Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

First Posting - Walnut Vase

Posts

First Posting - Walnut Vase

#1

Bob Moffett

First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Here is a Walnut Vase that I turned after getting help from people on this board. It is 9" tall and about 5" across hollowed the 1/4 - 3/8" think. I cored it and then hollowed it out. I turned the wood green and finished with Waterlox. Please give me some evaluative feedback as I am trying to learn to turn these. The grain pattern is from a knot being in the wood near the top of the piece. I know the picture isn't great. What do most of you use for a background?

Thanks in advance


img

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#2

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>You did a fine job turning that nice piece of Walnut, Bob. I expect that you mean you �bored�, and then hollowed it. Coring that form would be rough.

I generally use a white pillowcase for my background, but that is probably not a great idea. Build a photo tent. I will send you some plans if you like (and yes, I need to build one too).

Gil

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#3

Bob Moffett

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Gil,

I guess boring would be a better term. I have alot to learn, but at least I realize it. I have been a lurker for a while and am figuring out how to post pictures. If you would send me those plans I would appreciate it. I found an article by Jamie Donaldson in the Articles & Reviews about making a photo box. I used the sofa to take this picture on.

Thanks,

Bob

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#4

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Allen Neighbors

>Bob, that's a nice vase. Beautiful wood, and you show it well, with your finishing. What type of hollowing tool did you use?

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#5

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Jim Terry

>Bob,

That is a great job and a very nice piece of walnut. I hope you will bring it Tues., I want to see how you hollowed it.

Jim

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#6

ebd

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

ebd

>Beautiful. You must have a boatload of patience and skill to hollow something like that. I use a grey blanket. My brother-in -law works for Kodak and is an avid photo nut. He tells me to get an "18% photo grey" background. I guess I'm not that into photography. I'm just trying to keep a record to remind me of what I have done. As long as the photo is in good focus, relatively well framed and the color of the wood is accurate I'm happy.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#7

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Fawcett

>Very nice vase.

I have yet to hollow something like that.

The article you found by Jamie is a great way to setup a photo booth without spending a lot of money.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Brad Vietje

>Great job, Bob.

Very nice vase or bottle or hollow form -- it all depends who you ask. These are not easy, so all the more credit to your fine work. This is a great looking piece that anyone would love to own.

Was this hollowed in two pieces and then re-joined ? It looks like there is a nicely done glue join a little below the neck, in the style of Elvie Jackson or John Jordan. If so, my only suggestion would be to feature that line with a bead or small detail, or mask it with beads or a carved or woodburned detail band. I mostly make these sort of forms in one piece, so I like to keep a clear separation between one-piece hollow forms (for which I charge more), and the two-piece ones that I sell for a little less. One way is to leave a raised band on the neck piece, and then texture or carve this with an abrupt transition to the smooth finish of the lower section. It usually looks great, and allows a less-than-perfect glue join to still look very good.

After a few tries in the beginning, I have learned to never try to make a 2-piece pass for a single-piece hollow form. In fact, on a lark once I made a difficult one-piece hollow form with a narrow neck and small opening, and tried to create the illusion that it was done in two pieces with a burn line at a turned step. Experienced turners could see the perfect grain match and got the joke, but most people would just assume it was cut apart and re-attached.

The photo stuff does take some time and experimenting. I had a decent photo setup before I moved to a new house, and now have a pretty poor arrangement (and no time to turn or photograph). I have to make that a priority once my new biz is up on its feet and running smoothly.

Excellent first post -- very nice job -- keep 'em coming !

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#9

Re:Bob and Gil- the directions for....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. building a very effective and low budget photo set-up are on my website tips menu at jamiedonaldsonwoodturner.com A white vinyl window shade makes an excellent backdrop that's priced right and also easily stored- just roll it up!

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#10

Bob Moffett

Re:Bob and Gil- the directions for....

Bob Moffett

>Jamie,

Thaks for the plans. I went to your website and downloaded them. By the way, you really have a nice website. Do you do it yourself?

Bob

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#11

Bob Moffett

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Thanks Alan, I use some hollowing tools that I bought from a friend of mine. They are simular to the ones that Al Basham sells. He is a fellow member of the Raleigh, N.C. woodturning club. He sells them off of his website www.albasham.com. They have the arm on them that takes the torque out of them. I don't have any financial interest with him, but he does make good hollowing tools. It got sort of tense doing the final hollowing. I redesigned a couple them into goblets with open tops prior to that one.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#12

Bob Moffett

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Thanks for the kind words Jim. See you at the next meeting.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#13

Bob Moffett

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Thanks, really they aren't that hard to turn with the right hollowing tools. Although I have turned through the sides on a couple of them. Then it can become a goblet. lol

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#14

Bob Moffett

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Thanks I appreciate the kind words.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#15

Bob Moffett

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Brad,

Thanks for the compliment.

Yes it was hollowed in two pieces and then re-joined. It is interesting that you mention Elvie because we are both members of the Raleigh, N.C. woodturning club and I attended an all day break-out session that he did on hollow forms. I put 3 rings at the joint, one for the joint and 2 others above it. I will try some of the detail that you recommend. Thanks for the suggestions. I also attended a 1 day workshop that John Jordan participated in about a month ago in Kanapolis, N.C. about a month ago. He is really a great guy.

Where you mention the raised band, do you have a smooth surface both above it and below it?

Hope you get your new biz up and running soon.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#16

I like it

Jorge Castaneda

>Good work Bob,

For the pictures, even without a set like Jaimie, use just daylight, no direct sunlight, no flash, overcast days are good picture days, and reflectors, like a white cardboard from the art store are good helpers.

good to see your work

thank for showing

Jorge

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#17

Brad Vietje

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Brad Vietje

>Hi Bob,

I was thinking of smooth above and below, yes. On John Jordan's Hollow Turning video, he makes a large "bottle" by cutting off the neck, hollowing through the larger hole, and re-attaching the neck and boring a small hole through it. He disguises the join with a raised band which he carves by hand with a small U-shaped gouge to create a fluted band just above the join. This idea might work well for vases like the one you posted.

Hope to see more of your fine work here again soon.

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#18

Re:Bob - Ken Grunke is a frequent....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. poster here and is my web guru- I don't understand all that technical html code stuff at all!!! I do need to update the photos when I have time to go back to school with Ken and learn how to do it myself.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#19

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

MikefromTn.

>Great looking grain, nice form. You should be proud of your first attempt. Mine wasn't near that pleasing to the eye. Gotta love that walnut. It's one of my favorites to turn. I believe it's the same type I have. Black walnut?

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#20

Re: Bob- you must have in the audience...

Jamie Donaldson

>... way away from the stage where we had to place the lathe. I demoed the square bowls that day. It wasn't much fun not having the audience up close so we could shoot shavings at you!

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#21

Bob Moffett

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

Bob Moffett

>Mike,

That wasn't my first attempt. My first one was a maple one and much smaller and not as good of a shape. My second one turned into a redesign opportunity when I hollowed through to the outside. It became a goblet. Live & learn and keep trying.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#22

Bob Moffett

Re: I like it

Bob Moffett

>Jorge, I have you to thank for encouraging me to post pictures. Thanks.

Re: First Posting - Walnut Vase

#23

Bob Moffett

Re: Bob- you must have in the audience...

Bob Moffett

>Jamie, I remember you. I was on the front row. I was the one that asked you about the video.