Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

Posts

Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#1

Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

Steve Russell

>Hello to the group,

I have been looking into the possibility of adding short (1 minute or less) video segments to some of the Wednesday night Turning Chats. As you are probably aware, this raises bandwidth issues... However if we limit the segments to 1 minute or less, with an overall limit on the number of segments as well, we might be able to add video to some of the chats.

The details are far from being settled as there is a lot of work to get a page up and the video coded for viewing easily from different browsers. I have two short video segments on my website that are self-contained with viewers and players. All you have to do is click on the play button and you see the video in a small window. If you have never seen a preview video with a self-contained player, click on the link at the bottom of this message and you can watch the two on my web page.

My question is this... If we can get some video segments submitted by members (that relate to the chat topics) and you can watch them as easily as those on my website in a separate browser window, do you feel this will add to the value of the chat? If yes, why and if not, why? Obviously the member would need a video camera to shoot the video, but lots of folks have them these days...

My thoughts are that in certain instances, a short video of a project, technique, or other "on topic" material would be a nice added touch that would make it easier for the members to comment on the material vs. a standard picture, or lengthy text. This is all preliminary at the moment and nothing is set in stone. If everyone thinks that video will do nothing for the chat, then we will drop this and move on to other ideas. If however, you think it might be useful in some situations (obviously we could not do it all the time), then I can pursue this matter further.

Please give me your thoughts on this as my efforts are intended to increase the educational and informational value of the Turning Chats. I have the ability to edit and code the webpage for the video segments, but lots of other details need to be worked out. This might be a way to raise the bar a bit for the chat and then again, I may need to go and sweep out my studio for bringing up the idea in the first place. :-o Either way, your comments are appreciated and I stand with broom in hand ready to investigate this further, or get to sweeping... Ugh, I'd rather eat dirt than sweep out the studio... :-(

Thanks and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Wednesday Night Turning Chat Moderator


Example of Short Self-Contained Video with Player

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#2

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Don in Central Illinois

>I wasn't too much in favor of this. I thought it would be too bulky and cumbersome, but after viewing your example, I think it would be fine. However, I'm at work with a cable modem and I have DSL at home. It may still prove a problem with dial up users.

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#3

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Stuart Johnson

>Steve,

Many are still on dial-up connections which pretty well eliminates videos. Other than that and possibly the need to add some plug-ins I think it is a good way to get across a detail that might be loss in a still photo.

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#4

Questions, comments from a dialup user

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Steven,

Do both of your sample videos start loading as soon as we get to that page, or is it not until we click the arrow on one or the other?

If the latter, then good thing, at least if we know we would only like to view one video. If the former, then we're wastiing time and bandwidth waiting for a movie we won't watch. I had no interest in the pen video, but would like to see the bowl-turning one. I am still waiting after about 10 minutes, and it looks to be only half-way through. It would be nice to know the total file size of each video, so we can decide beforehand if we want to take the time waiting for it to completely load.On my connection, it takes about 3 minutes to load 1 megabyte. I'm guessing your bowl video is about 6-7 mb. To me, it looks to be very good quality and worth waiting for. But most of my internet resources were tied up while waiting to find that out.

Could be it's all a moot point. Maybe dialup users are such a minority anymore that we're not even worth considering? I don't know.

I missed last night's chat but I would like to get in on some of them this summer, and I think the videos are a cool idea as long as they're not too big!

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#5

There is a way of doing that here *Video*

Ron in Drums PA

>It can be done


Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#6

Re: Questions, comments from a dialup user

Steve Russell

>Hello Ken,

Thanks for your email. I was a dial-up user myself for many years... Your thoughts and concerns are very important to me. I want to improve the chat experience for everyone at WC, not just the broadband folks.

My video previews on the website do not start until you press the play button. That way, if you're on dial-up you can click on the one that interests you and not wait on another to load.

For our purposes in the chat, we would have one or two videos available and you could click on them before the chat starts and wait for the video to fully load. Then, during the chat, you could watch it and comment if you wish. That would help some with the wait time for dial-up users, if you could get to the chat a few minutes early.

Your suggestion about noting the file size of the video is a good one. Thanks and please accept my apologies for not including this important information! We can certainly do that for the chat videos and I should note it on my website as well. Thanks and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Wednesday Night Turning Moderator

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#7

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Steve Russell

>Hello Don,

Thanks for your email... I'm working on a way to help the dial-up users enjoy the videos as well. If the video is available before the chat begins, a dial-up user could download it during the meet and greet session (or maybe as they are finishing dinner) and be ready to watch it as the chat begins. That should help out some. I'm also looking at ways to reduce the file size to allow a faster download for everyone. Thanks and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Wednesday Night Turning Chat Moderator

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#8

Another Test - Warning 980K file - *Video*

Ron in Drums PA

>











Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#9

opps sorry

Ron in Drums PA

>I should have hit preview, sorry about the vulgar language

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#10

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Allen Neighbors

>I just tried to view the video and couldn't download it. After I clicked on the play button, I waited 5 minutes, and gave up. :(

Not your fault, my dial up stinks.

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#11

Re: 4m 35sec for the link to load

Al Crandall (N.E. of Indy)

>It took over 4 1/2 minutes for the link to open to your site. I gave up waiting for the video to load. Video in the chat is a good idea, but I don't think I could keep up with the pace.

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#12

Does this work any better? *BIG Video*

Ron in Drums PA

>I think what might be a better idea for videos is to upload them to WC a few days ahead of time so everyone can view them at their leisure.
















Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#13

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Steve Russell

>Hello Allen,

What we are thinking about doing is having a video available before the chat begins... You could then download it well before the discussion starts and then watch it as we discuss it. Even if it took 15 minutes to download, you could set your computer and go watch TV, or read whilst the video downloaded.

Then, join the chat at the normal time and proceed. I understand that we cannot add videos during the discussion, but what about before? Do you think this would work for you with a dial-up connection? Thanks and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Wednesday Night Turning Chat Moderator

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#14

Re: 4m 35sec for the link to load

Steve Russell

>Hello Al,

You're right about that, but what if the video is available well before the chat begins... You simply set your computer and let it download while you drink a cup of coffee, or read the paper, finish dinner etc. Then join the chat at the regular time and watch the previously downloaded video during the discussion. Would this work for you? Obviously, there would be a limit on the videos, probably only one per session. What do you think? Thanks and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Wednesday Night Turning Chat Moderator

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#15

JL

Re:Some people have way too much time!

JL

>

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Dick Hines

>Sounds like a great idea for the people that have fast internet. I don't think it would work for me because I use a dial up modem and peanut butter runs down hill faster than my interner.

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#17

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

John Veerkamp

>Probably a good idea, but due to my slow dialup connection I won't be able to view them. Don't let this stop it for others though.

John

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#18

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Allen Neighbors

>Yes. I can download a video while I'm finishing a piece, then come back and view it. My only problem with Chat, is being able to get in in time to link up. Fire calls, and accidents requiring extrication, sometimes keep me from getting on whene everyone else is there.

I like the idea of the videos...

But dial-up still stinks. :)

Thanks, Steve.

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#19

Re: Questions, comments from a dialup user

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>Hi Steve,

Your video previews may not start until you press the play button but it seems they do load in the background. I have both my desktop & laptop hooked to DSL lite. I'm on WC on the desktop and have your link loading on the laptop. The desktop is sluggish and there's much busyness on the router. ;-) Ok, your's is finished loading and when I start the video there's virtually no activity at the router. Your previews do preload.

Ed

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#20

Re: Questions, comments from a dialup user

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I saw the same indication, in a different way. My dialup program has virtual "LED" status bars, one for send and one for recieve. As soon as the video sample page loaded, the recieve bar filled up and stayed that way for the whole time, that's before I clicked on the play arrow. Before doing that I waited about 5 minutes, then when I clicked on it the bar indicator jumped up a tad to show what had been loaded.

Steve, if you had just one video per page, it would load faster. We can open each page in a browser tab, or seperate window.

Two versions of a video would be ideal--a low quality one for dialup, and high q for broadband. Probably asking too much, though :)

As long as I *am* asking a lot, I would suggest the ideal scenario would be to start with a quick slide show of a video, showing just a few preview frames. This flash file would have a small file size, and would point to the full video version. If you are good with Flash, just about anything is possible. I wish I had a good command of the program!

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#21

Re: Does this work any better? *BIG Video*

Don in Central Illinois

>Just think of all the time they had to spend setting this all up and the could have been on the lathe turning something!

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#22

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Don in Central Illinois

>Is that 'chunky' or 'smooth' peanut butter?

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#23

Re: Questions, comments from a dialup user

Steve Russell

>Hello Ken,

Thanks for the information... I was unaware that the video preview pre-loaded in the background. I've been on broadband for years, so you tend not to notice load times as it all happens so fast. We could certainly have a single video on a page to make the load time faster. We could also have a lower quality video for dial-up users and a higher quality one for the BB folks.

There may be a way to also prevent a pre-load of the video, I'll look into that. A flash slide show sounds interesting as well, but I'm not sure how to do it. Lots of good information, thanks for helping me on this... Take care and all the best to you and yours!

Steve Russell

Wednesday Night Turning Chat Moderator

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#24

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea?

Steve Russell

>Hello Allen,

I know what you mean about getting called away... I was in the Fire/EMS Department for several years and we were on 24 hour call. I can't tell you how many times the radio alert would go off during dinner, while taking a bath, while sleeping, etc; for either a fire, or EMS call.

You got to where you would go to sleep with one eye open and one leg in your turnout gear. :-o Many times, I would just sleep in my turnout gear to save a couple of minutes. That was in my younger days though, when I thought that riding on an exposed tailboard (with no safety belt), in the sleet and rain going 50 miles an hour to a fire was fun... I still get an adrenaline rush whenever I hear a fire or EMS siren. :-) Those were the days!

Steve Russell

The Woodlands, Texas

Re: Adding Video To The Turning Chat - Good Idea? *LINK*

#25

Re: Grinnin' from ear to ear...

Allen Neighbors

>Yep... ditto what you said! (But I never slept in my turnouts) That's why I can't give it up yet. I got certified at Wichita Falls Fire school, in 79, (at the age of 40, while on the CFD) but now I'm only a volunteer. Pumper operator at structures, and accidents, and BBQ Grill rider on range fires. I still love it!

Board footer: