Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Wood surface speeds

Posts

Wood surface speeds

#1

Wood surface speeds

Troy German

>I just went though this exercise for myself and thought others would find the results interesting. I�m sure this is old hat for many of you.

To calculate the surface speed of your wood the following formulas should work for all practical porpoises [insert picture of practical porpoises here]:

radius (inches) x rpm / 2 = ft/min (That�s radius times half the lathe speed�easy!)

radius (inches) x rpm / 170 = mph (At 1700 rpm, that�s radius times 10.)

radius (cm) x rpm / 1000 = m/sec (That�s metric.)

For example, a 10� turning blank (5� radius or 12.7 cm) at 500 rpm has a surface speed of (5 x 500 / 2) 1250 ft/min, or (5 x 500 / 170) 15 mph, or (12.7 x 500 / 1000) 6.4 m/sec. So, if you run a 10� blank at 500 rpm the tip of your gouge cuts 1250 ft of wood every minute! (I know. The radius gets smaller as you cut which throws off the numbers, but accounting for that involves other variables�and calculus.)

As far as safety is concerned, I would imagine that momentum is more important than speed alone, so weight of the blank would have to come into play. Is this true? Do some of you have guidelines about safe surface speeds?

If I've made a mistake, please speak up.

Enjoy,

Troy

Re: Wood surface speeds

#2

Re: Wood surface speeds

Lan Brady

>Troy,

I used "max dia. x rpm= constant". I wanted constant to be between 6000 and 9000. This is not my original idea, I copied it somewhere, but it worked for me.

Lan

Re: Wood surface speeds

#3

Re: Wood surface speeds

Rick Davenport

>I was just watching Bill Grumbine's second video.

He says lathe speed depends on two things.

(paraphrased badly)

If the lathe ain't shakin' and you ain't shaking in fear, then the speed us just right.

Rick

Re: Wood surface speeds

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wood surface speeds

keith tompkins

>Troy, there really isn't much need for calculations...mount the blank, set your lathe to the lowest speed. If variable speed, just slowly increase speed until the lathe begins to barely shake. then, either lower the speed until the shake is eliminated, or raise it just slightly until the shake stops...that sometimes helps. If no variable speed, and the blank is unbalanced, a faceplate is a good idea, with the tailstock drawn up for support.

Re: Wood surface speeds

#5

Re: Wood surface speeds

Troy German

>This equates to 4 times the ft/min. In other words, your speed range would have been between 1500 and 2250 ft/min. Math is fun!

Thanks,

Troy

Re: Wood surface speeds

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Wood surface speeds

Dick Hines

>Troy lathe speed is sort of like tightening a nut on a bolt. Run it up until is strips and back it off a 1/4 a turn.

I run a blank up until the lathe shakes then back her off a few RPM's.

All that math hurts my head.

Re: Wood surface speeds

#7

Steven Antonucci

Turning speeds are like my boss said when

steve antonucci

>he was pulled over by the police.

"Do you know how fast you were going?"

"As fast as I could, Officer." (Yes, he got the ticket...)

Never set the lathe so fast that it becomes self cleaning is my rule... I once turned the lathe on with a set of cole jaws and forgot to check the belts... 3600RPM. When it landed (after being cleared for take-off), my whole shop was clean (from the wind), but I needed a change of underpants...

I rarely use the upper three speeds on my Nova. Something about the streamers coming off so fast that they bruise...

Steve

Re: Wood surface speeds

#8

Re: Wood surface speeds

Troy German

>Rick,

That sounds like a fun way to think about it. I have no fear of the lathe whatsoever, so I' m not sure that would work for me. I'd be turning at full speed as soon as the block is round.

Thanks for responding,

Troy

Re: Wood surface speeds

#9

Re: Wood surface speeds

Troy German

>Quote: "there really isn't much need for calculations..."

Need! who said anything about need? Calculations are fun!

Actually, the safety comment was an afterthought. The reason I wanted to figure out surface speed was from thinking about the "how much wood does a turning tool cut before it's sharpened" question. Still, I appreciate yout response.

Thanks,

Troy

Re: Wood surface speeds

#10

Re: Turning speeds are like my boss said when

Troy German

>Wow! This might be the only topic woodturners agree on.

Troy

Re: Wood surface speeds

#11

Your question would be difficult to answer.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Even with a turing forum's help you couldn't get a good sample size. Each tree has many things that can take out an edge. there are countless foreign objects, sand or silica, knots, bark inclusions, hard areas due to drought, or wind shake (or is that wind twist). That's just the tree! We haven't even gone into the batch to batch variations (miniscule in some brands) in steel, how close to near death it got in sharpening, jagedness of the finished edge, etc. And...we haven't even touched on the effect of the operator of the cutting tool. It would almost be like solving for Pi.

A better math problem would be how much does the cost of fuel have to come down for me to visit Chico and to help you dispose of your stash of wood?...:-)

Re: Wood surface speeds

#12

Re: Wood surface speeds

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>The equation should start with sfm as a known value, along with diameter or redius, to calculate RPM. If I could remember my high school math, it would be a piece of cake for me to translate but that was almost 40 years ago. Actually, I think I've forgotten just about everything I learned in high school!

Re: Wood surface speeds

#13

Saw blad speed .......

Pete LaBelle

>Did the surface speed calculations the other day on my table saw (10"). If you flipped it upside down and let it pull itself down the road on it's saw blade, it would travel at 102.6 MPH ! !

Useless trivia for the day.

Re: Wood surface speeds

#14

Raffan Table

Bill Howatt

>I have a table that is attributed to Richard Raffan.

He says for a 10" diameter blank the speed should be 1400RPM for a 2" high blank and reduced to 1000 RPM for a 6" blank. A 4" high blank would be 1100RPM so it doesn't appear to be a linear relationship to height.

He also says to use half value for rough turning.

Raffan is obviously considering the diameter, the mass (or perhaps some increased torqueing moment from a taller blank) and the condition/shape of the blank (smooth round or rough).

I have had this table on the wall for a couple of years or more and this is the first time I have looked at it since I put it up. I am in the does it feel safe, is the cut nice, camp.

Bill

Re: Wood surface speeds

#15

Re: Raffan Table

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'm really not concerned with actual surface speed. My Nichols lathe has variable speed, but no means of knowing what RPM's are. I just crank it up to whatever speed I'm comfortable with. I tend to turn at higher speeds than most, I think. Of course my lathe weighs 800 lb. and is solid as a rock.

Wally

Re: Wood surface speeds

#16

My post references to your 2nd question.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>"how much wood does a turning tool cut before it's sharpened"

Re: Wood surface speeds

#17

Re: Wood surface speeds

Fog Tanner

>Using your example, I came up with 1308 fpm (dia x pi (3.14159625) or 14.8 mph. I also keep a calculator by my lathe for these things too.

I use a couple of methods, a gross limit is 9000/diameter in inches. A 10" bowl would have a safe limit of 9000/10 or 900 rpm. This came from Mike Mahoney who got it from Dale Nish. The other thing I use is the table from Raffin's Turning Wood which takes into account the height of the bowl. I look at both these methods as the upper end and work down from there.

I also use the shake test when roughing a bowl, take it up to the point of shake, and then a little higher to see if it smooths out. If it does then I use that speed, if not then back below the point of vibration. I try not to exceed the limits of the wood, my lathe weighs 1000lbs and its not hard to spin a piece of wood past its safe limits. I was at the Turn or Two a few years ago when an English demonstrator exceeded the structural limits of a platter - we never did find all the pieces.

Re: Wood surface speeds

#18

Re: Saw blad speed .......

Bob Fawcett

>Saws usually win the power tool races.

If you've never seen it on cable you missed a good one.

The only one that I remember beating the saw was a fire extinguisher setup like a rocket, but you have to stretch a little to call a fire extinguisher a power tool.

Re: Wood surface speeds

#19

Re: Wood surface speeds

Peter Hyde

>Math who needs it when you have one of these


img

Re: Wood surface speeds

#20

Re: Wood surface speeds

Fog Tanner

>I have three "analog" tacks, but they only go to 30,000. Noticed that yours goes to 99,999, looks like a good unit. Mine are for checking the rpm of the engines on my model raceplanes which idle at around 24,000. The digital ones were always too jumpy on an engine - but they worked great on electric motors. I just had to remember to use a flashlight indoors or they always read 3,600...

And now that you have brought it up, I'll have to get my mechanical tack out and tack my next bowl........just have to remember how to set it to read under 5,000.....

Re: Wood surface speeds

#21

Re: Wood surface speeds

Troy German

>To make the numbers easy to do in my head, I was using pi = 3, and just to be picky I think pi = 3.14159265... not 3.14159625... but pride prevents me from checking to make sure.

Anyway, I like that the English demonstator had the explosion. I suspect he was dementrating some French for a quick moment there.

Have Fun,

Troy

Re: Wood surface speeds

#22

Does this mean your lathe is running?

Troy German

>I can't make any promises, but the next time I'm at my inlaw's I'll try to bring you something.

Take care,

Troy

Re: Wood surface speeds

#23

3.141592653589793238462643383279502884197169399375

Ed Moore

>