Re: Coring Systems
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>I bought the McNaughten Combo set (large and small) before they changed the tip grind. I thus had to regrind my knives which work better now. The McN has gotten some bad comments, I think because some reviewers tried to "muscle" the cuts rather than letting the tool and the lathe do the work.
I tried the Oneway on another's lathe, and found that while the learning curve is shorter and the set is more forgiving because of the blade support being inside the kerf, I much prefer the McN's different profiles.
I don't use mine to make nested bowl sets which, while interesting turning exercises and commercially viable for their novelty, I regard as rather useless. If I want a "set" of bowls, I make a set, as in 4, 8, or 12 all the same.
I'm happy if I get 2 or 3 bowls out of a blank, and the McN does that for me just fine with very little effort.
Just a note: NEVER grind the top of the McN knives to sharpen them. Their knives have a fairly thin waffer of high speed steel bonded to the top edge of the end of the "softer" knife body. If you grind that off, you can go get a new knife as the knives' body-metal won't hold an edge for *****. Basically you grind them as you would a scraper, letting the stone push up a slight burr at the end. I use a 120 grit wheel on my set, and they cut very well without any honing.
Stongly suggest you get Mahoney's video; it will shorten your "curve" considerably.
Fell Better!
mm