Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

(Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

Posts

(Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

#1

(Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

Craig Daymon

>There was a news link yesterday on the news site I read talking about an "artist" who's body of work seems to be copies of other folks. This guy even has a painting hanging in an L.A. gallery.

Anyway, since we have had discussions about copying someone elses work, I think this is a perfect example of taking that to the extreme.

The first link is a satirical jab at the "artist" and, even though it might make you angry, it is fun to read.

http://www.somethingawful.com/d/news/todd-goliath-goldman.php

The second is a site that collects images of the "artist's" work along with what others perceive to be the original. It also includes links to other sites doing the same and a copy of the letter from the "artist's" lawyer trying to stop them. This is also interesting because it includes overlays of the "artist's" work on top of the original to see just how blatent the copying was.

http://www.miketyndall.com/todd_goldman/

Thank goodness the hands-on nature of woodturning/working makes it difficult to do something to this level.

-Craig

Re: (Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

#2

Re: Continuing the OT

Dinyar Chavda

>You're right, Craig, it did make me angry, but not for the reason you probably think.

This guy, Johnny Titanium, who wrote the update, says:



    September 19, 2001-- a mere 8 days after our nation's first ever tragedy.


First ever!!!

Whoever he is, he has the most short-sighted sense of history that I have encountered in quite a while---I guess that if it did not happen in Titanium's lifetime, it is of no import. Obvious, he has never heard of the tragedies of the battles in WWI and WWII, to say nothing of the deaths in the Civil War, or in Korea and Vietnam, all of which resulted in far more horrific loss of life. Even if he intends to restrict himself to attacks on US soil, I guess that, according to him, December 7, 1941 no longer is a date that "will live in infamy".

At that point in his update, I lost respect for anything Johnny Titanium had to say.

Re: (Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

#3

Re: Continuing the OT

Ron in Drums PA

>Good Points Dinyar

How many people know that the White House was set on fire by enemy soldiers.

Re: (Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

#4

Steven Antonucci

It brings up an interesting series of questions...

steve antonucci

>Let's see what the lawyers think about this-

1.) If you look at the scope of this, it appears that the guy copies things from everywhere, but all copying is not the same.

I believe that US law protects parody, so I assume that the Absolut T-shirt would be "ok", although I'm not sure if the legal definition of parody might apply here.

His work appears to directly copy some "open source" work- i.e., things that are either public domain or not copyrighted (are they the same thing?) If I post a picture, drawing or other work on the internet, do I retain any rights to it or does it enter the public domain? How many of the sources have gone through the "legal process" to protect themselves? He seems to back down pretty quickly against "big companies" like Absolut and Disney, where you know they've got the proper paperwork in place to protect their properties.

3.) Ethically, I'm mixed here. The guy has taken other people's work without licensing it (bad), but created the marketing,sales, and distribution around it on his own (good). Representing it as his own work is no different than a woodturner "copying" a form- the execution and the source both matter. The work is clearly "his" since his hands produced it, but the idea isn't. Does tht mean that none of us should be producing hollowforms without Ellsworth's permission?

But where does the value come from? Is it the idea or is it the marketing? None of the images or "art" work that he copied had any commercial value until he repackaged them. So is the original idea worth anything in the public domain or is it his creativity in sales and marketing that is makes the art?

Food for thought... looking forward to what others think.

Steve

Re: (Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

#5

Re: It brings up an interesting series of question

Rick Allen

>The information in the link provided should explain the difference between David Ellsworth pots and the cartoons that Todd copies.

Re: (Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

#6

Re: It brings up an interesting series of question  *LINK*

Rick Allen

>


Copyright - visual arts pamphlet

Re: (Not entirely)OT - How to make $$$ with no effort

#7

Steven Antonucci

A very interesting read-thanks for the link.

steve antonucci

>More questions than answers, I think. Not sure how the Internet affects this, since the laws all predate a practical web...

Thanks again.

Steve