Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Which side is up?

Posts

Which side is up?

#1

Which side is up?

GaryG in MD

>This is going to sound like a stupid question.... but maybe not.

I just bought a new, thin parting tool -- the blade is 1/16" x 1-1/4". The shape of the blade has a 45-degree angle on the end (i.e., the business end is shaped like the number "7").

So which side is up? The more I think about it, the less sure I am. I'm guessing thats the real answer is "both" or "either". I'm guessing that it will cut either way, but that the characteristics will be very different.

So which way is safer?

Which way is more controllable?

Which way cuts cleaner?

You get the idea.

What are the tradeoffs?

TIA, Gary

Re: Which side is up?

#2

Re: Which side is up?

Mac

>Long side down......

Re: Which side is up?

#3

Re: Which side is up?

Bill Clark

>I agree, long side down.

Re: Which side is up?

#4

Leo Van Der Loo

I use mine with the long end down.

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: Which side is up?

#5

Re: Which Long End?...

Allen Neighbors

>Long end of the blade? or the "7"? :o)

Re: Which side is up?

#6

Leo Van Der Loo

Long end of the 7 Allen, sorry for not saying so.

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: Which side is up?

#7

OK, I see the drift...

GaryG in MD

>Long-end-down was my feeling, but I wanted to see if anyone has tried it the other way.

I guess it would be pretty aggressive and prone to catching long-end-up, but I was wondering if it might not cut cleaner that way if one were careful to take light cuts?

Thanks for all your comments, and I look forward to more to come.

...Gary

Re: Which side is up?

#8

Re: OK, I see the drift...

Lan Brady

>Gary,

As you experiment with new tools. This question will come up again.

On any tool, imagine that it has an equator running the length of the tool. You should always make the cut with the bottom half of the tool. This will reduce the torque that the wood is placing on the tool.

As with all other turning rules, this one will be broken as well!

Just my opinion, Lan

Re: Which side is up?

#9

Oh yeah....

GaryG in MD

>Thanks for the explanation, Lan. That's why I asked. In retrospect, that was major stupidity on my part -- a 1-1/4" lever arm above the tool rest! No way. That's certainly an accident looking for a place to happen! I can just feel it whacking down onto the rest, and probably getting terminally bent. Duh! I hope I would have figured that out before doing it. Regards, Gary

Re: Which side is up?

#10

Re: Long end of the 7 Allen, sorry for not saying

Allen Neighbors

>I made my own out of an old, Old Hickory Butcher Knife, and put a long handle on it. I've been using it with the long end down, and it's quite catchy. I may try it the other way at least once, just to see how it acts.

Re: Which side is up?

#11

Re: Long end of the 7 Allen, sorry for not saying

Stuart Johnson

>If you do decide to try it with the short end down be sure to use some scrap that won't be missed. For what ever reason I started to part of a finished segmented piece with my thin parting tool and touched the piece with the long end up. It grabbed and punched a hole through the side before I even realized I had the tool upside down.

Re: Which side is up?

#12

Re: Long leg of the 7 , down....

Allen Neighbors

>I should have said. If you look at my parting tool from the tailstock end of the lathe, when I am parting off, you would see the "7".... The long side of the blade is up. I have a short (3/8 - 1/2") bevel on the top of the blade, which makes the horizontal, top leg, of the 7. And the end of the blade slants in, making the vertical, long leg, of the 7.

Is that what you recommend? Or am I backwards?

Re: Which side is up?

#13

Re: Parting tool drawing... sort of.

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Which side is up?

#14

Re: Parting tool drawing... sort of. 

Allen Neighbors

>


img

Re: Which side is up?

#15

Leo Van Der Loo

Yes Allen that's the way I use it, I also have the

Leo Van Der Loo

>end point ground on the corner of the grinding wheel, so there are 2 points, makes for a cleaner cut IMO

Something like the pic. not the same but I think you understand what I mean.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: Which side is up?

#16

Re: Thanks Leo. :)

Allen Neighbors

>My PT is only 1/16" thick, so it'd have to be a file corner to get the groove in the top edge. But I love that idea, so I'll give it a try. Thanks again, Leo.

Re: Which side is up?

#17

Re: Parting tool drawing... sort of.

Stuart Johnson

>This is the PT I mentioned. Using it with the long side up is not the way to go.


img

Re: Which side is up?

#18

Re: Parting tool drawing... sort of.

GaryG in MD

>That's exactly the tool I'm talking about, and from the posts here, and engaging my brain, it quickly became very clear to me that it would be dangerous to use it long-side-up. There is way too much torque if it gets a little crooked on the tool rest. Stuart's photo shows it in the safe long-side-down orientation. Allen -- I'm not sure I'm understanding your posts correctly if you're recommending long-side-up. Leo's original post said "long-side down". Are we all on the same page yet? ...Gary

Re: Which side is up?

#19

Re: Parting tool drawing... sort of.

Allen Neighbors

>Same page, different tools. My tool has a shorter bevel than the one you're using. I made mine from an old butcher knife, took the handle off, ground the blade down to about 3/4" depth, put on a long handle (16"), and ground the end.

It's 1/16" thick, and is relatively catchy... but I am careful to not let it get away from me. I think I'll change the bevel a little bit, and see if that helps.

If I use it with the bevel up, it doesn't part as well as it does the other way.

Re: Which side is up?

#20

Re: Parting tool drawing... sort of. *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

>Take a look at the parting tools offered in Packards catalog page 4. There is another one with a different style. You can see it at the link below.


Firmager 1/16 Parting Tool

Re: Which side is up?

#21

Re: Thanks for that, Stuart.

Allen Neighbors

>Now that I've looked at the parting tool in that link, I know what the problem is with my tool! The point of pressure is above the center of gravity. I'm going to change the end of mine to reflect that longer upper bevel, bringing the pressure to bear lower on the shank. If the cutting tip is at or below the longitudinal center of the shank it will be much easier to handle.

Thanks a lot, Stuart!! :)

Re: Which side is up?

#22

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Thanks for that, Stuart.

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Allen

Allen the normal parting tool end is like this right >, by making them thin the tool might not be strong enough anymore, by increasing the hight of the tool the beam strength is increased, placing all the increase in the lower half is the most advantageous, and having the cutting point above the center does not change the handling or behavior of the tool much if any, however the thinner blade makes it flexible and it will start to cut curved slits, this is especially a problem when using the cutoff tool on face grain where it will follow the grain and also if one corner of the tool is less sharp.

I also use extra thin parting off tools, and also made them from hand hacksaw blades, to keep the grain alignment when making boxes and some other small stuff, they work good.

I'll put a pic. here of one, it's 0.023" thick, and the total length is 8"

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: Which side is up?

#23

Re: Hijack not intentional... :)

Allen Neighbors

>I'm sorry, but it seems like we've hijacked this thread.

Thanks, Leo, for posting this. I understand what you said about the thinner blades. That one looks nice... Like the handle, too.

Mine is an ex-Old Hickory knife, so it doesn't bend... veeerrry stiff.

I always make a double cut when parting most things, to keep the blade from binding in the kerf.

I have a cutoff box to catch the piece when I part off, so I can use both hands to guide the tool.