Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Coring Systems

Posts

Coring Systems

#1

Coring Systems

RevDoug

>I know the question has been asked and answered, but I cannot find it with the search. Anyway, I'm getting pretty tired of seeing multiple bowls laying on the floor needing to be swept up and put on the compost pile. I've seen both the Oneway and the McNaughton in use. The demonstrators made the process look easy.

Which do you prefer? Why?

Are there other units than these two that I need to take a further look at?

I look forward to seeing what the collective of WC has to say on this subject.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Coring Systems

#2

Re: Coring Systems

Atwerz

>Another question regarding coring systems. What minimum horsepower is needed for each level of each coring system? I have a jet 1442 and was looking at the McNaughten smaller set.

Re: Coring Systems

#3

Re: Coring Systems

Michael Sinclair in Orkney

>I use the McNaughton.I don't push it to the limit but make sure not to turn the main bowl into a funnel and have a useable core.

There is a learning curve but just take your time to begin with,I even managed to get a core first go!I have stalled the VB with it but it was due to not paying attention.If you are selling work it will definately pay for itself.I don't beat myself up by trying to get 2 or 3 cores,if I get one I'm happy.I would say I'm glad I have it, just take the time to figure it out and it's no problem.

Michael

Re: Coring Systems

#4

Re: Coring Systems

Darryl Hansen

>I use the Mc Naughton on a 1hp Nova. There is a learning curve but after you master it it is really very easy to use.

Re: Coring Systems

#5

Re: Coring Systems *LINK*

George Van

>Doug, glad to hear you are keeping your self busy through recovery. I use the McNaughton set and like it. For the price it is a good tool. The 10� and under cores go quickly. The larger ones take a little more time to clear the chips from the long path along the blade before they fly out or you back out the blade to clear. If you check the archive for McNaughton you will get many topics on this subject.


Archive

Re: Coring Systems

#6

Re: Coring Systems

Bill Neddow

>George, I have both the McNaughton and the Oneway. I only use the Oneway. Much easier to control and any catches do a lot less damage to the equipment.

Re: Coring Systems

#7

Re: Coring Systems

Greg Haugen

>I use the Mcnaughton. If you follow Grumbine's or Mahoney's instructions and tips the "learning curve" can be gone in an hour or two. I'd say that the minimum power should be one horse. You couldn't use it on less power but I'd be more worried about the bearings on a smaller lathe than the motor. I'd think the Jet 1442 would be ok but the Delta or Jet iron beds maye be slightly small. I've never used the oneway because simply it's dang expensive. the right one will be whatever one you get, learn to use it, and then use it.

Hope it helps,

Greg Haugen

Re: Coring Systems

#8

Re: Coring Systems

DickAnderson

>Doug:

I have the McNaughton system and have used it on both the Nova 3000 and Nova DVR lathes and the Vicmarc lathe. Have cored green and dry wood that maxed out the lathe size (16"). McNaughton worked fine, but because of the limited power of the Nova lathes I took it slow and easy. Lathe power is independent of the hollowing system comparison, but is mentioned only lets you know of my experience.

The McNaughton is less expensive and has more flexibility than the One-Way system, which cores only a semi-circle. I would suggest that if you get the McNaughton that you also get the Mahoney video or have another turner show you the ins and outs of the system.

Dick

Re: Coring Systems

#9

Re: Coring Systems

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Atwerz, I have cored bowls on the Jet 1442 with my Kel McNaughton system with no trouble. I need to be a little more patient than normal, but I think it is still faster than hollowing, and certainly faster than hollowing and sweeping up!

Bill

Re: Coring Systems

#10

Re: Coring Systems

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Doug, I prefer the KM. Of course, when I bought it, it was pretty much the only one around, but even today, I would still make it my first choice. It is very quick to set up, easy to use once it is set up properly, and is no more expensive to maintain than the cutters for the Oneway. I remember in a thread somewhere someone recommending that the person buy the Oneway because with the KM tool you had to replace the entire knife, whereas with Oneway you could replace the cutter tip for $35.00. The knives I have replaced so far have all been that same price.

Good luck with it (so to speak) and I hope you are feeling a little bit better today.

Bill

Re: Coring Systems

#11

Re: Coring Systems

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I bought the McNaughten Combo set (large and small) before they changed the tip grind. I thus had to regrind my knives which work better now. The McN has gotten some bad comments, I think because some reviewers tried to "muscle" the cuts rather than letting the tool and the lathe do the work.

I tried the Oneway on another's lathe, and found that while the learning curve is shorter and the set is more forgiving because of the blade support being inside the kerf, I much prefer the McN's different profiles.

I don't use mine to make nested bowl sets which, while interesting turning exercises and commercially viable for their novelty, I regard as rather useless. If I want a "set" of bowls, I make a set, as in 4, 8, or 12 all the same.

I'm happy if I get 2 or 3 bowls out of a blank, and the McN does that for me just fine with very little effort.

Just a note: NEVER grind the top of the McN knives to sharpen them. Their knives have a fairly thin waffer of high speed steel bonded to the top edge of the end of the "softer" knife body. If you grind that off, you can go get a new knife as the knives' body-metal won't hold an edge for *****. Basically you grind them as you would a scraper, letting the stone push up a slight burr at the end. I use a 120 grit wheel on my set, and they cut very well without any honing.

Stongly suggest you get Mahoney's video; it will shorten your "curve" considerably.

Fell Better!

mm

Re: Coring Systems

#12

Re: Coring Systems

RPE

>I fretted over which to buy. I bought the Oneway. It works the first time, every time. NO learning curve. I only bought one set of knives, the 9". The book says you can go 2" above and below the knife set. I can do that. I have a PM3520. I can get three "bowls" out of a 13 or 14" blank. The outside one is a normal deep bowl, the middle is a normal bowl and the inside one is more like a small platter! If you core out a bowl larger than the knife size, i.e. an 11" from a 9" knife the bottom can get concave if you don't "snap" it out before it gets to that point. If you go under the size of the knife i.e. a 7" from a 9" knife, the bowl shape tends to be convex shaped, if you let it get to that point. I core my bowls to the 10% wall thickness rule and it seems to work.

Watch that video from oneway on the easy core. Just do it like the demonstrator says and it will be fine. I got mine from Cutting Edge in Houston.

It is pretty simple. It fits my mentality perfectly.

Take the 1 out of my email address for PM.

Re: Coring Systems

#13

Re: Coring Systems

RevDoug

>Thanks for all the opinions. I guess I have some more homework to do. You all have answered all my question and more. I'll let you know what I come up with, if I do decide.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Coring Systems

#14

Re: Coring Systems

robo hippy

>If you are coming to Portland, I will be doing 2 rotations on bowl coring systems. I should be filming a DVD on the McNaughton next week, with the idea of having it ready for Portland. I prefer the McNaughton for bowls under 14 inches as it is faster to set up and use for me. The Oneway is steadyier for bigger bowls. but you have to turn off the lathe to advance the support finger. This can be 4 or 5 times on a big bowl. I wish the tips were easier to sharpen. Woodcut is a good unit, but small (big blade is 5 inch radius).

robo hippy