you had a DC motor, then you can run it, with the appropriate speed control, using single phase input.

Three phase motors are readily available and at reasonable prices on Ebay. I am currently building a lathe running a 5HP three phase motor with a TB Woods X2C VFD. I have great low end torque using a poly-v groove belt and custom pulleys, however, I can actually stop the 2.25" diameter spindle with my hand on the higher speed pulley settings. This is because the VFD has single phase coming in and then changes it to three phase for the motor. In doing this, the motor is "de-rated" below its tagged HP/Torque. I am now building my own Phase Converter, that will change the single phase incoming electricity, to three phase input at the VFD, which then sends the three phase to the motor and I will get the fully rated HP and Torque from the 5HP motor. A commercial 5HP Rotary Phase Converter can set you back $2,500 or more. I can build one for about 1/10th the cost.

To Convert the Phase from single to three phase, you actually have to run a second three phase motor of equal or greater HP, to create the three phase input to the VFD. A single phase motor is used to "start" the second three phase motor and then is disengaged once the three phase motor reaches full speed, thus allowing it to power the three phase lathe motor. Some oil filled "run capacitors" are wired into the electrical stream and a disconnect is also installed.

The real advantage is you can then run any three phase machine (metal lathe, milling machine, industrial drill press, etc.) from your single phase shop/residential incoming supply and take advantage of some great equipment at reasonable prices, that you otherwise would not be able to use.

So, get a couple of cheap 3hp three phase motors, oil filled capacitors and a disconnect, and use your single phase as the starter motor and get yourself setup to run three phase, variable speed tools in your shop!!

Good luck!

Dave

Re: Motor speed control?

#5

Re: Motor speed control?

Keith Newton

>Not likely. The capacitor would not be needed on 3 ph.

Not even all 3 ph motors will work with VFD's. They need to be higher efficiency.

I have been through this, and would recommend that you buy the drive and motor together. Sometimes you can find them packaged together at a good price.

Re: Motor speed control?

#6

Re: Motor speed control?

Bill Howatt

>I am not a control expert but I don't understand the reasoning behind this:

"I have great low end torque using a poly-v groove belt and custom pulleys, however, I can actually stop the 2.25" diameter spindle with my hand on the higher speed pulley settings. This is because the VFD has single phase coming in and then changes it to three phase for the motor. In doing this, the motor is "de-rated" below its tagged HP/Torque. I am now building my own Phase Converter, that will change the single phase incoming electricity, to three phase input at the VFD, which then sends the three phase to the motor and I will get the fully rated HP and Torque from the 5HP motor."

Why does it really impact on the operation if the VFD is fed from 3-phase instead of single-phase if the circuit is adequate. AFAIK, VFDs convert the input voltage to DC and then chop it up at the appropriate frequence to control the motor. In other words the power to the motor comes from DC and it doesn't know anything about the input being 1 or 3 phases.

I can slow my 2HP General on the highest belt setting (up to 3000rpm) by grabbing my 4.5" dia chuck if the speed setting is relatively slow (under several hundred rpm). This doesn't cause any problems in turning because the heavy/large diameter work is turned at lower speeds and the step pulleys permit the operation in a more efficient region. I don't try to turn a 18" wet blank with the belt on the highest range. IMO, you are attacking a theoretical problem that doesn't manifest itself in practice but I am willing to be corrected about this.

Bill

Re: Motor speed control?

#7

Re: Motor speed control?

Jerry Klug

>I checked the data plate on my 3HP Dayton motor and it does list "PH-1". The phase converters comments are very interesting but a bit complicated for my less than electronic brain. I find the interchange interesting but I think I better keep the motor scope simple and pass on the motorless lathe. I will stick to already wired and operating equipment so I can use my grey cells making sawdust. Thank you all for the help.

Re: Motor speed control?

#8

Re: Motor speed control?

dwr

>Bill,

Here is my rational based on responses from the TB Woods Applications Manager for their VFD's. I had a choice between a 2HP Inverter Duty three phase motor and 5HP three motor. Since the TB Woods VFD was rated for 5HP motors, I went with the 5 HP Leeson I had on hand and decided to build the Phase Converter to get the full 5HP along with the full torque� as you see below, my actual torque is less than that of a 2HP motor because of the single-to-three phase conversion taking place at the VFD.

Here is his answer to my question regarding the two motors and the issue of HP vs. Torque:

"HP is strictly a reference number. Drives work or don�t work based on current draw. When single phasing a drive, we say derate by 50% but that derating is current not HP. The input size of the drive will now see double its normal current rating due to the single phase power versus the three-phase power. The DC buss portion of the drive will see a significant increase in ripple due to the single phase and trying to pull more current than 1/2 the nameplate can cause damage to the power capacitors."

"The other problem is what is called magnetizing current. A motor needs so much current just to make it turn whether is has load or not. In a given motor, approximately 20% of the actual current is magnetizing current. So if we assume your 2 HP motor is rated for around 7 amps and your 5 HP motor is rated for 15 amps, then the 2 HP motor has 1.4 amps for magnetization and the 5 HP would need 3 Amps. So during a run condition, the 2 HP motor has 5.6 amps to work with at full load and the 5 HP motor only 4.5 amps since we have to cut the rating of the drive in half. Bottom line, the 2 HP motor will get more available current to develop torque."

As for being able to stop the spindle with my hand, I had custom three step poly-v pulleys made so I could have three variable speed ranges which would narrow the torque curve and allow me to have a 0-875 rpm range, a 0-1750 rpm range and a 0-3500 rpm range. On the low-end pulley, 0-875, I have excellent torque because of the narrow torque curve. On the high-end, 0-3500 rpm range, I can actually stop the spindle.

TB Woods confirmed that the reduction of torque during the single-to-three phase conversion is the reason my torque drops off so severely and that if I could produce a three-phase input at the VFD, I would retain full torque. Hence, the construction of a phase converter.

I also contacted Oneway regarding their VFD�s and the issue of de-rating torque characteristics. I was told that they actually supply VFD�s that are rated for more HP than the motors they install on the lathes, so that the de-rating of the torque has less of an impact. I could have achieved the same thing by using a 3HP motor with the 5HP VFD... but only had the 2HP and 5HP motors on hand.

I am not an electrical technician. I am just going with the flow based on the VFD manufacturers technical expertise and what they recommend for their VFD, as well as the electrician doing the installation wiring and phase converter.

The net-net, is you need a three phase AC motor and VFD or a DC motor and DC Speed Control to run variable speed. I have three lathes and run both AC and DC motors and Drives... not sure which I prefer right now, just enjoy turning the dial and not swapping the belts around all the time!!

Dave

Re: Motor speed control?

#9

Re: Motor speed control?

Bill Howatt

>Dave,

Thanks for the informative response. I'm a bit wiser now. Good luck with the project.

Bill

Re: Motor speed control?

#10

Re: Motor speed control?

Bob Fawcett

>The VFD supplied with my PM 3520 does not show a HP rating. It is rated at 7.5 amps 3phase 220 output no matter the input. The input shows a single phase 220 draw of 15.7 amps and 3 phase draw of 8.4 amps. The motor is rated at 2HP, 6.2 amps 220 3 phase. This appears to be a proper match to me.

I think the current ratings on whatever VFD are more important than the HP. As long as the VFD can supply the needed current for the motor with the input you intend to use, it should be capable of developing maximum torque.

The pole count of the motor is also relevant. Mine is a 4 pole motor and speed at 60hz would be 1720. If the motor were designed to run at 3500 rpm at 60hz you would see different torque characteristics.

The VFD on my unit has a 400hz max freq. This should make the motor run at about 6 times its normal rpm.

Re: Motor speed control?

#11

Brad Vietje

3 Ph inverter packages...

Brad Vietje

>There are some decent deals out there on inverter/3Ph motor packages. All you have to do is supply a 220 1-phase line, and the inverter drives the 3-Ph with variable speed. I did this a few years ago, but no longer have the web links I used then.

If the lathe has manual-change step pulleys, you don't need a lot of horsepower -- you just use the variable speed over a number of different speed ranges. You'd use the lower range for roughing and heavier chunks of wood, and select a higher range by moving the belt for smaller pieces, or spindle turning. If you retain this manual step-pulley control of speed ranges for your variable speed motor, you'll be surprised what you can do with a 1 hp package (~$350).

I have a friend who turns big, natural-edge sculptural bowls up to 4' in diameter or so, and cores big burls up to about 30" with no more than 1.5 hp on a big, home-made lathe. Applying a 1 hp variable speed, 220v 3ph motor to a manual speed change Nova 3000 (8 steps and 16" swing) yields an impressive amount of low speed torque for roughing and coring operations, and positively screams at the higher ranges. While most work can be done without ever changing belt positions, you will have the capability to go real slow or real fast, as needed.

So, don't rule out that motor-less lathe just yet -- someone here must have a link to variable frequency drive/motor packages...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Motor speed control?

#12

http://www.dealerselectric.com/

Stuart Johnson

>

Re: Motor speed control?

#13

However that 400Hz...

Leppikallio

>is something you shouldn't try with most motors. I'm sure there is much wiser persons reading these so please give facts if you have them but basically every motor has some limit when rpm doesn't increase anymore. Also torque has been effectively zero before that limit. Please correct me if I'm wrong but I think 100Hz is pretty much maximum with these standard motors? I have been fooling with my setup now and 95Hz with 1390rpm motor (50Hz) is something I have tried and it does that without complaints...

Re: Motor speed control?

#14

Re: However that 400Hz...

Bob Fawcett

>You are right.

The top speed given by the manufacturer is a little over 3000rpm. I am sure this does not require 400hz. They probably program the VFD to top out at something less than 400. If the unit were direct drive, it would need 120hz to get to 3500rpm. I don't know the pulley sizes for the belt drive, but the high speed pair look to be close to the same size.

Re: Motor speed control?

#15

http://www.driveswarehouse.com/

Bob Fawcett

>