Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Fixing a finish

Posts

Fixing a finish

#1

Steve Kubien

Fixing a finish

Steve Kubien

>Afternoon everybody,

I sanded a birdseye maple plate on the lathe until it was sickenly smooth. 2 coats of tung oil, rubbed out with ultra fine steel wool between coats and after the last coat. Applied hard carnuaba wax on the lathe and buffed with a soft cloth. That was almost a month ago and now the surface feels rough like the grain has raised. Any ideas what happened and how I can fix it? Is it possible that the grain did raise after all this time? Could the wax be reacting with the tung oil?

This plate was/is to be an auction piece for a seminar I've got coming up and I would hate to have it go south on the buyer.

Thanks for your help.

Steve Kubien

P.S. Should also mention that the piece had a nice shine to it originally (about a semi-gloss). Now it looks flat.

Re: Fixing a finish

#2

Re: Fixing a finish

Mark Wollschlager

>You might try beall buffing, which will reapply the carnuba at the end.

Perhaps just buffing the wax will be enough.

Just a thought.

Mark.

Re: Fixing a finish

#3

Re: Fixing a finish

Russ Babbitt Jr.

>I'm no expert on finishing. I wonder what others may think about the oil not having a chance to set before applying the carnuba. I wander if dust may have settled on the piece giving it that raised grain feel. My quick answer was also the Beall. That is one reason I like the Beall you can always go back and refresh the surface finish.

Re: Fixing a finish

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Fixing a finish

Richard Allen

>Sometimes "sanding" to an ultra smooth surface actually burnishes the wood.

You should raise sanding dust when sanding, even at the very fine grits. Skipping at the fine grits is a good way to insure burnishing. Burnishing is the bending of wood fibers which results in a very smooth surface but ends up having a BUNCH wood fibers bent over. Those fibers are likely to "spring up" over time.

Actually I have no idea what happened. I would suggest that you sand back the finish to bare wood. Stop sanding around 400 grit, with the last few grits being hand sanded with the grain. Examine the surface in good light, you can wipe some lacquer thiner on the sanded surface to help any errant scratches show up.

I find pure tung oil to be slow drying. I would tend to go with one of the faster drying oils if the oil look was what I was after. It would also be a good idea to wait a week or two between the application of oil and wax.

Good luck

Re: Fixing a finish

#5

Re: Fixing a finish

Jorge Castaneda

>H i Steve,

I am no finish expert, but in the flat side of my life, before the final finish I wet the piece on purpose to raise the grain and then sand again, I have not done that yet in turnings, but is an easy thing to try.

When a finish does look bad to me, I sand back to bare wood and do it all over again

Good luck

Jorge

Re: Fixing a finish

#6

Re: Fixing a finish

Jimiles-Charlotte, NC

>Steve: was the wood totally dry? I've had pieces I thought were dry, finished them and 30 days later the same results as yours from the wood continuing to dry a bit.

Re: Fixing a finish

#7

Steve Kubien

Thanks for the help

Steve Kubien

>Thanks everybody. Here's where I think things stand right now....

Yes, the stock was totally dry. It is possible that the oil hadn't sat for long enough prior to putting on the wax.

I am going to try to rebuff the wax and see what happens. Worst case scenario is I have to sand it back to bare and go at it again.

Cheers!

Steve Kubien

Re: Fixing a finish

#8

Re: Fixing a finish

eliot d

>Richard, I'm always impressed with your breadth of knowledge, but I didn't understand exactly what you meant by, "Skipping at the fine grits is a good way to insure burnishing."

Re: Fixing a finish

#9

Leo Van Der Loo

I don't know Steve, but I think you might have put

Leo Van Der Loo

>put too much oil on it initially, or kept it to cool, it should to sit warm for the tung oil to cure. As it is now I would try to polish it with some white diamond on the buffer, set it warm, and see what it does, just my thoughts on it, and good luck.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Fixing a finish

#10

Steve Kubien

Thanks Leo

Steve Kubien

>Ya know, you may be right about it being left in too cool a spot. I'll (try to) remember that for next time.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien