Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Posts

Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#1

Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I guess this question can apply to any lathes with a fixed switch at the headstock end. If a piece starts going out of balance on the lathe after I've moved into position at the tail end (as when hollowing a vessel) I'd like a switch at the tailstock end so I don't have to walk across the danger zone. Anyone have a bright idea for this? I'm thinking to glue a strong magnet to a steel surface-mount box, with a 20-amp lightswitch in it, with 12-guage stranded copper wire so I can move it around. Looking for a simple and cheap solution, if possible. Thanks.

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#2

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Ken

I use an air actuated switch, inboard, outboard right where I am, when doing hollow forms, you can have it on the floor and you don't have to let go of your tools to stop or start the lathe.

Also safer as there's only a thin air hose that could get pinched or cut, not a live electrical wire.

I have use mine for at least 8 years, and never had any problems with it, other than pulling the hose out once or twice.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Dick Hines

>When I installed the power for my lathe I took into account that I would be turning from the end of the lathe.

So I installed the power plug at the tail stock end. It may not be as good as a switch but I don't have to walk in front of an out of control piece of wood to turn the lathe off.

One day I may put a remote stitch on my lathe.

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Brad Vietje

>In my previous shop, where I used a 1236 about 6 days/week, I installed a simple wall-mounted switch near the tailstock end that controlled power to the outlet that served the lathe. This costs maybe $10 - $12 for the box and the switch and about 6' of 12-2 wire, if you or a friend can wire it up. If I were thinking a bit more, I'd have gotten a switch and receptacle combo, which would fit in the same box with a different cover, and allow an auxiliary light or power sanding equipment to be plugged in right where it's convenient.

If you don't want to mess with household wiring, you can either buy an in-line switch that the lathe plugs into, or cheaper yet, just get a rugged extension cord and wire a switch into the middle of it. Plug one end into the wall, and plug the lathe into the other end, and you have a switch that can be mounted wherever you like. Old speaker magnets can be had for scrap, and can be screwed onto the back of the switchbox, for easy placement.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#6

Accessory Power Switch

Curly Smith

>I use one of these:

Accessory Power Switch


"This is an economical 20-amp switch, designed for use with scroll saws, sanders, lathes, router tables, or any bench-top tool application. The switch includes a 5-1/2' grounded cord with a 3-pin end and a 3-pin receptacle above the switch. A large paddle switch with removable child protective lock is easy to locate and turn the tool off. The housing is constructed from high impact plastic and the switch�s rear plate is made of heavy gauge steel with mounting tabs at the top and bottom."

$25 from Woodcraft (and others)

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#7

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Well, you all had basically the same solution, some type of inline switch which is what I'm gonna go for. Except for Dick, with the plug-pulling idea--a great idea I'm currently using ;)

But I'd like a foot switch or a paddle to whack with the hand for the quickest result.

I think I have the parts on hand for a shop-built inline switch, that I can use with any power tool. I thank Leo, Brad and Curly for putting the idea in my head!

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#8

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ken,

Should be simple to put a satellite switch in the lathe's 110 circuit, however I don't remember if the 1236's switch is a sealed unit. You should use 12ga stranded for your switchleg, however you should, at least, use a motor-rated switch, not just a heavy light switch. Best, of course, would be a 2-button on/off which will afford you a much higher degree of safety. If you happen to bump a toggle switch or knock it off on the floor, you can turn your lathe off by accident in the middle of a cut with unpretty results.

mm

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#9

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ken,

If what you want is an emergency stop, get a mushroom-style switch, Reid Tool has one (part No. N892) for about $25 with an enclosure and McMaster-Carr has a similar one (part # 6785K71) for about $33. You should NOT use a toggle switch for an e-stop. These are push-to-stop, pull-to-reset switches that you can mount with a glued-on magnet and move when you change positions.

mm

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#10

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

robert davis

>a switch like that on all my lathes..works good

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#11

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

robert davis

>ken i use a DECORA paddle switch with a red plock of wood glued to the off side. regular light switch used for ten years no problem

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#12

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>Be careful using a switch rated for lighting. I made a few nut cooling boxes for a client who roasts them. The coolers use a furnace fan switched with a light switch. My first stop on the way to the shop today is to replace a switch which has fused closed (on).

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#13

Simple solution

GaryG in MD

>Ken,

Another variation on the theme:

See http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org/Tip3.aspx

It's very cheap and very easy.

Regards, Gary

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#14

Nice, But . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>He's using a switch for a purpose far beyond its design limits, and there is a real danger of such a mechanical connection breaking or fusing in the "on" position; especially if he's using the thing as his primary power switch. In addition, I would resist use of such a lever around a lathe as it's too easy for something to hit it by accident, either breaking it off (leaving you without any switch) or disconnecting power and creating a dangerous situation with a work piece.

The power strip is $10, a real, properly designed mushroom "kill" switch unit is $25.00. To me, the extra $15 is more than worth it.

Your mileage may, of course, vary.

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#15

None of the above...

GaryG in MD

>Mark,

With all due respect, I don't understand your objections.

First of all, this configuration has worked perfectly for years. It has never fused or broken off. Electrically, the switch is functioning exactly as it would for anyone using it to turn attached equipment on and off, as many people do, and only one of the many plugs is being used. Physically, for one thing, that's the reason for the rubber tubing extension going beyond the metal rod -- it provides a cushioning effect to reduce the force at the glue joint (which has shown no signs of damage after extensive use).

Functionally, perhaps it's not clear that this switch is in series with the actual lathe power switch (the lathe is plugged into the power strip which is in turn plugged into the outlet. Both switches have to be 'on' for the lathe to be on. Turning either switch off disables the lathe. That's safe, particularly, as recommended in the link, if the lathe power switch is then also turned off. Geometrically, in an emergency, I find that a flick of the right wrist, with tool in hand, is a lot quicker and easier than trying to deal with mashing a button with a tool in your hand.

Just my opinions. As you say, YMMV. ...Gary

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#16

Reasons

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Gary,

I use power strips as extension cords too. I don't use them as switches for what's plugged into them because the internal switch componants built into these things in the Chinese factories, while I'd like to thjink they must meet minimum standards, are not made for continual use as on-off switches interrupting 12 amps on a regular basis. Given the wide range of quality of these cheap strips, I simply would not recommend their use to others who, unaware of the issues, might go out, buy a "$4 special" thinking "they're all the same," and get hurt when the el cheapo thing shorted, fused, or failed. I'm all for being innovative and saving a buck, but when it comes to safety items, I don't look for cheap or new. I want safeguards to be heavy duty and tested to be stupid-proof. |;-}}

I understand that your unit has worked okay for you. But I note from your write up that the user needs to "practice" using it because it may "bounce back" [to "on" I assume}. That's just not good design for an emergency switch. When something's 'going south' on a woodworking machine, the operator doesn't have time for gentle pushes. That kill switch has to be set to be hit HARD and once. That's why such switches are designed as they are. My stubby has a satellite on/off switch, however the separate mushroom emergency kill switch is located at knee height so I can literally kick the lathe off if I have to.

BTW I'm all for moveable remote switches on lathes. In fact, I think all of them should have their main switches as pendants for safety reasons. If I still had my 1236, I would replace the factory switch with a remote magnet-mount unit; the advantage of moving the switch as you change positions at the lathe is just so obvious for a turner, and the $25-30 cost is minimal. Ed Larson's rewiring of his 1236 is a very good example, and eliminates the real need for a pure kill switch.

Again, if it's working for you, that's fine. You obviously put some time and effort into your rig, and I certainly applaud your effort. It's just that if emergency lathe safety is the goal, there are better solutions out there, and the difference in cost in quite small.

Peace

mm

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#17

Yup

GaryG in MD

>Mark,

Well said. I cannot disagree with anything you said.

I know a lot of people who turn their computer systems (many plugs) on and off by the strip switch, and I'm not aware of any failures, but I have to admit that my experience is somewhat dated -- prior to the influx of such units of unknown quality from China. I agree that we can't really know what quality we have purchased without finding out the hard way.

On the other hand, I use the one I have all the time and have had no indication of any problem. You can usually hear arcing as a little 'pop' when they're not working right. You may know more about them than I do, but I'm not sure why possible fusing of the contacts is a specific concern to you. It seems to me that being turned on and off, with a load attached, is what they're supposed to do. Maybe I'm just naive. Have you had, or are you aware of, a specific failure? Or are we just talking second-order saftey concerns?

I've never had a bounce back either -- I just put that in there as an added safety thought. That's actually the reason for the extended rubber tube -- I designed around what I perceived as a potential problem. You're completely correct, however, that a more positive and permanent state change is desirable. I guess I've traded that off for speed. I think a knee switch or foot switch is a good idea, but I'm not sure how practical they are given the many body locations and positions one takes around the lathe without even thinking about it. Isn't that a bit awkward and constraining?

Anyway, as I say, your concerns are real and appreciated. Safety first! Thinking ahead for dealing with that 3-sigma event is what it's all about.

Regards, Gary

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#18

Re: Yup

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hi Gary,

I, in fact, had one "melt" on me. Had a Halogen work light and two 18v battery chargers running at the time. No fire [TG], just fused and shorted the switch; house breaker for that circuit kicked everything off.

These strip things are, as you point out, often used for computer stations and things that rarely pull more than 400 watts total on a strip. Good surge-supression strips for electronics ($20-$40) are almost always limited to 15 amp max loads. The motor on your lathe may pull 8-10 amps (more when you lean into a heavy cut), but the motor's start capaciter can pull up to 20 amps when you hit that switch, especially with a heave blank mounted. That's a lot of juice to ask wiring designed for less to handle, and it has to take that start phase shot every time you turn on the lathe. Take a strip apart sometime and measure the guage of the wiring and componants to see if you're comfortable using it for heavy loads.

I view this stuff like my computer's hard drive. It's not a question of "if" it will fail, but rather "when" and how bad will the damage be when it does. [Yeah, I back up every day on removable media] If you're at all like me, the lathe switch gets a LOT of use. I therefore want control units built for a lot of wear and tear. In any case, I'm scared of electricity, been zapped several times, and view it as a coiled monster ready to strike without warning. I therefore will not give the beast any chance to take another whack at me.

While my lathe's mushroom kill-switch is at knee-height at the tail end, I've only used it once in the 5 years I've had the lathe because the satellite on/off is always stuck near my right elbow. I do, however have my table saw set up with a shop-made kick-off switch that is used every time. In fact, I'm always uncomfortable using a saw without one because I have to let loose of the board to turn the saw off. I will confess, however, that years ago I set up my router table with a pair of motor-rated 3-way toggle switches, and have just never gotten around to changing them out for better. |;-{

I've seen foot switches used on lathes, but personally I'd shy away from them as I don't want to have to be hunting around under the shavings for it in time of need. A "dead-man" type foot pedal would not be good for me as I move around too much when turning. Works well on the flex-shaft, however.

Want to thank you for posting this because I sold my 1236 to a very good friend, and this has reminded me that I told him I'd help him set up a satellite switch unit for it!

|;-}}

Mark

Re: Jet 1236 switch at tailstock end?

#19

Thanks

GaryG in MD

>All very good info, Mark -- quite interesting and informative.

I appreciate your viewpoints. I've learned some things and enjoyed our discussion. Thanks a lot.

(That reminds me, it's time to back up my computer!) ;-)

Cheers, Gary