Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Senseless tragedy

Posts

Re: Senseless tragedy

#26

Re: This is a sick world....

Bill Crommett

>O.K. Let me expand on this. Before Columbine happened, the school people noted some devient behavior by one of the perpetratos, but were reticent to report any thing to higher authority because of the fear of litigation. This has been called "legal blackmail"

Second: We have on several occasions seen where an expert opinion by mental health professionals has been overruled by a judge who has taken the position of following "case law" or what is known as res judicata where courts are reticent to NOT follow a previous courts opinion --right or wrong. We all know that Judges are not chosen for their brillience, but rather appointed or elected for their political leaning or political involvement. And we also know that legislators are not elected for their concern for the well being of society beyond their own constituents whom they rely on to get re-elected -- thus the budget restraints and the Pork Barrel going for votes rather than for societal needs. More Questions ?

Re: Senseless tragedy

#27

Somebody is probably...

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>already working on a screen play.

Gary

Re: Senseless tragedy

#28

Re: Senseless tragedy *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Read these accounts of the previous campus shooting I was talking about, and then do a google search on this shooters name, and almost all of the accounts will just say that other students tackled him.

Mark


http://www.keepandbeararms.com/information/XcIBViewItem.asp?ID=3117

Re: Senseless tragedy

#29

Re: Senseless tragedy

Atwerz

>Bill thats the way I look at it too. You would fit in real well here in West Texas. Since my first child was born I've had nightmares that one would suffer like the young people killed and wounded tooday. All three daughters are trained and own hand guns for defensive reasons.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#30

Re: Senseless tragedy

Carole Valentine

>Thank goodness Amanda is OK, Mark. Thanks for letting us know. And you are so very right about telling the ones you love that you love them every day because it could be their last.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#31

Re: Senseless tragedy

Barry Turner

>Ever notice how the perpetrators often kill themselves after one of these horrific events? Nickle Mines, Columbine, and now this one. I can only assume they are basically spineless cowards who are not stand-up enough to face the punishment that they so richly deserve. If my beliefs are correct, the Virginia Tech shooter should be in a pretty hot place by now. How could one man inflict so much suffering on so many innocent people and their families in such a short time?

Re: Senseless tragedy

#32

Re: Very, Very Sad.

Barry Turner

>It's been going on for centuries in the Middle East...........

Re: Senseless tragedy

#33

Re: Senseless tragedy

Jim Swank

>It goes beyond carrying a gun. It also has to do with opportunity and will - the opportunity to use a gun or other means, and the will to put your own life on the line to oppose evil instead of putting survival first. Without that, a gun is no use. With it, a gun is only one means to an end. The passengers on that hijacked flight didn't have guns, but they had the will and seized the opportunity.

None of us were there, and none of us know for sure what we'd have done if we had been. I might well have been the first one out the window, though I'd like to think otherwise.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#34

Jesper, Denmark

You shock me, Bill.......

Jesper, Denmark

>Are you really suggesting to arm the student body?

Is SWAT training going to be a requirement for admission?

With 11,000 armed students on Campus, how many minor disputes are then going to be settled by gunfire?

When and how do we decide to turn the other cheek or take an eye for an eye in a lawful society?

You cannot fight violence with more violence.

Jesper

Re: Senseless tragedy

#35

Leo Van Der Loo

What else do you propose to do when a lunatic

Leo Van Der Loo

>starts shooting at you and your children ?

Take away all the guns from the law abiding citizen ??, don't think for a moment you can take them away from the other ones.

We have seen the results here in Canada, did you notice it to ?? or disregard it.

Leo

Re: Senseless tragedy

#36

Jesper, Denmark

Addendum........

Jesper, Denmark

>More than 30,000 people die from gunshot wounds in the United States every year and there are more guns in private hands than in any other country.

Source: Reuters

Sort of the same number as in Iraq?

Re: Senseless tragedy

#37

Dick Hines

Re: Senseless tragedy

Dick Hines

>Bill, guns are barred from the Va Tech. I guess this guy did not get the word.

It's like DC. Guns are barred there too but how many shooting do they have there in a day?

Re: Senseless tragedy

#38

Re: You shock me, Bill.......

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Jesper

It has been a while since I have seen you post. But I think you may have some misconceptions about my perspective and philosophy. I am not saying every single person should be armed. I am saying they should have the freedom to choose whether or not they are armed. In those areas of our society where anyone might be armed, these sorts of things rarely, if every happen. But the school, along with almost every other school in our nation proudly proclaims itself a gun free zone. They might as well put out a big sign saying "Please come and hurt us. We are unprotected." There are already reports in the news that the perpetrator avoided campus police on his way from one side of campus to the other. Why do you think he did that? It wasn't because they would speak sternly to him, it was because they were armed. Schools are natural targets because the cowards who commit these crimes are afraid of people who have the means at hand to defend themselves, whether those means are guns or knives or custom turned shillelaghs.

Many people have raised the argument that arming a society would result in bloodbath after bloodbath. One of the most recent examples of this was when Florida made concealed carry of weapons a lot easier to obtain. Unfortunately for the naysayers, and fortunately for the rest of us, that has not proved to be the case. In FL as in every other state of the Union, one is much more likely to be killed by an errant driver. Children die in drowning accidents at 10 times the rate of children with guns. Here in PA, statistics report that people possess concealed carry permits at a ratio of 1:20. You don't see any bloodbaths going on around here, except where there are prohibitions against guns.

Then there is the argument that no one knows what a person is capable of doing, if they will be able to pull the trigger and kill their fellow man. This is a valid argument, but a weak one. There is a huge record from early on in our history of men, women, and children stepping up and doing what needed to be done to protect themselves from danger, whether that danger be from man or beast. On the flip side, while we can never be sure how a person will react when their life is in danger when they do have the means to protect themselves, we already know the outcome when they don't have those means.

It is exceedingly obvious from this event and others that gun free zones do not work. If they did, this guy would not have shot up the campus. They only prevent law abiding people from protecting themselves. More laws will not change a thing except to resrtict law abiding people even further. It is already against the law to shoot people. That law didn't work too well either, did it?

Anti gun laws are going to have the same effect that drug laws already have - i.e. none at all. If bad people want something bad enough, they are going to get it. To suggest that writing more laws, removing more guns from society, is a utopian dream. It is not going to happen. Remember the raging success of Prohibition?

Secondly, we see over and over again the lack of ability in our police forces to be where they need to be when they need to be. This is not an indictment of the police at all - far from it. But dedication and enthusiasm are not enough. By the nature of our society, the police are always going to have a response time. Anything longer than right now is too long. This guy planned this thing. Don't you think he had the foresight to avoid armed authority? I answered that one above. It has already been pointed out to me off line that we don't know if someone would have had the time to produce their own weapon and respond to this person. That might be arguable, but if we take that assumption, we already know the best response time of police is going to be woefully longer. And while this person committed a horrific act, he is not, was not, some sort of superman. He was a human being pumped up on adrenaline and who knows what else, but he couldn't keep an eye on every single person at the same time. If someone else had been armed, I think it would be been very likely that his shooting spree would have ended much sooner. Even is someone just shot back without hitting him, results might have been different. We call that suppressing fire here.

Personally, I have owned guns since I was 12 years old. I have been in many fights growing up, and many confrontations as an adult, and I have never shot anyone, although I had the opportunity many times. It is an issue of self control that millions of Americans exercise every day as they carry their own means of protection. These statistics don't make news though, because they do not support the agenda of those who convey the news to us.

Bill

Re: Senseless tragedy

#39

Jesper, Denmark

I am still shocked, but.....

Jesper, Denmark

>Further discussion on this subject does not belong in this forum.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#40

Ellis Walentine

Re: Senseless tragedy

Ellis Walentine

>Good morning, folks. I needed to chime in here and let you know why we have removed Bill Grumbine's subthread which linked the tragedy in Virginia to opinions on gun ownership. Bill and I have been friends for a long time and I respect his views as I respect all thoughtful opinions. I have spoken with Bill directly about the need to remove this subthread, and he said he sort-of expected it.

I know that the respondents on this thread were making a heartfelt outcry about all the dead students and their grieving families, and that is an understandable and humanitarian response to such a grievous situation. I feel as deeply about this as you do.

The position that WoodCentral is going to take is to let these innocent children be buried, let their families begin to try to come to terms with what has happened, and let the rest of us observe what has happened with simple decorum and quiet respect for the dead and their families. Expressions of sadness or bewilderment or outrage are expected, but this is not the forum to debate gun control, however relevant we think it may be to the issue.

Thanks for understanding.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Senseless tragedy

#41

Jesper, Denmark

Dear Ellis..

Jesper, Denmark

>The neutral - and right thing - would have been to erase the complete thread.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#42

Re: Dear Ellis..

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Jesper,

I understand your feelings, but the fact remains that when you're playing in someone else's yard, you have to go by their rules. This is Ellis' back yard, and I haven't played in many where things were dealt with so even-handedly.

I personally feel that Ellis has gone beyond the necessary to allow everyone who wants to express their outrage at such an unbelievable occurance. I concur with his decision regarding the subsequent discussion on guns.

Gary

Re: Senseless tragedy

#43

Agreed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>

Re: Senseless tragedy

#44

Re: Right on, Bill!

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Senseless tragedy

#45

Re: Senseless tragedy

Lan Brady

>Ellis,

Thank you for providing a place for us to learn, brag and vent frustrations. As long as you pay the bill, it is your site to control. I think you were a real gentleman to contact Bill to discuss your decision.

Keep up the good work, Lan

Re: Senseless tragedy

#46

Re: Senseless tragedy

MikefromTn.

>Fellow woodworkers and friends of WC..As a newcomer to this forum I have come to know some of you by name, if not by some pics of your work. And as this is a forum, we all open ourselves up for opinions, suggestions, ridicule, and praise...For our work with wood.Several quotes about opinions and personal politics come to mind but I don't want to stir the pot any more than it's already been stired. Don't misunderstand me, we all greive in our own way, and this truely is a tragedy, but arguing and dissing the goverment with fellow woodworkers on a woodworking forum is not only assinine it's rude.This site has the highest caliber of craftsmen on the net, and the collective sorrow for these people involved can be felt.Don't insult me or them by turning it into a moral or political debate. I respectively Thank you all.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#47

Re: What else do you propose to do when a lunatic

ben d.

>And in Australia where murders and crime in general has increased since the goverment bought all the guns.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#48

Ellis Walentine

It was a tough decision, Jesper

Ellis Walentine

>Carole's original post was a heartfelt expression of sympathy and dismay. It is fitting for friends and comrades in woodturning to grieve together and try to find meaning or any redeeming lessons from such a senseless tragedy. We can't be all turning all the time. Friends and communities need this deeper level of interaction, and I felt it ws well within bounds, although I knew right away that it was a potential hot potato.

Where we have strenuously drawn the line is at issues political, religious and defamatory, where nothing is to be gained and a lot of mutual respect is to be lost. The gun issue is a hugely fractious political and societal battle in the United States and it is clearly an incendiary tangent -- if a natural one -- to the turning forum. I felt there was no way I could let it stand, but I consulted with the other moderators and spoke personally with Bill before I nixed the subthread. We try to be as reasonable and even-handed as possible in such matters, and I'm satisfied with our decision.

I've received numerous e-mails expressing appreciation for the way it was handled. I'd like to count you among those who support my decision, but I realize I can't please everyone all the time. Sorry about that.

Best regards,

Ellis

Re: Senseless tragedy

#49

Re: Another example of why...

Jamie Donaldson

>...friends and family should not discuss politics or religion, and gun control falls into both categories.

Re: Senseless tragedy

#50

Re: Very, Very Sad.

Don O.

>Barry, of course you're right. It's actually been going on all around the world forever. My post was deliberately non-specific to emphasize the ignorance of violence.

My heart aches with sadness for the families and students at VT and elsewhere in the world.